NextGen Real Property · 24-Minute Integrated Question Set
Integrated Set 1: Counseling & Drafting — The Willowbrook Cottage Dispute
Read the client intake facts below and complete all five mixed-form counseling and drafting questions.
Fact Pattern
Three years ago, siblings Clara Diaz and Nora Diaz bought Willowbrook Cottage, a single-family house on a half-acre lot in the town of Willowbrook, for $250,000. Seller Owen Mercer conveyed Willowbrook Cottage to Clara and Nora "as joint tenants with right of survivorship" by a general warranty deed containing no exceptions or reservations. First Valley Bank lent Clara and Nora $150,000 of the purchase price, took a first mortgage signed by both sisters, and promptly recorded the mortgage.
Eighteen months ago, without telling Nora, Clara borrowed $40,000 from Cedar Credit Union for Clara's catering business and executed a mortgage on Clara's undivided half-interest in Willowbrook Cottage. Cedar Credit Union promptly recorded its second mortgage. Twelve months ago, Clara and Nora leased Willowbrook Cottage to Tenant Liam Cho under a valid two-year written residential lease at $1,800 per month. Liam immediately moved into the cottage and lived there openly, though neither party recorded the lease.
Six months ago, Clara died, leaving a valid will devising "all of my real property to my friend, Devon Park." Shortly thereafter, the cottage's septic line backed up into the ground-floor bathroom, filling the cottage with raw sewage odors. Liam promptly notified Nora in writing, but Nora took no action to hire a plumber for three weeks. Liam stayed in an upstairs bedroom during those three weeks and withheld $900 of that month's $1,800 rent; once Nora finally repaired the septic line at the end of the third week, Liam resumed paying the full $1,800 monthly rent.
Two months ago, Nora fell behind on First Valley Bank's loan, and First Valley Bank completed a valid judicial foreclosure of its senior $150,000 mortgage. First Valley Bank joined Nora as a defendant, but inadvertently failed to join Tenant Liam Cho despite Liam's visible occupancy of the cottage. Investor Quinn bought Willowbrook Cottage at the foreclosure sale for $165,000, leaving a $15,000 surplus after paying foreclosure costs and First Valley Bank's $150,000 debt.
Separately, Nora just received a certified survey showing that Neighbor Priya built a permanent wooden fence and glass greenhouse fifteen years ago extending three feet over the boundary line onto Willowbrook Cottage's side yard, and has used that three-foot strip openly, exclusively, and without permission ever since (the statutory adverse-possession period is ten years). Priya never recorded any deed or court judgment for the strip. Assume Willowbrook's jurisdiction follows the majority lien theory of mortgages, the modern residential implied warranty of habitability, standard general warranty deed covenant rules, and that the statute of limitations on deed-covenant claims has not expired. Nora Diaz comes to your law office seeking counseling and drafting assistance.
Checked: 0 of 3 · Score: 0 / 3
Question 1 of 5Select One of Four
Counseling — Joint Tenancy Survivorship, Lien-Theory Mortgages, and Wills
During the intake meeting, Nora asks whether Clara's friend Devon Park (named in Clara's will) or Cedar Credit Union (holding the $40,000 mortgage Clara signed alone) acquired an ownership interest or surviving mortgage lien on Willowbrook Cottage when Clara died. Which statement gives Nora the MOST accurate legal advice? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
In a majority lien-theory jurisdiction, a mortgage creates only a security interest (a lien) rather than conveying legal title, so a mortgage granted by one joint tenant alone does not break the four unities or sever a joint tenancy. When Clara died first, the right of survivorship operated instantaneously at the moment of death: Nora became the sole owner of Willowbrook Cottage, nothing remained in Clara's estate for Clara's will to pass to Devon Park, and Cedar Credit Union's mortgage lien on Clara's extinguished half-interest vanished with Clara's interest (though Cedar Credit Union may still pursue Clara's probate estate personally on the promissory note). Note that in a minority title-theory state, a mortgage severs the joint tenancy into a tenancy in common and keeps the half-interest encumbered.
Question 2 of 5Select Two of Six
Counseling — Foreclosure Surplus Priority and Omitted Junior Tenants
Nora asks who is entitled to the $15,000 surplus from First Valley Bank's $165,000 foreclosure sale, and why Investor Quinn is demanding money back from Nora because Tenant Liam Cho refuses to vacate under the remaining year of Liam's lease. Which TWO legal points should you explain to Nora? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
First, foreclosure sale proceeds pay foreclosure expenses, then the foreclosing senior mortgage debt, then valid junior liens in order of priority, and finally any remaining surplus goes to the debtor-owner. Because Clara's solo mortgage to Cedar Credit Union died upon Clara's death under lien theory and Devon Park took no ownership interest, Nora Diaz is entitled to the full $15,000 surplus. Second, while a senior foreclosure normally extinguishes junior interests (including a lease signed after a prior recorded senior mortgage), foreclosure eliminates only those junior interest holders who were joined as parties; because First Valley Bank failed to join Tenant Liam Cho, Liam's leasehold interest survived the foreclosure sale intact.
Question 3 of 5Select One of Four
Counseling — Implied Warranty of Habitability vs. Constructive Eviction
Nora asks whether Nora can sue Tenant Liam Cho to recover the $900 in rent that Liam withheld during the three-week septic sewage backup, arguing that Liam forfeited any defense by remaining in the upstairs bedroom instead of moving out. Which advice is MOST accurate? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Constructive eviction requires (1) substantial interference caused by the landlord's breach of duty, (2) notice to the landlord and a reasonable opportunity to cure, and (3) the tenant actually vacating within a reasonable time. Because Liam stayed in the upstairs bedroom, Liam cannot claim constructive eviction. However, under the non-waivable residential implied warranty of habitability, a landlord must maintain basic sanitation and plumbing fit for human habitation; after giving written notice and waiting without repair, a residential tenant may stay in possession and withhold or abate rent down to the diminished fair rental value during the period of breach—so Liam's proportionate $900 withholding during the three-week sewage backup is defensible if it reflects the reduced rental value.
Question 4 of 5Short Written Response
Counseling — Adverse Possession and General Warranty Deed Covenants
Nora asks whether Neighbor Priya actually owns the three-foot strip under Priya's fence and greenhouse despite never recording a deed or court order, and whether Nora can recover damages from Seller Owen Mercer under Owen's general warranty deed. Draft a concise 4-to-6 sentence counseling explanation advising Nora on both questions.
Model Response
Neighbor Priya acquired fee simple title to the three-foot strip five years ago—after ten years of continuous, open and notorious, actual, exclusive, and hostile possession—and title by adverse possession vests automatically at the end of the statutory period without recording a deed or judgment. Because Priya's title ripened two full years before Seller Owen Mercer delivered the general warranty deed to you and Clara three years ago, Owen did not own or convey the three-foot strip at closing. As an original grantee, you can recover damages from Owen for breaching the present covenants of seisin and right to convey at delivery, and Priya's physical possession of the strip at closing and during your ownership also constituted an immediate partial eviction breaching the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty. By contrast, if Priya's ten-year period had completed after closing, Owen would not have breached any deed covenant. Note two practical caveats: Owen may contest substantial damages if the $165,000 foreclosure sale occurred before the encroachment was discovered and caused no measurable price loss, and because the covenant claims accrued jointly to you and Clara at delivery, you may need to account for Clara's estate.
Key Points
Concludes Neighbor Priya acquired title to the three-foot strip by adverse possession five years ago (before closing), because adverse-possession title vests automatically upon completing the statutory period without recording.
Explains that because Priya's paramount title existed before delivery of Seller Owen Mercer's general warranty deed, Owen breached the present covenants of seisin and right to convey at delivery (enforceable by Nora as an original grantee).
Explains that Priya's physical occupation of the strip at closing and during Nora's ownership triggers immediate partial eviction breaching the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty.
Notes the key timing distinction (post-closing completion breaches no deed covenant) and practical caveats regarding post-foreclosure measurable damages and Clara's estate.
Explanation
Neighbor Priya built the permanent fence and greenhouse fifteen years ago and maintained actual, exclusive, open and notorious, continuous, and non-permissive possession for over ten years, so Priya's adverse possession vested fee simple title automatically ten years after entry—five years ago, which was two full years before Seller Owen Mercer delivered the general warranty deed to Clara and Nora (and recording is not required for title to vest by adverse possession). Because Priya already held paramount title and physical possession at closing, Seller Owen Mercer breached the present covenants of seisin and right to convey at delivery (which Nora can enforce directly as an original grantee without needing present covenants to run), as well as the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty via Priya's immediate partial eviction at closing and during Nora's ownership prior to foreclosure. (Note that if Priya's ten-year period had completed after deed delivery rather than before, Owen would have breached no deed covenant. As a practical counseling caveat, Owen may contest substantial damages if the $165,000 foreclosure sale occurred before the encroachment was known and caused no measurable price reduction, and Nora may need to account for co-grantee Clara's estate on claims that accrued jointly at delivery.)
Question 5 of 5Short Written Response
Drafting — Creditor Rejection Letter & Warranty Deed Demand Notice
Nora instructs you to protect her interests in writing. Draft: (a) two sentences for a letter to Cedar Credit Union explaining why Cedar Credit Union holds no surviving lien on Willowbrook Cottage and no valid claim to the $15,000 foreclosure surplus; and (b) two sentences for a formal demand notice to Seller Owen Mercer asserting Owen's liability under the general warranty deed for Priya's pre-closing adverse-possession strip.
Model Response
(a) Letter to Cedar Credit Union: Under this jurisdiction's lien theory of mortgages, Clara Diaz's unilateral $40,000 mortgage did not sever the joint tenancy between Clara and Nora Diaz, so upon Clara's death sole ownership passed immediately to Nora Diaz by right of survivorship and extinguished Cedar Credit Union's lien on the property. Consequently, Cedar Credit Union holds no surviving security interest in Willowbrook Cottage and no claim to the $15,000 foreclosure surplus, and any claim on the underlying promissory note must be presented solely to Clara Diaz's probate estate.
(b) Demand Notice to Seller Owen Mercer: Because Neighbor Priya's ten-year adverse possession of the three-foot side strip under Priya's permanent fence and greenhouse ripened into paramount fee simple title before you delivered the general warranty deed to Clara and Nora Diaz three years ago, you lacked title and authority to convey that strip at closing. Demand is hereby made for damages resulting from your breach of the deed's present covenants of seisin and right to convey at delivery, as well as the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty based on Priya's paramount possession and immediate partial eviction at closing and during our ownership prior to foreclosure.
Key Points
Letter to Cedar Credit Union states that under lien theory Clara's mortgage did not sever the joint tenancy and survivorship extinguished the lien on Willowbrook Cottage.
Letter to Cedar Credit Union concludes Cedar has no claim to the $15,000 foreclosure surplus (and must look to Clara's estate on the note).
Demand notice to Seller Owen Mercer identifies Priya's pre-closing ripened adverse possession of the three-foot strip as pre-existing paramount title.
Demand notice asserts breach of the present covenants of seisin and right to convey and the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty.
Explanation
In (a), the letter to Cedar Credit Union should clearly state the majority lien-theory rule that Clara's mortgage did not sever the joint tenancy and that upon Clara's death Nora took sole ownership by survivorship free of Cedar's lien, leaving Cedar no claim against the $15,000 foreclosure surplus (though Cedar may seek recovery against Clara's probate estate on the note). In (b), the notice to Seller Owen Mercer should identify the three-foot strip adversely possessed by Neighbor Priya before delivery of the general warranty deed three years ago and assert breach of the present covenants of seisin and right to convey as well as the future covenants of quiet enjoyment and warranty based on Priya's paramount possession and immediate partial eviction at closing and during Nora's ownership before the foreclosure sale.