Integrated Set 1: Counseling & Drafting — The Falling Awning at Pinecrest Grocer
Read the client intake facts below and complete all five mixed-form counseling and drafting questions.
Fact Pattern
Two weeks ago, Pinecrest Grocer LLC ("Pinecrest") hired Bramble Sign & Awning Co. ("Bramble"), an established independent contractor using its own crew and equipment, to install a new 200-pound metal-and-canvas awning directly above Pinecrest's main customer entrance along a public sidewalk in the town of Mapleford.
Bramble purchased six steel mounting brackets manufactured and sold commercially by Apex Hardware Corp. ("Apex"). One of the six brackets left Apex's factory with an internal hairline metallurgical crack invisible from the outside. In addition, Bramble's lead installer used only four of the six specified mounting bolts when anchoring the awning into Pinecrest's brick facade because the installer ran short of bolts and decided four would hold overnight. At 4:00 p.m., Pinecrest's store manager stepped outside, saw Bramble's crew packing up with two empty bolt holes visible on the right bracket, and unlocked the front doors for evening shoppers without asking Bramble to finish bolting or barricade the entrance.
At 5:30 p.m., Tessa Vance, a freelance graphic designer, walked along the public sidewalk toward Pinecrest's open front doors to buy groceries. Just as Tessa stepped beneath the awning onto Pinecrest's entrance threshold, the cracked Apex bracket snapped and the under-bolted awning tore free, striking Tessa on the shoulder and knocking Tessa to the pavement. Tessa suffered a fractured collarbone, $18,000 in hospital and physical-therapy bills (paid initially by Tessa's private health insurer), and $6,000 in documented lost freelance design income.
Tessa's husband, Darius Vance, was standing inside a coffee shop across the four-lane street waiting for Tessa. Hearing a loud crash, Darius looked out the window and saw Tessa already lying on the sidewalk beneath the fallen awning. Darius ran across the street, experienced severe anxiety and sleeplessness for several weeks, and missed three days of work, though Darius suffered no physical symptoms such as nausea, chest pain, or weight loss.
Assume Mapleford's jurisdiction follows general United States tort law, modified 51% comparative fault, joint and several liability for indivisible physical injuries, and comparative-fault contribution among joint tortfeasors. Tessa comes to your law office seeking advice on potential claims, recoverable damages, Darius's possible claim, and drafting the initial pleading.
During the intake meeting, Tessa asks whether Pinecrest can avoid liability by blaming Bramble as an independent contractor. Which statement gives Tessa the MOST accurate legal advice? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
A hirer is generally not vicariously liable for an independent contractor's torts, but two rules establish Pinecrest's potential liability here: (1) direct negligence, because Pinecrest's store manager actually observed the incomplete bolting (two empty bolt holes) and nevertheless opened the entrance to shoppers without inspecting, repairing, or barricading; and (2) vicarious liability under the nondelegable duty doctrine, because a business owner cannot delegate its duty to keep business premises and customer entrances reasonably safe for business invitees—or to prevent overhead hazards immediately above a public sidewalk. Tessa was a business invitee approaching an open store during business hours, and Pinecrest is not a commercial seller of brackets subject to strict products liability.
Tessa asks whether Tessa can recover from Apex Hardware Corp. even though Tessa never purchased the mounting bracket and Bramble also under-bolted the awning. Which TWO legal points should you explain to Tessa? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
A commercial seller is strictly liable for physical harm to a user, consumer, or foreseeable bystander caused by a manufacturing defect (a product departing from its intended design) even if the manufacturer exercised all possible care and lacked privity with the injured plaintiff. Moreover, Bramble's concurrent negligence in omitting two bolts does not automatically cut off Apex's liability where the defective bracket snapped and remained a substantial factual and proximate cause of the awning's collapse—making Apex and Bramble jointly and severally liable for Tessa's indivisible personal injuries. Lost freelance earnings resulting from physical bodily injury (the fractured collarbone) are recoverable economic damages, not barred by the pure economic loss rule.
Tessa asks whether the $18,000 in medical bills paid by Tessa's private health insurer reduces Tessa's recoverable tort damages, and whether Tessa is likely to recover punitive damages against Pinecrest or Apex. Which advice is MOST accurate? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under the common-law collateral source rule, a tortfeasor's liability for compensatory damages (medical bills and lost earnings) is not reduced by benefits the plaintiff receives from third-party insurance paid for by the plaintiff. Compensatory damages cover both medical expenses and documented lost self-employment earnings caused by the physical injury. Punitive damages require clear proof of willful, wanton, or reckless misconduct—ordinary carelessness or an inadvertent factory defect alone does not support punitive damages.
Question 4 of 5Short Written Response
Counseling — Bystander NIED Analysis for Darius Vance
Tessa asks whether Darius can assert a separate bystander claim for negligent infliction of emotional distress (NIED) based on Darius's severe anxiety, sleeplessness, and three missed days of work. Draft a concise 3-to-5 sentence counseling explanation advising Tessa on the likely outcome of Darius's bystander NIED claim under the majority rule.
Model Response
Darius's bystander NIED claim is very unlikely to succeed under the majority rule. Although Darius is Tessa's spouse and stood across the street within unaided sight of the storefront outside the zone of physical danger, a bystander must contemporaneously perceive the injury-producing impact causing serious injury and suffer physical symptoms from the emotional distress. Here, Darius looked out the coffee shop window only after hearing the crash and saw Tessa already lying on the ground rather than the awning striking Tessa, and suffered anxiety and sleeplessness without physical symptoms. Even in jurisdictions that relax the physical-symptom requirement for severe distress, failing to contemporaneously observe the injury-producing impact (seeing only the aftermath) will defeat Darius's claim.
Key Points
Identifies the four majority bystander NIED elements: close relationship, physical presence at the scene, contemporaneous perception of the injury-producing event, and physical symptoms (noting the modern severe-distress alternative).
Notes that Darius satisfies the close-relationship element (spouse) and was outside the zone of physical danger (standing across a four-lane street with direct sight of the storefront satisfies proximity at the scene, unlike remote video).
Applies facts showing Darius fails contemporaneous perception (looked out only after hearing the crash and saw Tessa already on the ground).
Notes Darius lacks physical symptoms (anxiety and sleeplessness alone fail the majority physical-symptom rule) and concludes the claim will likely fail.
Explanation
Under the traditional/majority rule for bystander NIED outside the zone of physical danger, a claimant must show (1) a close family relationship to the injured victim, (2) physical presence at the scene of the injury-producing event when it occurs (which can be satisfied from across a street with direct unaided sight, unlike remote video), (3) contemporaneous perception of the impact causing death or serious injury, and (4) physical symptoms resulting from the emotional distress (while the modern minority rule requires serious/severe emotional distress). Although Darius is Tessa's spouse and stood within sight across the four-lane street outside the zone of danger, Darius did not contemporaneously perceive the awning strike Tessa—looking out only after hearing the crash and seeing Tessa already on the sidewalk—and experienced anxiety and sleeplessness without physical manifestations such as nausea or chest pain. Therefore, advise Tessa that Darius's bystander NIED claim is very unlikely to succeed.
You are preparing Tessa's civil complaint against Pinecrest, Bramble, and Apex, along with an internal note on cross-claims. Draft: (a) two sentences for the complaint pleading why Pinecrest is liable despite hiring Bramble as an independent contractor; and (b) two sentences for the internal file note explaining whether Pinecrest can obtain 100% common-law indemnity or only comparative contribution from Bramble and Apex if Pinecrest is found directly negligent versus solely vicariously liable.
Model Response
(a) Complaint Allegation: Defendant Pinecrest Grocer LLC owed Plaintiff Tessa Vance, a business invitee, a nondelegable duty to maintain its storefront entrance and public-sidewalk approach in a reasonably safe condition, rendering Pinecrest vicariously liable for Defendant Bramble Sign & Awning Co.'s negligent installation. In addition, Pinecrest was directly negligent when its store manager observed missing mounting bolts on the newly hung awning and nonetheless opened the entrance to shoppers without securing the awning or warning invitees.
(b) Internal Cross-Claim Note: If Pinecrest is held solely vicariously liable under the nondelegable-duty doctrine without personal fault, Pinecrest is entitled to 100% common-law indemnity from Bramble (the active negligent installer). However, because strong evidence supports Pinecrest's direct negligence through its store manager's notice and inaction, a finding of active fault by Pinecrest will defeat 100% indemnity and limit Pinecrest to comparative-fault contribution from Bramble and Apex for any payment exceeding Pinecrest's fault share.
Key Points
Complaint allegation pleads Pinecrest's nondelegable duty to keep business premises/approaches safe for invitees (vicarious liability despite independent-contractor status).
Complaint allegation also pleads Pinecrest's direct negligence (manager saw missing bolts and opened doors without warning or barricade).
File note distinguishes sole vicarious liability (100% common-law indemnity from active wrongdoer Bramble) from direct negligence.
File note explains that if Pinecrest is found directly negligent, 100% indemnity is unavailable and Pinecrest is limited to comparative-fault contribution from Bramble and Apex.
Explanation
A strong complaint pleads both Pinecrest's direct negligence (opening the entrance after its manager noticed empty bolt holes) and vicarious liability under its nondelegable duty to maintain safe business premises and sidewalk approaches for invitees. For the internal apportionment note, 100% common-law indemnity is available only if Pinecrest is held solely vicariously liable without personal fault; if the factfinder holds Pinecrest directly negligent for its manager's failure to act, Pinecrest is restricted to comparative-fault contribution against Bramble and Apex.