Archetypes and Trigger-Fact Types
Fact-pattern shapes seen in Evidence, with our original trigger-fact descriptions and the issues each shape raises. Sitting links open Issue Spotter.
other acts and impeachment under the state rule
3 essaysTrigger-fact types- a co-defendant's notes offered at trial
- an old felony offered to impeach
- a privilege claim the court rejects
- other acts offered to show the accused is a thief
- a witness's old convictions offered to impeach
- character proof and an old arrest paper
- six objection points under state evidence rules and the constitution
Issues triggered
a crash witness's notes and a passenger's report
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a calm passenger reports the car that hit them
- notes of an apology are offered as a photocopy
- the offer to pay medical bills is in those notes
Issues triggered
a spouse, a neighbor, and a coffee-shop gesture
1 essayTrigger-fact types- the court calls a spouse who refuses to answer
- a neighbor hears a confession through an open window
- a friend sees a throat-cutting gesture at a cafe
Issues triggered
hangar talk, a college lie, and a maintenance log
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a mechanic's hangar talk is offered through a witness
- the witness lied about college on an application
- a maintenance log is offered as a business record
Issues triggered
a workplace email, a silence, and a dead speaker
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a workplace email calls a fired employee a thief
- a supervisor describes silence after an accusation
- the other voice in the quarrel is dead
- the call uses the state evidence code
Issues triggered
three out-of-court statements from one crash
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a form filled at intake offered for its truth
- excited words at the scene of a crash
- a later remark about paying the bills
Issues triggered
interview notes split into fact and opinion
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a memo of what a witness said and what the lawyer thought
- a demand to turn that memo over
Issues triggered
a distress call and a computer printout
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a call for help minutes after a beating
- a printout offered to show when a file was made
Issues triggered
a cross-border collapse, proof fights, and jurisdiction
1 essayTrigger-fact types- damage that crosses a state line
- an expert's opinion and a party's own reply
Issues triggered
objection practice on testimony and a report
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a manager's answers on the stand
- an insurer's report offered as an exhibit
Issues triggered
a confession, physical proof, and a withdrawal
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a client admits the killing and hands over stained clothes
- the lawyer gives the clothes and the alibi notes to the state
Issues triggered
a photocopy and a stack of expert proof
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a copy of an ad offered as the original
- an expert, a learned text, and the expert's own article
Issues triggered
an identification and three exhibits
1 essayTrigger-fact types- a photo array shown to a witness
- a prior statement, a signed photo, and machine records
Issues triggered
which parts of a battering expert's preview may be heard
1 performance testrecant-expert-battery• Sittings: Jul 2013 (PT B)• Call: open• General law
Trigger-fact types- the complaining witness now says the injury was an accident
- an expert would explain why recanting is common
- the memo sorts which parts of that preview come in
Issues triggered
which out-of-court words come in at a civil-rights trial
1 performance testcourthouse-arrest-hearsay• Sittings: Feb 2014 (PT B)• Call: open• General law
Trigger-fact types- a civil-rights plaintiff faces a motion to exclude words
- the fight is which out-of-court statements are hearsay
- the memo maps the arguments before the reply is written
Issues triggered
a motion to keep out a call and a witness interview
1 performance testconfrontation-call-and-interview• Sittings: Feb 2015 (PT B)• Call: specific• General law
Trigger-fact types- the defense moves to keep out a 911 call
- it also moves to keep out a dead witness's interview
- the draft argues both hearsay and confrontation
Issues triggered
prior acts for the case in chief and for impeachment
1 performance testother-acts-substantive-and-impeach• Sittings: Jul 2019 (PT 1)• Call: specific• General law
Trigger-fact types- older incidents offered to rebut an innocent explanation
- the same incidents offered if the accused testifies
Issues triggered
hand copy of texts offered as the originals
1 performance testoriginal-documents-texts• Sittings: Feb 2026 (PT 1)• Call: open• General law
Trigger-fact types- a handwritten copy of texts is offered to show a drug plan
- the defense says the original messages are required
Issues triggered
California-Only Flags
10 of 15 Evidence essays (67%) and 0 of 5 PTs carry the california_only flag, either from a California-specific issue code or a crossover with a California-only subject.
California-only issues tested in this subject:
Flagged administrations: Jul 2012 Q3, Feb 2016 Q5, Jul 2017 Q2, Jul 2018 Q2, Feb 2020 Q4, Feb 2021 Q1, Feb 2022 Q4, Feb 2024 Q4, Feb 2025 (Retest) Q1, Jul 2026 Q5.