Written for study. Not legal advice.

Part I: Case File

Document 1: Assigning Memorandum

To: Associate

From: Samuel Park, Partner, Park & Alvarez LLP (Oakridge, Linden)

Date: November 14, Year 9

Re: Nadia Bennett — Trust/Will Redrafting & Motion for Surcharge Against Trustee Thomas Bennett

We represent Nadia Bennett on two related matters in Oakridge, Linden. First, Nadia wants to sign a new revocable living trust and pour-over will, and she brought us four clauses produced by an online form template (Document 3) that conflict with Linden law and her actual estate goals (Document 2). Second, Nadia is an adult beneficiary of her late father's Year 2 irrevocable trust (the Bennett Memorial Trust), where her uncle, Thomas Bennett, serves as sole trustee. We have moved for summary judgment seeking disgorgement/surcharge and removal of Thomas based on two undisputed transactions (Document 4).

Please complete two drafting tasks:

  1. Part A (Instrument Redrafting): Redraft Clauses 1 through 4 of Nadia's draft estate-planning documents so they comply with Linden Code §§ 32-511, 32-513, 32-517, 32-608, 33-411, 33-412, 33-502, and 33-503, avoid common-law Rule Against Perpetuities invalidation, and accomplish Nadia's lawful objectives (Document 2). After each replacement clause, add a concise 1–2 sentence drafter's note explaining what legal defect in the template draft was corrected.
  2. Part B (Persuasive Brief Section): Draft the Argument section of Nadia's Motion for Summary Judgment / Petition for Surcharge and Removal against Trustee Thomas Bennett under Linden Code §§ 33-706, 33-802, 33-902, 33-1001–1002, and In re Trust of Halvorsen.

Document 2: Client Planning & Litigation Instruction Note (Nadia Bennett)

Client: Nadia Bennett | Date: November 12, Year 9

  • Spendthrift & Trust Flexibility: Nadia wants her trust (after her death) to include the strongest legally permitted spendthrift protection for her nephew Owen—including expressly making the spendthrift clause a "material purpose" so beneficiaries cannot terminate the trust early—while respecting mandatory statutory exceptions and judicial modification rules so a court does not strike the clause.
  • Personal Property List & Pour-Over Will: Nadia wants the flexibility to write and update a signed list after executing her will to leave family heirlooms (jewelry, artwork, and furniture—not cash, stocks, or real estate) to friends, and she wants her pour-over will to follow any future written amendments to her revocable trust without re-executing her will.
  • Owen's Sub-Trust & Power of Appointment: Nadia wants Owen's trust share held for Owen's life, then distributed to Owen's children when they reach age 25, but protected by a perpetuities savings clause so it never fails under common-law Rule Against Perpetuities rules. She also wants Owen to hold a testamentary power of appointment limited strictly to Owen's children (excluding Owen, his estate, his spouse, and his creditors), exercisable only if Owen expressly refers to the power in his will.
  • No-Contest Clause: Nadia wants a strong no-contest clause discouraging frivolous challenges, while remaining legally valid.
  • Uncle Thomas's Breaches (Bennett Memorial Trust): Nadia confirmed she never consented to—and was never told about—Thomas selling the trust's Oakridge apartment parcel to his wife's company or investing $210,000 of the trust's $300,000 cash in one risky biotech startup.

Document 3: Online Template Draft Clauses (Defective Excerpts)

Draft Clause 1 (Spendthrift & Modification): "No beneficiary's interest may be reached by any creditor whatsoever, expressly barring all claims for child support, spousal support, trust-protection services, and state or federal taxes. No court may ever modify any administrative or dispositive term of this trust even upon unanticipated circumstances. This clause makes no mention of whether spendthrift protection is a material purpose."

Draft Clause 2 (Pour-Over Will & Property List): "I leave my residuary probate estate to the Trustee of the Nadia Bennett Trust, to be governed solely by the trust terms existing today; any later trust amendment shall be void unless re-signed with two will witnesses. In addition, I direct my Executor to distribute any cash, brokerage stocks, jewelry, and my Maplewood cabin listed in any future unattested memorandum I may write."

Draft Clause 3 (Remainder & Power of Appointment): "Upon my death, Owen's share shall be held for Owen for life, then distributed to Owen's children who reach age 25 (with no perpetuities savings limit). Owen shall have a testamentary power to appoint the principal to any person or entity he chooses, including his estate, spouse, or creditors, which may be exercised automatically by any general residuary clause in his will."

Draft Clause 4 (No-Contest Clause): "Any beneficiary who files any probate or trust action—even with probable cause, to seek judicial construction of an ambiguous term, or to challenge a trustee's self-dealing—shall automatically forfeit all benefits under this trust."

Document 4: Undisputed Record — Bennett Memorial Trust Summary Judgment Facts

  • Trust Terms: Created in Year 2 by Nadia's late father (now irrevocable); names Uncle Thomas Bennett as sole trustee for Nadia and her brother as beneficiaries. Contains no authorization for trustee self-dealing or non-diversified venture investing.
  • Transaction 1 (Oakridge Apartment Sale): In June Year 8, without notifying or obtaining consent from Nadia or her brother, Thomas sold a trust-owned Oakridge apartment building to Crestline Holdings LLC—a company owned 100% by Thomas's wife, Miriam Bennett—for $400,000 (an independent appraisal's fair market value at the time). Six months later, Crestline Holdings LLC resold the building for $485,000, netting an $85,000 profit. In his opposition brief, Thomas admits the sale to his wife's company without beneficiary notice or consent, but argues "the trust suffered no harm because Crestline paid full appraised fair market value in good faith."
  • Transaction 2 (Speculative Biotech Startup): In August Year 8, Thomas invested $210,000 (70%) of the trust's entire $300,000 liquid cash reserve into a single unproved, closely held biotech startup, without seeking professional investment advice or diversifying across asset classes. In March Year 9, the startup filed for bankruptcy and lost $140,000 of the trust's principal.

Part II: Library — Law of the State of Linden (Supplied for This Task)

Notice: The statutes and appellate decision below are the controlling law of the invented jurisdiction of Linden, modeled on the Uniform Probate Code, Uniform Trust Code, Uniform Prudent Investor Act, and majority United States rules, and supplied solely for this performance task.

Linden Code § 32-511 & § 32-513 (Pour-Over Wills & Tangible Personal Property Lists)

§ 32-511 (UTATA): A will may validly devise property to the trustee of a trust identified in the will, even if the trust is amendable or revocable and even if the trust is amended after execution of the will; the devised property is administered under the trust's terms as amended at the testator's death without re-executing the will.

§ 32-513: A will may refer to a written statement or list to dispose of items of tangible personal property not otherwise specifically disposed of by the will, other than money (and excluding intangibles such as stocks and real property). To be admissible, the writing must be signed by the testator or in the testator's handwriting and must describe the items and devisees with reasonable certainty; it may be prepared or altered after execution of the will.

Linden Code § 32-517 (No-Contest Clauses)

A provision in a will or trust purporting to penalize an interested person for contesting the instrument or instituting proceedings relating to the estate or trust is unenforceable if probable cause exists for instituting proceedings, and public policy bars enforcing forfeiture against good-faith petitions seeking construction or challenging fiduciary self-dealing.

Linden Code § 33-411, § 33-412, § 33-502 & § 33-503 (Spendthrift Validity, Material Purpose & Deviation)

§ 33-502(a)–(b): A spendthrift provision is valid only if it restrains both voluntary and involuntary transfer of a beneficiary's interest; restraining only involuntary creditor attachment or only voluntary assignment renders the spendthrift provision invalid rather than implying the other. A term providing that a beneficiary's interest is held subject to a "spendthrift trust," or words of similar import, is sufficient to restrain both voluntary and involuntary transfer.

§ 33-503(b): A spendthrift provision is unenforceable against: (1) a beneficiary's child, spouse, or former spouse who has a judgment or court order for support or maintenance; (2) a judgment creditor who has provided services for the protection of a beneficiary's interest in the trust; and (3) a claim of the State of Linden or the United States to the extent a statute or federal law so provides.

§ 33-411(c): A spendthrift provision is not presumed to constitute a material purpose blocking beneficiary termination unless the trust instrument expressly states that spendthrift protection is a material purpose.

§ 33-412(a): A court may modify the administrative or dispositive terms of a trust or terminate the trust if, because of circumstances not anticipated by the settlor, modification or termination will further the purposes of the trust. A trust term purporting to strip the court of statutory equitable-deviation authority is ineffective.

Linden Code § 32-608 & Common-Law Perpetuities Rule

§ 32-608: A nongeneral (special) power of appointment restricts appointees to the specified class (excluding the donee, the donee's estate, and creditors). If the creating instrument expressly requires specific reference to the power, a general residuary clause never exercises it.

Common-Law RAP: Common-law RAP runs from the testator's death for wills, from when the power to revoke terminates (usually the settlor's death) for revocable trusts, and from creation/delivery for irrevocable inter vivos trusts. Unless saved by a valid perpetuities savings clause naming appropriate measuring lives in being (including any living beneficiary such as Owen whose children form the open class), terminating any unvested interest within 21 years after the last surviving measuring life's death (or reducing an age contingency to 21 if needed), and providing an express gift-over directing outright distribution of any remaining principal upon cutoff, an open class gift to a living person's children conditioned on reaching age 25 violates the common-law Rule Against Perpetuities under the all-or-nothing rule.

Linden Code §§ 33-706, 33-802, 33-902, 33-1001, 33-1002 & 33-1012 (Fiduciary Duties & Remedies)

§ 33-802(b)–(c) (Duty of Loyalty): A trustee shall administer the trust solely in the interests of the beneficiaries. Under § 33-802(b), a sale or transaction involving trust property entered into by the trustee for the trustee's own personal account (direct self-dealing) is irrebuttably voidable under the no-further-inquiry rule regardless of good faith or fair price, unless authorized by the trust, approved by the court, or consented to or ratified by the beneficiaries. Under § 33-802(c), a transaction with the trustee's spouse or an entity in which the trustee's spouse has an interest that might affect the trustee's best judgment is rebuttably presumed to be affected by a conflict of interest, which the trustee may overcome only by proving the transaction was unaffected by the conflict. Under §§ 33-802(b) and 33-1012(a)–(b), (e), equitable rescission and in-specie recovery of trust property are cut off once the property is acquired by a third-party bona fide purchaser for value without notice (BFP).

§ 33-902 (Uniform Prudent Investor Act): A trustee shall invest and manage trust assets as a prudent investor would, considering the purposes, terms, and total portfolio risk and return, and shall diversify the investments of the trust unless the trustee reasonably determines that, because of special circumstances, the purposes of the trust are better served without diversifying.

§§ 33-706, 33-1001, 33-1002 (Remedies & Removal): A trustee who commits a breach of trust is liable for the greater of the amount required to restore the value of the trust property and distributions to what they would have been had the breach not occurred, or the profit the trustee (or related party) made by reason of the breach. When resale to a third-party BFP cuts off rescission, beneficiaries remain entitled to monetary surcharge or disgorgement of profits against the trustee. The court may also remove the trustee for a serious breach of trust and deny or reduce trustee compensation.

In re Trust of Halvorsen, 20 Linden 175 (Linden Sup. Ct.)

Under Linden Code § 33-802(c) (unlike traditional common law, which applies strict irrebuttable no-further-inquiry to spousal sales as well), a trustee's unconsented sale of trust property to a company owned by the trustee's spouse without court approval or trust authorization triggers a rebuttable presumption of conflict. Bare proof of subjective good faith and payment of an independent appraisal's fair market value—without prior disclosure, independent arm's-length safeguards, and affirmative proof that the sale was unaffected by the spousal conflict, particularly where the spouse's entity resells soon after at a substantial profit—fails as a matter of law to rebut § 33-802(c)'s presumption. Beneficiaries may elect rescission while the property remains with the spouse's entity or a non-BFP transferee, but once the property is resold to an innocent third-party BFP, §§ 33-802(b) and 33-1012(a)–(b), (e) cut off in-specie rescission and confine beneficiaries to monetary disgorgement of the resale profit against the trustee under § 33-1002. Likewise, concentrating 70% of a trust's liquid reserves in a single speculative venture without special trust authorization violates § 33-902's diversification mandate as a matter of law, supporting summary judgment for surcharge of the principal loss, removal of the trustee, and fee forfeiture.

Part III: Written Assignment (60 Minutes)

Complete both drafting components: