Archetypes and Trigger-Fact Types
Fact-pattern shapes seen in Professional Responsibility, with our original trigger-fact descriptions and the issues each shape raises. Sitting links open Issue Spotter.
a fee the client did not truly agree to
4 essaysTrigger-fact types- gifts to the person who sends the clients
- a business tie with a nonlawyer
- another lawyer's threat that must be reported
- a fee taken from the recovery the client cannot audit
- a release traded for giving part of the fee back
- a fee split arranged before the client agrees
- the case settles before the client sees the new terms
- a deposit kept while the lawyer quits
- a second lawyer with a tie to the opponent
Issues triggered
a sexual or business tie with the client
3 essaysTrigger-fact types- they are intimate and the case is outside her experience
- he believes a half-price deal covers the recovery too
- she misses a hearing and holds the award in trust
- a relative who pays and demands to be told everything
- the lawyer then goes into business with the client
- in-house counsel and a sexual relationship at the company
- a conviction the lawyer does not report
- a filing prepared by a tool and not checked
Issues triggered
a paid expert and a gift for the referral
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a letter to doctors offers to take their patients
- the lawyer advances an expert's hourly fee
- he offers testimony he cannot say is true
- a gift certificate thanks the referring doctor
Issues triggered
a family home pledged for one spouse's lawyer and a crash
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a drunk spouse injures a pedestrian
- the only asset is the family home
- his lawyer takes a lien on that home
Issues triggered
a former manager's lunch and an unapproved settlement
1 essayTrigger-fact types- he asks a former manager about talks with opposing counsel
- the client lies at her deposition and he stays quiet
- he accepts a settlement the same day and tells her later
Issues triggered
a secret fee split and a hotel for a witness
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a secret referral keeps one-third of another lawyer's fee
- a gift certificate asks a journalist for coverage
- a witness is offered a hotel to testify truthfully
Issues triggered
a withheld forensic report and a call to the judge
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a press release treats the accused as guilty
- a forensic report is withheld because she will not use it
- she calls the trial judge without the defense
Issues triggered
a lawyer trades ahead of a client's bid
1 essayTrigger-fact types- she ignores a plan to skip a deposition with a fake note
- she buys shares ahead of the client's tender offer
- the client sues her and the firm
Issues triggered
a lawyer sells the company to his wife's firm
1 essayTrigger-fact types- salary is paid in shares below par
- counsel negotiates a sale to his wife's company
- his own company then joins the buyer in a venture
Issues triggered
a lawyer who hopes his own client's case fails
1 essayTrigger-fact types- he agrees to attack a housing law he supports
- he privately hopes the client will lose
- the president plans another false filing with an agency
Issues triggered
a withdrawal, a personal tie, and lost proof
1 essayTrigger-fact types- the client will not answer, then begs to stay
- opposing counsel is a former intimate
- the proof garment is cleaned with the lawyer's own clothes
Issues triggered
interview notes split into fact and opinion
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a memo of what a witness said and what the lawyer thought
- a demand to turn that memo over
Issues triggered
a hidden defect plus a lawyer's extra facts
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a seller says a roof has been fine despite a maker's warning
- a lawyer adds facts the record does not contain
Issues triggered
one lawyer for two co-defendants
1 essayTrigger-fact types- one lawyer for two friends charged together
- a fee demanded after the court removes the lawyer
Issues triggered
a disbarred lawyer still working the case
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a disbarred lawyer rehired as a clerk
- that clerk drafts questions and sits at the deposition
Issues triggered
orders from a partner and an offer from the opponent
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a supervisor says to withhold a damaging paper
- a job offer from the firm on the other side
Issues triggered
who the client is, and a secret from the board
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a new entity with a very small board
- an employee who wants a secret kept from that board
Issues triggered
the other lawyer is a former intimate
1 essayTrigger-fact types- opposing counsel is a former intimate
- a client wants a private affair used as leverage
Issues triggered
a shared office and a family-member receptionist
1 essayTrigger-fact types- lawyers who share space but not a firm
- a family member on staff who sees a key paper
Issues triggered
a confession, physical proof, and a withdrawal
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a client admits the killing and hands over stained clothes
- the lawyer gives the clothes and the alibi notes to the state
Issues triggered
a leak of a client's matter
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a third party learns of a client's suit
- the lawyer tells the client to stay quiet
Issues triggered
misconduct inside the client, and who may be told
1 essayTrigger-fact types- an employee brings proof of misconduct upstairs
- a boss says to bury it and the lawyer tells the state
Issues triggered
a gift, paid witnesses, and a closing opinion
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a gift of tickets if the lawyer wins
- payments to witnesses and a closing that adds the lawyer's own view
Issues triggered
a forced trial strategy and a buried report
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a lawyer who will not let the client take the offered plea
- a report the prosecutor keeps after the plea
- a plea taken with little questioning, then a maximum sentence
Issues triggered
a former business and a lawyer with a bar history
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a lawyer who used to broker the same kind of deal
- a lawyer on the other side who was disbarred elsewhere
Issues triggered
a lawyer's forms business with a nonlawyer
1 performance testforms-venture-ethics• Sittings: Feb 2012 (PT A)• Call: specific• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a lawyer plans a forms business with a nonlawyer
- a receptionist would give legal help by phone
- they would split the revenue
Issues triggered
a malpractice suit by someone who was not the client
1 performance testnonclient-deed-malpractice• Sittings: Jul 2012 (PT B)• Call: open• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a beneficiary sues the lawyer who drafted a family deed
- the other side says a nonclient has no claim
- the draft opposes that demurrer
Issues triggered
a lawyer holding stock while the seller tries to revoke
1 performance testlawyer-holds-the-shares• Sittings: Feb 2015 (PT A)• Call: specific• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a deal lawyer is holding the stock certificates
- the seller wants them back and calls him the escrow
- the firm must choose among closing, waiting, or interpleader
Issues triggered
a short trust account and a late client payment
1 performance testtrust-account-shortfall• Sittings: Feb 2016 (PT A)• Call: specific• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a client says settlement money was kept too long
- the trust balance fell short for several weeks
- the memo tests four proposed discipline charges
Issues triggered
discipline hearing limited to moral turpitude
1 performance testconviction-moral-turpitude• Sittings: Jul 2018 (PT 1)• Call: specific• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a lawyer pleads to a crime and the bar seeks disbarment
- the hearing is limited to moral turpitude, not the penalty
Issues triggered
prosecutor contact with a represented accused
1 performance testprosecutor-no-contact• Sittings: Feb 2022 (PT 1)• Call: specific• California-only (1/1)
Trigger-fact types- a prosecutor talks to a charged person whose lawyer is absent
- a supervisor's advice is offered as a shield
Issues triggered
California-Only Flags
Professional Responsibility is a 100% California-only subject on the California Bar Exam (30 of 30 essays, 6 of 6 PTs).
California-only issues tested in this subject:
Flagged administrations: Feb 2012 Q5, Jul 2012 Q2, Feb 2013 Q2, Jul 2013 Q1, Feb 2014 Q1, Jul 2014 Q3, Jul 2015 Q5, Feb 2016 Q3, Jul 2016 Q6, Feb 2017 Q5, Jul 2017 Q2, Feb 2018 Q1, Jul 2018 Q3, Feb 2019 Q5, Jul 2019 Q4, Feb 2020 Q2, Oct 2020 Q1, Feb 2021 Q4, Jul 2021 Q2, Feb 2022 Q4, Jul 2022 Q3, Feb 2023 Q4, Jul 2023 Q3, Feb 2024 Q3, Jul 2024 Q3, Feb 2025 Q5, Feb 2025 (Retest) Q4, Jul 2025 Q5, Feb 2026 Q3, Jul 2026 Q1, Feb 2012 PT A, Jul 2012 PT B, Feb 2015 PT A, Feb 2016 PT A, Jul 2018 PT 1, Feb 2022 PT 1.