Written for study. Not legal advice.

Written Assignment

You are an associate at a Linden law firm representing Havenwood Tile Works LLC (“Havenwood”) and its managers, Maya Alverez and Benji Sato. Read the three Case File documents and the supplied State of Linden Library below, then draft an objective internal memorandum answering the questions posed in Partner David Okafor’s Task Memorandum.

Task Instructions

Write a structured objective memorandum addressing: (1) whether Havenwood is bound to KilnCraft Supply Corp. on the $18,500 kiln purchase order signed by Nolan Park under Linden Code §§ 31-205 and 31-212; (2) whether Nolan Park is entitled to an immediate cash buyout or may maintain a direct lawsuit against Maya Alverez and Benji Sato under Linden Code §§ 31-218 and 31-224; and (3) whether KilnCraft Supply Corp. can pierce Havenwood’s limited liability company veil to hold Maya Alverez personally liable under Linden Code § 31-209. Apply only the supplied State of Linden law in the Library.

Part 1: Case File

Document 1 of 3 · Law Office Memorandum

Task Memorandum

To: Associate
From: David Okafor, Partner
Re: Havenwood Tile Works LLC — Post-Dissociation Claims and Veil-Piercing Exposure (File No. LB-218)
Date: November 12

Our clients, Havenwood Tile Works LLC (“Havenwood”), a custom ceramic tile studio in Cedarbrook, State of Linden, and its two managers, Maya Alverez and Benji Sato, face three legal disputes following the departure of former member Nolan Park and a demand letter from vendor KilnCraft Supply Corp. (“KilnCraft”).

Maya and Benji want an objective internal memorandum evaluating Havenwood’s and Maya’s legal exposure before our client strategy call next week. Please organize your memorandum into clear headings covering three issues:

  1. Whether Havenwood is bound to pay KilnCraft $18,500 for an electric kiln ordered by Nolan Park after Nolan dissociated from Havenwood, applying Linden Code §§ 31-205 and 31-212;
  2. Whether Nolan Park can compel Havenwood to pay an immediate cash buyout of Nolan’s one-third interest, and whether Nolan can bring a direct individual lawsuit against Maya and Benji over a lost hotel bid and withheld September distribution under Linden Code §§ 31-218 and 31-224; and
  3. Whether KilnCraft can pierce Havenwood’s limited liability company veil to hold Maya Alverez personally liable for Havenwood’s undisputed $6,200 May glaze balance (or any other obligation) under Linden Code § 31-209.

Ground every legal conclusion in the attached client interview summary, operating agreement excerpts, bookkeeper’s note, and our State of Linden Library.

Document 2 of 3 · Client Interview Summary

Interview with Maya Alverez and Benji Sato (Havenwood Managers)

Three years ago, Maya Alverez, Benji Sato, and Nolan Park formed Havenwood Tile Works LLC in Cedarbrook, State of Linden. They filed articles of organization with the Linden Secretary of State listing only Havenwood’s name, principal street address, and registered agent; the articles said nothing about managers. At the same time, all three members signed a written Operating Agreement expressly establishing a 10-year term and designating Maya Alverez and Benji Sato as sole managers. Havenwood never filed a Statement of Authority with the Linden Secretary of State.

During Havenwood’s first two years, Nolan handled studio maintenance and occasionally placed small glaze supply orders between $500 and $1,500 with KilnCraft Supply Corp. after getting Maya’s verbal approval for each order. Early in Year 2, Maya emailed KilnCraft’s sales manager: “Nolan Park is authorized to place routine supply orders up to $2,000 for our Cedarbrook studio; please check directly with me for anything larger.”

On June 1 of Year 3, Nolan handed Maya and Benji a signed letter stating: “I am withdrawing and dissociating from Havenwood effective immediately to open my own solo ceramics workshop.” Havenwood filed a formal Statement of Dissociation with the Linden Secretary of State on June 10, but Maya forgot to email or mail direct notice of Nolan’s departure to KilnCraft.

On August 20 (71 days after the June 10 filing), Nolan walked into KilnCraft’s showroom wearing an old Havenwood studio jacket and signed an $18,500 purchase order for a new industrial electric kiln in Havenwood’s name (“Havenwood Tile Works LLC, by Nolan Park”). Nolan directed KilnCraft to send the $18,500 invoice to Havenwood and deliver the kiln to a storefront across town where Nolan was opening his solo studio. Without contacting Maya or Benji, KilnCraft’s sales manager shipped the kiln to Nolan’s new studio address and later billed Havenwood $18,500, along with an undisputed $6,200 unpaid balance for ceramic glazes Maya had ordered in May.

Meanwhile, Nolan’s lawyer sent a letter demanding an immediate cash buyout of Nolan’s one-third ownership interest and threatening to sue Maya and Benji directly in Nolan’s own name for two complaints: first, that Maya and Benji negligently missed a deadline in May and lost a lucrative hotel lobby tile bid (which allegedly reduced the value of every member’s LLC interest); and second, that Maya and Benji refused to pay Nolan a cash profit distribution in September.

Finally, because studio sales slowed over the late summer, Havenwood currently has only $2,400 in its business checking account. KilnCraft’s attorney has threatened to pierce Havenwood’s LLC veil to collect the $6,200 undisputed balance (and the $18,500 kiln order if enforceable) from Maya personally. KilnCraft’s letter points out that Havenwood never held formal annual member meetings or kept minute books, and notes a $450 check drawn on Havenwood’s business account in April to pay Maya’s personal residential electric bill.

Document 3 of 3 · Operating Agreement & Accounting Record

Havenwood Operating Agreement Excerpts & Bookkeeper’s Note

Excerpts of Havenwood Tile Works LLC Operating Agreement (signed Year 1 by Maya Alverez, Benji Sato, and Nolan Park):

Section 3 (Manager-Managed Governance): The Company shall be manager-managed solely by Maya Alverez and Benji Sato, who hold exclusive authority to enter contracts and manage the ordinary business of the Company. Non-managing members have no authority to bind the Company.

Section 8 (Term and Wrongful Dissociation): The Company is formed for a definite term of ten (10) years ending in Year 10. A member who voluntarily withdraws before expiration of Year 10 commits wrongful dissociation. If the remaining members continue the business, any buyout payment to a wrongfully dissociating member is deferred until expiration of the 10-year term, offset by any damages caused by the wrongful dissociation.

Section 9 (Pre-Dissolution Distributions): Pre-dissolution cash distributions shall be declared solely in the good-faith discretion of the Managers when the Company’s cash reserves exceed $25,000.

Bookkeeper’s Accounting Note (dated November 8, signed by Independent Bookkeeper):

“Reviewed Havenwood’s financial ledgers from Year 1 through November of Year 3. At formation, the members contributed $60,000 in initial cash capital and $35,000 in tile presses and kiln equipment, and Havenwood has continuously maintained $1,000,000 in commercial liability insurance. Havenwood keeps a separate business bank account and double-entry books. On April 4, Maya inadvertently wrote a $450 company check to pay Maya’s home electric bill using the wrong checkbook; upon catching the error, Maya deposited $450 of Maya’s personal funds back into Havenwood’s account on April 7 with a clear ledger memo (‘Reimbursement for April 4 personal utility check error’). No other personal expense has ever been paid from company funds. As of September 1 and today, Havenwood’s cash reserve is $2,400, well below Section 9’s $25,000 distribution threshold.”

Part 2: Library — Law of the State of Linden

Task Law Notice: The statutes and cases below are invented law written solely for this State of Linden performance task. Apply only these authorities in your memorandum; do not treat them as real-world law.

Library Authority 1 · Task Statute

Linden Limited Liability Company Act, Linden Code §§ 31-205, 31-209, 31-212, 31-218, and 31-224

§ 31-205 (Manager-Managed Election and Agency Power):

  • (a) A limited liability company is member-managed by default unless its operating agreement expressly provides that the company is manager-managed.
  • (b) A member is not an agent of a limited liability company solely by reason of being a member. A limited liability company is bound only by actual authority, common-law apparent authority, or a Statement of Authority filed under section 31-206.

§ 31-209 (Limited Liability and Formalities):

  • (a) The debts, obligations, and other liabilities of a limited liability company are solely the liabilities of the company. A member or manager is not personally liable for a company liability solely by reason of acting as a member or manager.
  • (b) The failure of a limited liability company to observe formalities relating to the exercise of its powers or management of its activities, such as holding annual meetings or keeping minute books, is not a ground for imposing personal liability on the members or managers for the company’s liabilities.

§ 31-212 (Post-Dissociation Authority and Statement of Dissociation):

  • (a) After dissociation, a dissociated member’s act binds the limited liability company only if the act would have bound the company before dissociation under section 31-205(b) and, at the time of the transaction, the third party (1) reasonably believed the dissociated member still held authority and (2) did not have notice of the dissociation.
  • (b) A Statement of Dissociation filed with the Linden Secretary of State gives third parties constructive notice of the member’s dissociation 90 days after the filing date.

§ 31-218 (Wrongful Dissociation and Buyout Timing):

  • (a) A member’s voluntary dissociation before the expiration of a definite term specified in the operating agreement is wrongful, and the wrongfully dissociating member is liable to the company and the other members for damages caused by the dissociation.
  • (b) A dissociated member has no statutory right to an immediate cash buyout upon dissociation; buyout timing, valuation, and deferral for wrongful dissociation are governed by the operating agreement.

§ 31-224 (Member Direct Versus Derivative Actions):

  • (a) A member may maintain a direct action against another member, a manager, or the limited liability company to enforce the member’s rights and otherwise protect the member’s interests only if the member pleads and proves an actual or threatened injury that is not solely the result of an injury suffered or threatened to be suffered by the limited liability company.
  • (b) A member may maintain a derivative action to enforce a right of a limited liability company only if the member first makes a written demand on the managers requesting that they cause the company to bring an action and waits a reasonable time, unless demand would be futile.

Library Authority 2 · Linden Supreme Court (Task Case)

Alderwood Glass Co. v. Mercer

Issue: Whether a limited liability company was bound under Linden Code § 31-212(a) where its manager had previously notified a supplier by email that a representative held authority to place routine orders “up to $2,000, and check with me for anything larger,” the representative dissociated and the company filed a Statement of Dissociation 75 days before the disputed order, and the representative then signed a $15,000 purchase order for delivery to an unfamiliar off-site warehouse without the supplier contacting the manager.

Holding: Even though the 90-day constructive-notice window under Linden Code § 31-212(b) had not yet expired at 75 days, the limited liability company was not bound under section 31-212(a). Section 31-212(a) requires both that the act would have bound the company before dissociation under section 31-205(b) and that the third party reasonably believed the dissociated member still had authority. Because the manager had explicitly notified the supplier of a $2,000 cap, the supplier could not reasonably believe the representative held authority to sign a $15,000 order without checking with the manager—particularly when an unfamiliar off-site delivery address created an obvious red flag.

Library Authority 3 · Linden Appellate Decisions (Task Cases)

Brookside Metals LLC v. Chen & Riverstone Hauling Co. v. Vance

Brookside Metals LLC v. Chen (Linden Court of Appeals): A dissociated member threatened to sue the limited liability company’s managers directly, claiming the managers negligently lost a lucrative customer bid (reducing the value of all members’ ownership interests) and improperly refused to issue a September cash distribution. The Court of Appeals held: (1) a claim that managers negligently lost a company business contract and lowered membership value asserts an injury suffered directly by the limited liability company and only indirectly by its members, so it may not be brought as a direct action under Linden Code § 31-224(a) and must instead proceed as a derivative action complying with section 31-224(b); and (2) a member’s claim challenging a withheld discretionary distribution fails where the operating agreement conditions distributions on cash reserves exceeding a stated dollar threshold and the company’s reserves are below that threshold.

Riverstone Hauling Co. v. Vance (Linden Supreme Court): A trade creditor sought to pierce a limited liability company’s veil to hold a managing member personally liable for an unpaid invoice. The Supreme Court held that piercing the limited liability company veil in Linden requires proving both: (1) such unity of interest and ownership that the company had no separate legal existence (shown by pervasive commingling of personal and company funds, siphoning of assets, or gross undercapitalization at formation); and (2) that preserving the limited liability shield would sanction fraud or promote injustice. Applying Linden Code § 31-209(b), the Court held that failing to hold formal meetings or keep minute books cannot support veil piercing, an isolated bookkeeping error promptly reimbursed within days with a clear ledger entry does not prove pervasive commingling, and a subsequent revenue slowdown does not establish gross undercapitalization at formation when the company launched with substantial initial cash, equipment, and commercial insurance. Furthermore, courts are especially reluctant to pierce the veil for voluntary contract creditors who had the opportunity to check the company’s credit before extending credit.

Practice Scratchpad (Optional)

Use this box to outline or draft your State of Linden memorandum before revealing the model answer. Text typed here stays in your browser tab only and is not saved or transmitted.