NextGen Business Associations · 24-Minute Integrated Question Set
Integrated Set 1: Counseling & Drafting — Birchwood Solar Works, Inc.
Read the client intake facts below and complete all five mixed-form counseling and drafting questions.
Fact Pattern
Six months ago, three engineers—Nora Morales, Owen Brooks, and Priya Nair—agreed to form Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. in the town of Birchwood to design commercial rooftop solar mounting brackets. One week before articles of incorporation were filed, Nora (acting as promoter) signed a two-year commercial warehouse lease with Harbor Realty LLC in the name of "Birchwood Solar Works, Inc., a corporation to be formed." The lease contained no clause releasing Nora upon incorporation and no clause limiting Harbor Realty LLC's recourse solely to the corporation. Compliant articles of incorporation were filed one week later, naming Nora, Owen, and Priya as the three-member board of directors. At its organizational meeting, the board passed a resolution expressly adopting the warehouse lease, and the corporation moved in and paid rent for four months.
At incorporation, Nora held 35 percent of the common stock, Owen held 30 percent, Priya held 20 percent, and Nora's late aunt, Helena Reed, held 15 percent. Two months ago, Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. had $18,000 in its checking account, though it also held an untapped $150,000 bank line of credit and $95,000 in collectible customer receivables. While attending a regional clean-energy conference on company business, Owen was approached by a municipal transit authority seeking a vendor to supply solar carport brackets—a product directly within Birchwood Solar Works, Inc.'s core line of business. Owen never mentioned the inquiry to Nora, Priya, or Helena. Instead, Owen privately formed a separate company, Solstice Brackets LLC, and took the municipal contract for Solstice Brackets LLC.
Around the same time, Nora arranged for Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. to purchase $90,000 of custom mounting bolts—roughly 25 percent above fair market price—from Birchwood Fasteners Corp., a company secretly 100 percent owned by Nora. Nora never disclosed her ownership of Birchwood Fasteners Corp. to Owen, Priya, or Helena when the board approved the bolt contract.
Three weeks ago, Helena Reed died, leaving all of her 15 percent stock in Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. to her nephew, Marcus Reed, by will. Shortly afterward, Marcus discovered both Owen's municipal solar carport contract and Nora's undisclosed ownership of Birchwood Fasteners Corp. Priya, the third director, is completely disinterested and had no prior knowledge of or involvement in either transaction.
Marcus comes to your law office seeking advice on: (1) who is bound on the warehouse lease; (2) Owen's defense that the company lacked cash for the municipal contract; (3) Marcus's standing and pre-suit demand requirements; (4) whether Marcus can recover 15 percent of the damages directly and how the bolt contract will be reviewed; and (5) drafting a written demand letter under the Model Business Corporation Act and a derivative complaint standing allegation.
Checked: 0 of 3 · Score: 0 / 3
Question 1 of 5Select One of Four
Counseling — Pre-Incorporation Promoter Liability and Corporate Adoption
During the client intake meeting, Marcus asks whether Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. is legally bound on the pre-incorporation warehouse lease with Harbor Realty LLC, and whether the board's formal resolution adopting the lease released Nora from personal liability to Harbor Realty LLC. Which statement gives Marcus the MOST accurate legal advice? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Restatement (Third) of Agency section 4.04 comment c, a corporation not yet in existence when a contract is signed lacks capacity to ratify the contract retroactively; instead, the newly formed corporation becomes bound only when it adopts the contract expressly (by board resolution) or impliedly (by knowingly accepting benefits). However, under Restatement (Third) of Agency section 6.04 (and Model Business Corporation Act section 2.04 when a promoter signs knowing incorporation has not yet occurred), corporate adoption binds the corporation without releasing the promoter. Nora remains personally liable alongside Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. unless Harbor Realty LLC expressly agreed to a sole-recourse disclaimer at signing or entered a subsequent novation releasing Nora.
Question 2 of 5Select Two of Six
Counseling — Corporate Opportunity Doctrine (Delaware Versus American Law Institute Approach)
Marcus tells you that Owen plans to defend taking the municipal solar carport contract by arguing that Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. had only $18,000 in its checking account at the time (despite holding an untapped $150,000 bank line of credit and $95,000 in receivables) and that Owen had no duty to present the contract to the board first. Which TWO legal points should you explain to Marcus? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Delaware law (Guth v. Loft, Inc. and Broz v. Cellular Information Systems, Inc.), courts weigh four factors—including whether the corporation is financially able to exploit the opportunity—and formal board presentation is a protective safe harbor rather than an absolute prerequisite when the corporation is genuinely financially unable to take the deal. Even under Delaware law, however, mere low checking-account cash does not establish financial incapacity when the corporation can finance the deal through an untapped $150,000 bank line of credit and strong receivables. By contrast, under the American Law Institute Principles of Corporate Governance section 5.05 (followed in cases such as Northeast Harbor Golf Club, Inc. v. Harris and Klinicki v. Lundgren), a director or senior executive must first present the opportunity to the board and wait for a disinterested rejection, and cannot raise financial inability as a defense after failing to disclose it. Model Business Corporation Act section 8.70(b) expressly states that failing to use its safe harbor creates no inference of usurpation, and routing a usurped opportunity through a separate LLC does not shield Owen.
Question 3 of 5Select One of Four
Counseling — Derivative Standing, Demand Futility, and Universal Demand
Marcus is worried that because Marcus inherited his 15 percent stock from Helena Reed after the bolt contract and the municipal contract occurred, Marcus lacks standing to sue, and asks whether Marcus can skip making a pre-suit demand on the board by arguing that both Nora and Owen (two of the three directors) committed undisclosed self-dealing. Which legal advice is MOST accurate? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Model Business Corporation Act section 7.41(1) and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23.1(b)(1), a derivative plaintiff satisfies the contemporaneous-ownership requirement either by owning shares at the time of the wrong or by acquiring shares afterward by operation of law (such as inheritance by will) from a contemporaneous owner, so Marcus has standing. On pre-suit demand, Model Business Corporation Act section 7.42 mandates universal written demand and a 90-day waiting period unless (1) the corporation earlier notifies the shareholder that demand has been rejected, or (2) waiting 90 days would cause irreparable injury to the corporation. In a Delaware demand-futility jurisdiction under United Food and Commercial Workers Union v. Zuckerberg, futility is evaluated claim-by-claim and director-by-director, requiring at least half of the board (two of three directors) to be disabled on each specific claim. Because only Nora is conflicted on the bolt contract and only Owen is conflicted on the municipal contract—with Priya and the other director disinterested and unaware on each separate claim—unrelated undisclosed conflicts cannot be aggregated, so demand is not excused on either claim.
Question 4 of 5Short Written Response
Counseling — Direct Versus Derivative Suits and Conflicting-Interest Remedies
Marcus asks whether Marcus can bring a direct individual lawsuit against Nora and Owen so that Marcus personally receives 15 percent of any money recovered, and also asks how a court will review Nora's undisclosed $90,000 bolt contract with Birchwood Fasteners Corp. Draft a concise four-to-five sentence counseling explanation advising Marcus on both questions.
Model Response
You cannot bring a direct individual lawsuit to collect 15 percent of the recovery personally, because under the Tooley test both claims belong to Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. rather than to you individually. Overpaying for mounting bolts and diverting a corporate business opportunity harmed the corporation directly and affected you only indirectly as a shareholder, so those claims must be brought derivatively with any damages paid to the corporation. On the merits of the $90,000 bolt contract, Nora breached the fiduciary duty of loyalty by failing to disclose her 100 percent ownership of Birchwood Fasteners Corp. Because the transaction was neither disclosed to nor cleansed by disinterested directors or disinterested shareholders, the contract is voidable unless Nora proves it was entirely fair in both process and price—a burden Nora is unlikely to meet given the secret dealing and the 25 percent price markup above fair market value.
Key Points
Applies the Tooley direct-versus-derivative framework (who suffered the harm and who receives the recovery) to explain that both the overpriced bolt contract and the usurped municipal contract injured the corporation directly and Marcus only indirectly.
Concludes that the claims must be brought derivatively and any monetary recovery goes to Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. rather than 15 percent directly to Marcus.
Identifies Nora's undisclosed 100 percent ownership of Birchwood Fasteners Corp. as an uncleansed conflicting-interest transaction breaching the duty of loyalty.
Explains that without informed disinterested director or shareholder cleansing, the bolt contract is voidable unless Nora proves entire fairness in both process and price (which fails given the nondisclosure and 25 percent above-market price).
Explanation
Under Tooley v. Donaldson, Lufkin and Jenrette, Inc., distinguishing a direct suit from a derivative suit depends on (1) who suffered the alleged harm (the corporation or the suing shareholder individually) and (2) who would receive the benefit of any recovery or remedy. Overpaying by 25 percent on the $90,000 bolt contract and diverting the municipal solar carport opportunity harmed Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. directly (and harmed Marcus only indirectly through a drop in share value), so both claims are derivative and any recovery belongs to the corporation rather than 15 percent to Marcus personally. As to the bolt contract, Nora engaged in a classic undisclosed conflicting-interest transaction by failing to disclose her 100 percent ownership of Birchwood Fasteners Corp., so the contract was never cleansed by informed disinterested directors or disinterested shareholders and is voidable by the corporation unless Nora proves the transaction was entirely fair in both process and price—which Nora cannot do given the 25 percent markup over fair market price.
Question 5 of 5Short Written Response
Drafting — Model Business Corporation Act Demand Letter and Derivative Standing Allegation
Assuming Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. is incorporated in a Model Business Corporation Act jurisdiction, draft: (a) two to three sentences for a formal written pre-suit demand letter to the board of directors demanding action on the Birchwood Fasteners Corp. contract and stating the section 7.42 waiting rule and exceptions; and (b) two sentences for a derivative complaint (if the board rejects demand) pleading Marcus's standing by operation of law and why the claim is derivative.
Model Response
(a) Pre-Suit Demand Letter Excerpt: Pursuant to Model Business Corporation Act section 7.42, Shareholder Marcus Reed hereby demands that the Board of Directors of Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. immediately investigate and take suitable action—including rescinding the contract or recovering overcharges and disgorgement—regarding Director Nora Morales's undisclosed self-dealing $90,000 bolt contract with Birchwood Fasteners Corp. Under section 7.42, Mr. Reed will refrain from commencing a derivative proceeding for 90 days from the date of this written demand to allow the corporation to act, unless the Board notifies Mr. Reed earlier that this demand has been rejected or irreparable injury to the corporation would result from waiting for the 90-day period to expire.
(b) Derivative Complaint Allegation: Plaintiff Marcus Reed brings this action derivatively on behalf of Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. to recover corporate overcharges and fiduciary-breach remedies belonging solely to the corporation rather than to any individual shareholder. Plaintiff satisfies the contemporaneous-ownership requirement of Model Business Corporation Act section 7.41(1) because Plaintiff acquired his 15 percent common shares by operation of law under the will of Helena Reed, who continuously held those shares at the time of the challenged transaction.
Key Points
Demand letter clearly identifies Nora Morales's undisclosed $90,000 Birchwood Fasteners Corp. self-dealing contract and demands corporate corrective action.
Demand letter states the Model Business Corporation Act section 7.42 90-day waiting period and both statutory exceptions (earlier rejection or irreparable corporate injury).
Derivative complaint allegation pleads that the action seeks recovery on behalf of Birchwood Solar Works, Inc. for corporate injury.
Derivative complaint allegation pleads Marcus's contemporaneous-ownership standing via transfer by operation of law (inheritance by will from Helena Reed) under section 7.41(1).
Explanation
Under Model Business Corporation Act section 7.42, a formal written demand must clearly identify the challenged transaction and request that the board take suitable corrective action (such as rescinding or recovering the overcharge from Nora and Birchwood Fasteners Corp.), while noting that under section 7.42 the shareholder will wait 90 days before filing a derivative suit unless the board rejects the demand earlier or irreparable injury to the corporation would result from waiting. If demand is rejected, the derivative complaint must plead under section 7.41(1) that Marcus acquired his 15 percent shares by operation of law (inheritance under Helena Reed's will) from a contemporaneous shareholder who held the shares at the time of the transaction, and that the suit seeks recovery on behalf of the corporation for corporate injury.