Five select-one-of-four questions and five select-two-of-six questions (~1.8 minutes per item) under general United States tort law.
Checked: 0 of 10 · Score: 0 / 10
Question 1 of 10Select One of Four
Intentional Torts — Assault & Bystander IIED
Outside a bakery, Actor shouts violent threats and lunges with a raised heavy umbrella toward Victim. Victim sees the umbrella coming, ducks swiftly, and is not struck, though Victim genuinely fears being hit. Across the street, Victim's spouse is watching through a one-way tinted cafe window; Actor has no idea anyone is behind the tinted glass. Watching the lunge causes Victim's spouse severe emotional distress and chest pains. Which tort claim is MOST likely to succeed? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Victim's assault claim succeeds because Actor committed an intentional overt act (lunging with a raised umbrella while shouting threats) that placed Victim in reasonable apprehension of imminent harmful contact, with apparent present ability to strike. Battery fails because no harmful or offensive contact occurred. Spouse's bystander IIED claim fails because bystander IIED requires that the actor know—or act with reckless disregard of a high probability—that the bystander is present; Actor had no reason to know Spouse was watching behind one-way tinted glass across the street. Bystander NIED fails because Actor's conduct was an intentional assault rather than negligence, Victim suffered no physical injury at all (bystander NIED requires death or serious bodily injury to the primary victim), and Spouse was neither in the zone of physical danger nor witnessing a negligent physical injury.
Question 2 of 10Select Two of Six
Intentional Torts — Recapture of Chattels & Privilege
During a sudden spring flood, Neighbor's aluminum canoe washes off Neighbor's dock and lodges against Homeowner's wooden garden fence on Homeowner's land. Homeowner is away for the weekend and played no role in the flood. Seeing heavy rain forecast to swell the creek again that evening, Neighbor carefully enters Homeowner's yard to pull the canoe free before it washes away, accidentally snapping three fence pickets and crushing several prized tulips. Under general United States tort law, which TWO statements are correct? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
When a chattel is on an innocent landowner's property due to an act of God (such as a flood), the chattel's possessor has an incomplete privilege to enter at a reasonable time and in a reasonable manner to reclaim it (with prior demand excused when impossible or urgent because the owner is away and further loss is imminent). Because the entry is privileged, Neighbor is not liable for nominal trespass damages. However, because Homeowner was innocent of wrongdoing, Neighbor's privilege is incomplete and Neighbor must pay for any actual physical damage caused to Homeowner's land, fence, and tulips. Homeowner did not commit conversion because Homeowner never intentionally exercised dominion or control over the canoe.
Owner hires Plumber to repair a leaking basement water heater at Owner's house for a fee. While descending the basement stairs, Plumber trips on a loose step tread that Owner did not know was loose, even though protruding nails would have been obvious upon a quick pre-visit inspection. That same evening, Owner hosts Friend for dinner. While walking down the hall to the coat closet, Friend opens an unlocked adjacent door by mistake, steps onto the top landing, and slips in a small puddle of rainwater that Owner knew had leaked under the side door that morning and had neither mopped up nor mentioned. Under traditional common-law premises liability categories, what duties did Owner owe to Plumber and Friend? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under traditional premises-liability categories, Plumber entered for Owner's business purpose and is an invitee, to whom Owner owes a duty of reasonable care to inspect, discover, and warn of or make safe dangerous conditions (which a reasonable inspection of the stairs would have revealed). Friend is a social guest—a licensee—to whom Owner owes no duty to inspect for unknown hazards, but does owe a duty to warn of or make safe concealed dangers (natural or artificial) that Owner actually knows about, such as the known rainwater puddle.
Question 4 of 10Select Two of Six
Negligence — Causation & Apportionment
Two chemical tankers operated independently by Alpha Co. and Beta Co. negligently discharge separate loads of toxic solvent into a creek upstream from Farmer's orchard at the same time. Either company's discharge alone was concentrated enough to kill all of Farmer's peach trees, and the combined plume destroys the entire orchard. Farmer sues both companies in a jurisdiction following general United States tort law. Which TWO legal conclusions are correct? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
When two independent negligent acts combine to cause an indivisible injury and each alone would have been sufficient to bring about the harm, the strict 'but-for' test fails, so each actor's conduct is treated as a factual cause under the substantial factor (multiple sufficient causes) test. Because the destruction of the orchard is an indivisible physical property injury (not a pure economic loss), both companies are jointly and severally liable in a traditional joint-and-several jurisdiction. Alternative liability does not apply because both discharges actually harmed the orchard (not a case where only one of two negligent actors caused the harm). Neither active wrongdoer is entitled to 100% indemnity from the other; instead, the paying defendant may seek contribution.
Question 5 of 10Select One of Four
Negligence — Bystander NIED
Driver negligently runs a red light at an intersection and strikes Pedestrian in a crosswalk, causing severe injuries. Pedestrian's adult sibling, Sibling, is working in an office building two blocks away while watching a live municipal traffic webcam on a computer screen and witnesses the collision happen in real time. Overcome with shock, Sibling suffers severe anxiety, insomnia, and recurring stress-induced migraines for several weeks. In a jurisdiction following the majority rule for bystander negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED), will Sibling recover against Driver? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under the majority rule for bystander NIED outside the zone of physical danger, the plaintiff must be (1) closely related to the victim, (2) physically present at the scene of the injury-producing event when it occurs, (3) contemporaneously perceiving the serious injury, and (4) suffering physical symptoms (or severe emotional distress under the modern minority). Watching a live video feed from two blocks away fails the physical-presence-at-the-scene requirement, and Sibling was not in the zone of physical danger.
Blaster Co. conducts controlled rock blasting with dynamite to excavate a commercial sewer trench in a densely populated residential neighborhood in Linden. Even though Blaster Co. follows every industry safety protocol, shockwaves from a blast shatter the stained-glass windows of Neighbor's house next door. Two days earlier, while driving an empty flatbed truck along the same street to haul unprimed blasting mats, Blaster Co.'s driver negligently ran a stop sign and knocked down Neighbor's mailbox without any explosion. Assume the jurisdiction applies traditional common-law strict liability defenses for abnormally dangerous activities unless otherwise stated. Which TWO legal conclusions are accurate? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
An actor carrying on an abnormally dangerous activity—one that creates a foreseeable and highly significant risk of physical harm even when reasonable care is exercised and is not a matter of common usage, such as blasting with dynamite in a populated area—is strictly liable for physical harm resulting from the kind of risk that makes the activity abnormally dangerous (Restatement (Second) of Torts §§ 519–520; Restatement (Third) § 20). Strict liability does not extend to the knocked-down mailbox because ordinary driving is a matter of common usage and the harm did not stem from an explosive risk (triggering negligence instead). In addition, traditional common-law strict liability distinguishes ordinary contributory negligence (which is no defense at all) from knowing and unreasonable assumption of risk (which is a complete bar under §§ 523–524), whereas modern comparative-fault jurisdictions reduce recovery proportionally (Third § 25).
Manufacturer makes a commercial electric meat slicer with a plastic blade guard secured by two hand-turned wingnuts so kitchen staff can detach the guard for daily washing. Manufacturer knows from customer service reports that deli workers frequently leave the guard off during busy lunch rushes to slice faster, yet designs the slicer to run at full speed without the guard attached. During a lunch rush, Worker detaches the guard, slips on a damp floor mat, and severely cuts a hand on the exposed blade. Worker sues Manufacturer in strict products liability for a design defect. How does Worker's removal of the blade guard affect Manufacturer's strict products liability? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under products liability doctrine, only an unforeseeable misuse or an unforeseeable substantial alteration bars strict liability. Where removing an easily detachable blade guard during busy shifts is reasonably foreseeable—here, actually known to Manufacturer—the alteration does not defeat strict liability for a defective design that omits an interlock switch or safer alternative design, though Worker's own unreasonable conduct may reduce recovery proportionally under comparative fault.
Question 8 of 10Select Two of Six
Nuisance — Private, Public & Remedies
Cement Plant operates lawfully in a semi-rural valley, emitting heavy dust and loud nighttime grinding noise. Homeowner buys a cottage a quarter-mile away knowing Cement Plant is already operating next door; soon afterward, Cement Plant's dust coats Homeowner's porch daily and nighttime noise keeps Homeowner awake. Separately, Cement Plant's runoff silts up the valley's sole public riverboat landing, blocking access for everyone. Tour Operator holds an exclusive dockside kiosk lease at that landing and loses all ticket bookings, while local residents must drive five extra miles to launch recreational kayaks. Which TWO statements are correct under general United States nuisance law? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Coming to the nuisance—buying or moving onto land after a nuisance has begun—is a relevant equitable factor in deciding liability and remedies rather than an absolute bar to a private nuisance claim. For public nuisance (unreasonable interference with a right common to the general public), a private plaintiff may sue for damages or injunctive relief only by proving special injury different in kind, not merely in degree, from the inconvenience suffered by the public; Tour Operator's lost dockside commercial bookings illustrate a distinct pecuniary injury different in kind from recreational boaters' detour. Courts may award permanent damages rather than an unconditional shutdown injunction when closing a useful plant would cause severe economic hardship, and nuisance covers intangible interferences such as noise and odors without requiring a physical trespass.
Question 9 of 10Select One of Four
Defamation — Fair-Report Privilege
During an open city council hearing on municipal paving contracts, a council member falsely accuses Private Contractor of bribing city building inspectors. Local Gazette publishes an accurate, complete summary of the council hearing in the next morning's paper, including the council member's accusation, even though Gazette's editor personally dislikes Contractor and strongly suspects the bribery accusation is false. Contractor sues Gazette for defamation. What is Gazette's STRONGEST defense? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under the fair-report privilege (Restatement (Second) of Torts § 611), publication of defamatory matter in an accurate and complete report or fair abridgement of an official action, proceeding, or public meeting on a matter of public concern is privileged. Unlike ordinary conditional privileges, the fair-report privilege is not defeated by widespread public dissemination, ill will, or knowledge or suspicion that the underlying statements made at the proceeding were false. Truth is not a defense to republishing another's false factual accusation of bribery, and an accusation of bribery is a statement of fact rather than pure opinion.
Department Store hires Electrician, an independent electrical contracting company, to rewire ceiling fixtures directly over Store's main customer entrance during business hours. Electrician negligently leaves an energized wire dangling six feet above the entrance mat, shocking Customer as Customer walks in to shop. Store had no notice of the dangling wire and exercised reasonable care in selecting Electrician. Customer sues both Store and Electrician and obtains a single $100,000 judgment. Which TWO statements accurately describe Store's liability and recovery rights? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Although a hirer is generally not vicariously liable for the torts of an independent contractor, a business owner owes a nondelegable duty to keep business premises reasonably safe for invitees and cannot shift that responsibility to an independent contractor performing work over a customer entrance. Store is therefore vicariously liable—jointly and severally with Electrician—for Customer's $100,000 judgment. However, because Store was personally blameless and held solely vicariously liable, Store is entitled to 100% indemnity (rather than mere 50% contribution) from Electrician, the active wrongdoer.