Part I: Case File
Document 1: Assigning Memorandum
To: Associate
From: Elena Ortiz, Senior Partner, Ortiz & Lin LLP (Cedarville, Linden)
Date: November 13, Year 12
Re: Rachel Sato — Client Counseling Letter on Elective Share, Estate Debts, Sub-Trust & Counsel Contact
I met this morning with Rachel Sato, whose husband Kenji Sato died three weeks ago in Cedarville. Kenji's adult son from a prior marriage, Leo Sato, has retained attorney Marcus Grant, who just sent Rachel a 48-hour $50,000 settlement ultimatum. Please draft a client counseling letter to Rachel answering each of her four questions in plain, reassuring English (explaining any legal terms simply), showing exact dollar estimates, evaluating practical risks, and recommending immediate next steps:
- Given Kenji's $20,000 will gift and his $600,000 in nonprobate transfers to Leo and Mei, how much can Rachel recover through Linden's elective share and family allowance, and does Rachel's own $120,000 savings/IRA reduce her recovery?
- Will Kenji's $100,000 hospital bill wipe out Rachel's family allowance or force Rachel to pay out of pocket, and can the hospital reach Kenji's revocable trust and POD bank account?
- If Rachel and Leo reach a broader settlement, can Rachel and Leo simply sign a paper terminating the $200,000 sub-trust for Kenji's 10-year-old granddaughter, Mei, to cash it out early?
- Should Rachel sign Marcus Grant's $50,000 waiver before Friday's 48-hour deadline, and may our firm call Leo directly to negotiate a fair deal without going through Mr. Grant?
Document 2: Client Intake Note (Rachel Sato)
Date: November 13, Year 12 | Client: Rachel Sato (Cedarville, Linden)
- Marriage & Family: Rachel (age 56) and Kenji Sato married on October 10, Year 0, and remained married for exactly 12 full years until Kenji's death on October 22, Year 12. They have no children together. Kenji has one adult son from a prior marriage, Leo Sato, and Leo has a 10-year-old daughter, Mei Sato. Rachel and Kenji never signed a premarital or postmarital agreement.
- Rachel's Own Assets: Rachel holds $120,000 in total personal assets ($85,000 in her sole IRA and $35,000 in her sole checking account).
- Kenji's Estate Plan: Two years before his death, Kenji put most of his wealth into nonprobate transfers: (a) a revocable living trust holding $500,000 in brokerage assets, and (b) a Payable-on-Death (POD) bank account of $100,000 naming Leo as sole POD beneficiary. Kenji's will leaves only "$20,000 to my wife Rachel" and the probate residue to Leo.
- The Sub-Trust for Mei: Under Kenji's trust (which became irrevocable at his death), $300,000 passes outright to Leo, and the remaining $200,000 stays in an irrevocable spendthrift sub-trust paying income for Mei's education and distributing principal to Mei only when Mei reaches age 25 (or to Leo if Mei dies before age 25).
- Rachel's Questions: Rachel is worried that Kenji's $100,000 final hospital bill will consume the entire $100,000 probate estate, leaving her nothing from the will and jeopardizing her statutory rights (and wonders if she must pay out of pocket, though she never co-signed or guaranteed Kenji's hospital admission contract). She also wonders whether Leo's lawyer's $50,000 offer is a good deal, whether she and Leo could dissolve Mei's sub-trust as part of a family agreement, and whether we can call Leo directly since Leo has always been reasonable on the phone.
Document 3: Email from Marcus Grant, Esq. to Rachel Sato (November 12, Year 12)
From: Marcus Grant, Esq. (Grant & Bell PC) | To: Rachel Sato
Dear Ms. Sato: I represent Leo Sato, both individually and as successor trustee of the Kenji Sato Revocable Trust, in all estate and trust matters. As you know, the probate estate has only $100,000 and the hospital has filed a $100,000 claim, which leaves nothing under the will and means your own $120,000 savings will block most statutory claims anyway. As a courtesy, Leo is willing to pay you $50,000 cash if you sign and return the attached Waiver of Elective Share and Allowances by 5:00 p.m. Friday (48 hours from now). After Friday, this offer is withdrawn.
Document 4: Estate & Nonprobate Asset Inventory Summary
- Kenji's Gross Probate Estate: $100,000 (sole-name checking and vehicle).
- Enforceable Creditor Claim: $100,000 unpaid hospital bill (validly presented).
- Kenji's Revocable Trust (at death): $500,000 brokerage account ($300,000 outright to Leo; $200,000 spendthrift sub-trust for Mei until age 25).
- Kenji's POD Bank Account: $100,000 payable to Leo.
- Rachel's Sole Property & Nonprobate Assets: $120,000 ($85,000 IRA + $35,000 checking).
Part II: Library — Law of the State of Linden (Supplied for This Task)
Notice: The statutes, ethics rule, and appellate decision below are the controlling law of the invented jurisdiction of Linden, modeled on the 2008 Uniform Probate Code, Uniform Trust Code, and ABA Model Rules, and supplied solely for this performance task.
Linden Code § 32-202, § 32-203, § 32-207 & § 32-209 (Augmented Estate, Elective Share & Satisfaction)
(a) Elective-Share Amount (§ 32-202): A surviving spouse has a right of election to take an elective-share amount equal to 50 percent of the value of the marital-property portion of the augmented estate.
(b) Augmented Estate (§ 32-203(a)): The augmented estate equals the sum of: (1) the decedent's net probate estate (gross probate estate reduced by priority family/exempt allowances and enforceable claims paid therefrom); (2) the decedent's net nonprobate transfers to others (such as revocable trusts and POD accounts, less any decedent debts paid therefrom); (3) the decedent's nonprobate transfers to the surviving spouse; and (4) the surviving spouse's own property and nonprobate transfers at the decedent's death (§ 32-207).
(c) Marital-Property Portion Schedule (§ 32-203(b)): The marital-property portion equals the augmented estate multiplied by the statutory percentage based on length of marriage (3% under 1 year, +6%/year for Years 1–10 to 60%, and +8%/year for Years 11–15 to 100%). For a marriage of at least 12 years but less than 13 years, the statutory percentage is 76 percent.
(d) Satisfaction & Liability (§ 32-209): The elective-share amount is satisfied first by applying: (1) 100 percent of amounts included in the augmented estate that pass or have passed from the decedent to the surviving spouse (under the will or nonprobate transfers, §§ 32-204, 32-206); plus (2) the § 32-203(b) marital-property percentage (here 76 percent) of the surviving spouse's own property and nonprobate transfers included under § 32-207. Any remaining deficiency is collected proportionally from recipients of the decedent's nonprobate transfers to others.
Linden Code § 32-402 (Priority Family Allowance)
A surviving spouse is entitled to a reasonable family allowance of $20,000 from the probate estate during administration. The family allowance is exempt from and takes priority over all general unsecured creditor claims (including medical bills), and is in addition to any elective share.
Linden Code § 33-505 & § 32-6102 (Creditor Reach Against Nonprobate Transfers)
After a settlor's or depositor's death, property of a trust that was revocable at death (§ 33-505(a)(3)) and funds in a Payable-on-Death (POD) account (§ 32-6102) are subject to claims of the decedent's creditors—on a proportional basis unless the instrument directs otherwise—to the extent the decedent's probate estate is inadequate after priority allowances.
Linden Code § 33-411 (Modification or Termination of Irrevocable Trust)
(b) A noncharitable irrevocable trust may be terminated upon consent of all of the beneficiaries (including minors or contingent beneficiaries represented by a court-appointed guardian ad litem or qualified representative) only if the court concludes that continuance of the trust is not necessary to achieve any material purpose of the trust.
(c) A spendthrift provision in the terms of the trust is not presumed to constitute a material purpose of the trust; however, a restriction postponing principal distribution until a beneficiary attains a specified age (such as age 25) constitutes a material purpose.
Linden Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2
In representing a client, a lawyer shall not communicate about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented by another lawyer in the matter, unless the lawyer has the consent of the other lawyer or is authorized by law or court order.
In re Estate of Albright, 24 Linden 91 (Linden Sup. Ct.)
When a probate estate is insufficient to satisfy both the surviving spouse's priority statutory allowances and general unsecured claims, the spouse's allowance is paid first out of probate assets, and general creditors must collect the unpaid balance from the decedent's revocable trust and POD transfers. Those debt payments reduce the net value of the decedent's transfers before calculating the augmented estate under § 32-203, ensuring the surviving spouse does not bear general estate debts out of her priority allowance.
Furthermore, a surviving spouse is not personally liable for a deceased spouse's separate debts unless the surviving spouse expressly contracted to pay or guaranteed the debt, or secondary liability arises under Linden's doctrine of necessaries for necessary medical care. Under Linden's doctrine of necessaries, secondary personal liability attaches to the surviving spouse only if the decedent's probate estate and reachable nonprobate transfers (§§ 33-505(a)(3), 32-6102) are insufficient to pay the necessary medical bill.
Part III: Written Assignment (60 Minutes)
Draft the client counseling letter from Elena Ortiz's firm to Rachel Sato. Address all four of Rachel's questions in clear, empathetic, plain English while accurately computing her family allowance, augmented estate, marital-property portion, elective share, and net recovery under Linden Code §§ 32-202, 32-203, 32-207, 32-209, 32-402, 33-505, 32-6102, 33-411, Rule 4.2, and Albright (including the doctrine of necessaries). Explain why Marcus Grant's email is misleading, evaluate risks, and give a clear step-by-step action plan.
Model Answer — Client Counseling Letter
Opening & Summary
Ortiz & Lin LLP · Cedarville, Linden
November 13, Year 12
Dear Rachel,
Thank you for meeting with me today to go over Kenji's estate papers and Marcus Grant's email. Please accept my condolences on your loss. The bottom line is encouraging: do not sign Mr. Grant's $50,000 waiver before Friday's deadline. Mr. Grant's message omits critical protections under Linden law. Because your priority family allowance outranks the hospital bill and Kenji's revocable trust and POD account count toward your elective share—while only the marital-property portion (76%) of your own savings counts against your elective share—your net recovery from Kenji's estate and nonprobate assets is approximately $194,800, nearly four times Leo's $50,000 offer.
1. Your Priority Family Allowance and Elective Share ($194,800 Estimated Net Recovery)
Even though Kenji's will left you only $20,000—and the $100,000 hospital bill will leave nothing in the probate estate to pay that will gift—Linden law protects surviving spouses from being disinherited through trusts or beneficiary accounts. You have two separate claims:
- First, Priority Family Allowance ($20,000): Under Linden Code § 32-402 and In re Estate of Albright, you are entitled to a $20,000 family allowance straight from the $100,000 probate estate, ahead of the hospital bill and in addition to your elective share.
- Second, Elective Share ($174,800 Net Payment): Under Linden Code §§ 32-202, 32-203, and 32-209, because you and Kenji were married for 12 full years, you may claim 50% of the "marital-property portion" (76%) of the combined "augmented estate"—which pulls together Kenji's net probate assets, Kenji's revocable trust and POD account (after unpaid debts), and your own $120,000 savings/IRA. Here is how the numbers work:
- Net Probate Estate: $100,000 gross probate minus your $20,000 priority allowance leaves $80,000 to pay toward the $100,000 hospital bill, leaving $0 net probate estate (and a $20,000 unpaid hospital balance).
- Net Nonprobate Transfers to Leo & Mei: $500,000 revocable trust + $100,000 POD account = $600,000, minus the $20,000 unpaid hospital balance paid from those accounts = $580,000.
- Your Own Assets (§ 32-207): Your $120,000 IRA and checking account count in the pool.
- Total Augmented Estate: $0 + $580,000 + $120,000 = $700,000.
- Marital-Property Portion (76% for 12 years): 76% × $700,000 = $532,000.
- Total Elective Share (50%): 50% × $532,000 = $266,000.
- Less Marital-Property Portion of Your Own Assets (§ 32-209): Although any net probate or nonprobate gifts from Kenji would count at 100% (here $0), under § 32-209 only the 76% marital-property percentage of your own $120,000 assets (76% × $120,000 = $91,200) is applied first toward your $266,000 elective share—protecting your remaining 24% ($28,800) separate share. Subtracting $91,200 from $266,000 leaves $174,800 owed to you from Kenji's trust and POD account (paid proportionally by Leo and Mei's sub-trust).
Adding your $20,000 family allowance and your $174,800 net elective share yields $194,800 in new cash/assets on top of keeping your own $120,000.
2. Why the $100,000 Hospital Bill Does Not Wipe Out Your Recovery
Mr. Grant's email implies that the $100,000 hospital bill leaves nothing for you. That is misleading. Under Linden Code § 32-402 and Albright, your $20,000 family allowance is paid out of the $100,000 probate estate before general unsecured creditors like the hospital. Only the remaining $80,000 goes to the hospital. Under Linden Code §§ 33-505(a)(3) and 32-6102, the hospital must collect the remaining $20,000 shortfall proportionally from Kenji's $500,000 revocable trust and $100,000 POD account—not from your $20,000 allowance. Nor will the hospital force you to pay out of pocket: under Albright, a surviving spouse is not personally liable for a deceased spouse's separate debts unless she co-signed or guaranteed the bill (you did not) or secondary liability arises under Linden's doctrine of necessaries—which applies only if the decedent's probate and reachable nonprobate assets are insufficient. Here, Kenji's $80,000 remaining probate cash plus $600,000 in reachable trust and POD funds cover the $100,000 bill nearly seven times over, leaving you $0 personal liability.
3. Why You and Leo Cannot Simply Dissolve Mei's $200,000 Sub-Trust
Even if you and Leo reach an overall settlement, you and Leo cannot simply sign an agreement ending Mei's $200,000 sub-trust early. Under Linden Code § 33-411(b)–(c), ending an irrevocable trust after the creator dies requires two things: (1) consent of every beneficiary, and (2) no remaining material purpose of the trust. Both hurdles block early termination here:
- Missing Consent: Mei (age 10) is a minor and the primary beneficiary of the sub-trust, so she cannot legally consent unless a court appoints a guardian ad litem or representative—who is unlikely to approve giving up Mei's educational trust.
- Postponed Age-25 Distribution Is a Material Purpose: Although Linden Code § 33-411(c) does not automatically treat the sub-trust's spendthrift clause as a material purpose, § 33-411(c) explicitly makes a postponed payout until age 25 a material purpose. A court would refuse to terminate Mei's sub-trust before she turns 25.
Accordingly, any settlement with Leo should be structured around Leo's outright $300,000 trust share and $100,000 POD account rather than counting on dissolving Mei's sub-trust (though Mei's sub-trust would contribute its proportional share if a court enforces your § 32-209 elective share without a settlement).
4. Reject the 48-Hour Deadline & Why We Cannot Call Leo Directly
Do not sign the waiver. Mr. Grant's 48-hour deadline is a classic pressure tactic offering roughly a quarter of your statutory entitlement ($50,000 vs. $194,800). Walking away now would permanently forfeit roughly $144,800.
No Direct Call to Leo: You asked if I can call Leo directly because he is easier to talk to. Under Linden Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2, a lawyer may not communicate about a legal matter with anyone the lawyer knows is represented by counsel in that matter without the other lawyer's permission. Because Mr. Grant's email confirms he represents Leo in all estate and trust matters, our firm must send all settlement proposals through Mr. Grant. (While you are not personally bound by Rule 4.2 if you speak with Leo about family logistics, I strongly advise letting us handle all financial negotiations through Mr. Grant so nothing you say is misquoted.)
Recommended Next Steps
- Do not sign or return Mr. Grant's waiver form.
- Authorize our firm today to email Mr. Grant notifying him that we represent you, declining the $50,000 offer, and inviting a realistic settlement discussion based on the $194,800 statutory calculation.
- Gather your October Year 12 IRA and bank statements so we can document your $120,000 offset and promptly file your formal Petition for Family Allowance and Election of Elective Share in probate court before statutory deadlines run.
Please call my office this afternoon so we can respond to Mr. Grant before Friday.
Warm regards,
Elena Ortiz, Esq.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 25 Points
Tone, Clarity & Structure (3 Points)
- 1 pt Uses proper client-letter format addressed to Rachel Sato and organized around all four questions.
- 1 pt Translates technical terms (augmented estate, marital-property portion, material purpose, Rule 4.2) into clear, empathetic plain English.
- 1 pt Provides concrete, realistic next steps ahead of Friday's 5:00 p.m. deadline.
Question 1: Priority Allowance & Elective-Share Math (8 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies Rachel's $20,000 priority family allowance under § 32-402 as in addition to the elective share.
- 1 pt Explains that the $100,000 probate estate minus $20,000 allowance and $80,000 hospital payment leaves $0 net probate estate (and $0 from the $20,000 will gift).
- 1 pt Includes net nonprobate transfers to others ($600,000 − $20,000 unpaid debt = $580,000) in the augmented estate under § 32-203(a)(2).
- 1 pt Answers Rachel's question directly: her own $120,000 IRA/checking counts in the augmented estate (§ 32-203(a)(4)) and only its 76% marital-property portion ($91,200) is applied first to satisfy her share (§ 32-209).
- 1 pt Computes total augmented estate accurately ($0 + $580,000 + $120,000 = $700,000).
- 1 pt Applies the 12-year statutory marital-property percentage (76% × $700,000 = $532,000) and 50% elective share ($266,000).
- 1 pt Subtracts 76% of Rachel's $120,000 own assets ($91,200) under § 32-209 to calculate $174,800 net elective share owed proportionally from nonprobate recipients.
- 1 pt Totals Rachel's new estate recovery as $194,800 ($174,800 + $20,000 allowance).
Question 2: Creditor Priority & Nonprobate Debt Reach (5 Points)
- 1 pt Reassures Rachel that under § 32-402 and Albright, her $20,000 family allowance outranks the $100,000 hospital bill.
- 1 pt Identifies the $20,000 probate shortfall ($100,000 debt − $80,000 remaining probate cash).
- 1 pt Applies § 33-505(a)(3) and § 32-6102: the hospital can reach Kenji's revocable trust and POD account proportionally for the $20,000 shortfall.
- 1 pt Explains why Rachel is not personally liable for Kenji's medical bill under Albright (she did not co-sign/guarantee it, and secondary liability under the doctrine of necessaries applies only when decedent's probate and reachable nonprobate assets are insufficient).
- 1 pt Notes Albright's rule that the $20,000 nonprobate debt payout reduces the augmented estate before calculating her share.
Question 3: Terminating Mei's $200,000 Sub-Trust (4 Points)
- 1 pt States both prongs of § 33-411(b): unanimous beneficiary consent + no unfulfilled material purpose.
- 1 pt Explains missing consent: minor beneficiary Mei (age 10) cannot consent without a court-appointed representative/guardian ad litem.
- 1 pt Applies § 33-411(c) accurately: while the spendthrift clause is not presumed material, postponing principal until age 25 is a material purpose barring early termination.
- 1 pt Advises structuring any settlement from Leo's outright $300,000 trust share and $100,000 POD account rather than dissolving Mei's sub-trust.
Question 4: Rejecting Offer, Rule 4.2 & Action Plan (5 Points)
- 1 pt Advises strongly against signing Grant's $50,000 waiver (forfeiting ~$144,800 under a 48-hour pressure tactic).
- 1 pt Exposes Grant's misleading framing (omitting $20,000 priority allowance and nonprobate augmented estate).
- 1 pt Cites Linden Rule 4.2 barring the firm from calling Leo directly because Marcus Grant represents Leo in the matter.
- 1 pt Advises Rachel to route negotiations through counsel (cautioning her against informal financial talks with Leo).
- 1 pt Sets concrete action steps (decline offer, gather asset records, file allowance and elective-share petitions timely).