Five select-one-of-four questions and five select-two-of-six questions (~1.8 minutes per item) under the Federal Rules of Evidence, federal common law, and the Sixth Amendment.
Checked: 0 of 10 · Score: 0 / 10
Question 1 of 10Select One of Four
Relevance — Victim Character Evidence and Homicide Peacefulness Rebuttal
In a federal murder prosecution, Defendant testifies in self-defense that Victim swung a heavy crowbar at Defendant first. Defendant also calls a neighbor to testify that Victim had a reputation in the community for violent aggression. Defendant offers no evidence of Defendant's own character for peacefulness. During its rebuttal case, what character evidence may the prosecution introduce under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 404(a)(2)(B), when a criminal defendant offers evidence of an alleged victim's pertinent trait—here, Victim's violent aggression—the prosecution may both rebut that evidence and offer evidence of the defendant's own same trait (violence or aggression), even though Defendant never introduced good-character evidence of peacefulness. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 404(a)(2)(C), in a homicide case, the prosecution may also offer evidence of the alleged victim's trait of peacefulness to rebut any evidence that the victim was the first aggressor. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 405(a), when character evidence is admissible to prove conduct under these rules, the prosecution's rebuttal witnesses on direct examination may testify only in the form of reputation or opinion, not specific prior bar fights.
Question 2 of 10Select Two of Six
Relevance — Expert Opinion Bases and Mental-State Ultimate Issues
In a federal wire-fraud prosecution, Defendant raises an insanity defense. Defense counsel calls a qualified forensic psychiatrist who diagnoses Defendant with a severe psychotic disorder based in part on unauthenticated, otherwise inadmissible hospital intake notes written by an out-of-state nurse, which forensic psychiatrists reasonably rely upon in forming opinions. On direct examination, defense counsel asks to read the nurse's intake notes aloud to the jury and asks whether Defendant lacked the capacity to know the fraud was wrong at the time of the offense. Which TWO rulings accurately state the law under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 703, an expert may rely on otherwise inadmissible facts or data if experts in the particular field would reasonably rely on them, but the proponent of the opinion may disclose those inadmissible facts to the jury only if their probative value in helping the jury evaluate the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect. By contrast, under Federal Rule of Evidence 705, an expert may state an opinion without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, and the adverse party may compel disclosure of those underlying facts or data on cross-examination without meeting Rule 703's reverse balancing test. In addition, under Federal Rule of Evidence 704(b), while ultimate-issue opinions are generally permitted in civil cases and on non-mental issues, an expert in a criminal case may not state an opinion about whether the defendant did or did not have a mental state or condition that constitutes an element of the crime charged or of a defense.
Question 3 of 10Select One of Four
Presentation — Refreshing Recollection Before Versus While Testifying
In a federal civil contract trial, a warehouse manager reviews a private handwritten pocket notebook in the courthouse hallway twenty minutes before taking the witness stand in order to refresh memory of specific shipment dates. On the witness stand, the manager testifies clearly from revived memory without ever consulting or bringing the notebook into the courtroom. On cross-examination, opposing counsel learns that the manager read the notebook before testifying and demands as an absolute right to inspect the notebook and introduce relevant pages into evidence. How should the trial judge rule under Federal Rule of Evidence 612? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Federal Rule of Evidence 612 distinguishes between refreshing recollection while testifying and refreshing recollection before testifying. Under Rule 612(a)(1), when a witness uses a writing to refresh memory while testifying, an adverse party is automatically entitled as of right to inspect the writing, cross-examine the witness about it, and introduce in evidence any portion that relates to the witness's testimony. Under Rule 612(a)(2), when a witness uses a writing to refresh memory before testifying, the adverse party has those production, cross-examination, and introduction rights only if the court decides that justice requires it. Only the adverse party—not the proponent—may introduce a refreshing item under Rule 612.
Question 4 of 10Select Two of Six
Presentation — Original Writing Rule and Self-Authentication Notice
In a federal breach-of-contract action, Buyer needs to prove the price terms of a written supply agreement whose sole signed original was accidentally destroyed when a burst water pipe flooded Buyer's storage room. Buyer also seeks to introduce a certified printout of Seller's computerized shipping database accompanied by a system-process certification under Federal Rule of Evidence 902(13), though Buyer gave Seller no written notice before trial and never made the certification available for pretrial inspection. Seller previously told a friend at an informal dinner (unsworn and oral) what the contract price was. Which TWO rulings are correct under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 1002, an original writing is required to prove the contents of a contract whose terms are in issue, and under Rule 1007 an opposing party's admission excuses producing the original only if made in the opponent's testimony, deposition, or written statement—never through an unsworn oral remark at dinner. However, under Rule 1004(a), an original is excused and secondary evidence of contents is admissible when all originals are lost or destroyed without bad faith on the proponent's part, as in an accidental pipe flood. Separately, under Federal Rules of Evidence 902(11) through 902(14), certified business records, certified records generated by an electronic process or system (Rule 902(13)), and certified copied electronic device data (Rule 902(14)) self-authenticate only if the proponent gives an adverse party reasonable written notice before trial and makes the record and certification available for inspection.
Question 5 of 10Select One of Four
Presentation — Juror Testimony and Verdict-Form Transcription Mistakes
After a federal civil jury returns a $400,000 verdict for Plaintiff in a personal-injury action, Defendant moves for a new trial or correction of the judgment supported by affidavits from two jurors stating two points: (1) during deliberations, the jurors mistakenly counted Plaintiff's future medical expenses twice when calculating the damages award; and (2) the jury actually agreed upon a total award of $40,000, but the foreperson accidentally wrote "$400,000" onto the paper verdict form due to a transcription slip. Which juror affidavit testimony may the court consider under Federal Rule of Evidence 606(b)? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 606(b)(1), a juror generally may not testify about statements made or incidents that occurred during jury deliberations, the effect of anything on a juror's vote, or any juror's mental processes concerning the verdict. Rule 606(b)(2) creates three narrow exceptions: (A) extraneous prejudicial information improperly brought to the jury's attention, (B) an outside influence improperly brought to bear on any juror, and (C) a mistake made in entering the verdict onto the verdict form. A clerical transcription mistake in writing "$400,000" instead of "$40,000" onto the verdict form falls within Rule 606(b)(2)(C), whereas a substantive calculation error made during deliberations (such as double-counting medical expenses) concerns internal deliberation processes and is barred.
Question 6 of 10Select Two of Six
Privileges and Policy Exclusions — Spousal Privileges and Joint Crime
Husband and Wife remain legally married at the time of Husband's federal criminal fraud trial. Two years earlier during their marriage, while alone in their kitchen, Husband and Wife privately planned how to submit falsified invoices to a federal agency, and Husband whispered the fabricated invoice numbers to Wife to carry out the scheme. At Husband's trial, Wife voluntarily appears for the prosecution and is willing to testify about what Husband privately told Wife during that kitchen conversation. Husband objects under both spousal testimonial immunity and the confidential marital communications privilege. Under federal common law, which TWO statements are accurate? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under federal common law governed by Federal Rule of Evidence 501, the two spousal privileges operate differently. First, under Trammel v. United States, spousal testimonial immunity applies only in criminal cases, ends upon divorce, and belongs solely to the witness-spouse—meaning Husband cannot stop Wife from testifying voluntarily (and even if Wife had refused, most federal circuits reject a joint-participants exception to testimonial immunity). Second, although the confidential marital communications privilege applies in both civil and criminal cases, can be invoked by either spouse, and survives divorce, federal courts uniformly deny the marital communications privilege for private communications made to further an ongoing or future joint crime.
Question 7 of 10Select One of Four
Privileges and Policy Exclusions — Compromise Negotiations With a Public Agency
A federal environmental enforcement agency opens a civil administrative investigation against Factory Owner over disputed chemical discharge limits. During formal settlement negotiations with the agency's enforcement attorneys, Factory Owner signs a written offer to pay a $50,000 civil penalty to resolve the disputed claim and orally admits during the same meeting, "I knew our outflow valve was leaking last May." Months later, federal prosecutors indict Factory Owner for knowingly discharging pollutants, and at the criminal trial Factory Owner testifies denying any prior knowledge of the May leak. What may the prosecution introduce under Federal Rule of Evidence 408? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 408(a), settlement offers and conduct or statements made during compromise negotiations over a disputed claim are generally inadmissible to prove or disprove the validity or amount of the claim, or to impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or contradiction. However, Rule 408(a)(2) creates a specific criminal-case carve-out: conduct or statements made during compromise negotiations regarding a claim by a public office in the exercise of its regulatory, investigative, or enforcement authority are admissible in a criminal case. Importantly, that carve-out applies only to Rule 408(a)(2) (conduct or statements in negotiations); the offer or acceptance of valuable consideration to compromise the claim itself remains inadmissible even in a criminal trial under Rule 408(a)(1).
Question 8 of 10Select Two of Six
Hearsay and Confrontation — Bruton Redactions and Agency Corroboration
Codefendants Alpha and Beta are tried jointly in federal criminal court for interstate cargo theft. Before trial, Alpha gave a recorded custodial police confession stating, "Beta unlocked the warehouse gate so I could drive the van inside." Alpha exercises the Fifth Amendment right not to testify at trial. Separately, to prove Beta's delivery company employed a lookout named Driver, the prosecution offers Driver's out-of-court remark to a dock clerk ("I am working tonight for Beta's company and Beta told me to watch the gate") without offering any other evidence at trial that Driver ever worked for Beta's company. Which TWO rulings are correct under the Federal Rules of Evidence and the Sixth Amendment? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Bruton v. United States, Gray v. Maryland, and Samia v. United States, the Confrontation Clause bars introducing a nontestifying codefendant's testimonial out-of-court confession that facially incriminates the defendant at a joint trial unless the trials are severed or the confession is properly redacted. Under Samia, replacing the defendant's name with a neutral pronoun or phrase (such as "the other person") combined with a limiting instruction satisfies the Confrontation Clause, whereas obvious blanks or "[DELETED]" symbols are barred under Gray (and Bruton applies only to testimonial statements, not casual remarks to a cellmate). Separately, under the 1997 amendment to Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(2), the court considers the offered statement itself under Rule 104(a), but the statement does not by itself establish speaking authority under Rule 801(d)(2)(C), agency or employment under Rule 801(d)(2)(D), or conspiracy participation under Rule 801(d)(2)(E); independent corroborating evidence is required.
Question 9 of 10Select One of Four
Exceptions — Police Reports Under Recorded Recollection Versus Public Records
In a federal robbery trial, the prosecution seeks to prove the getaway vehicle's license-plate number recorded by a police officer in an investigative incident report ten minutes after interviewing eyewitnesses at the crime scene. On the witness stand, the officer testifies that the officer wrote the plate number carefully while it was fresh in memory and verified every character, but now has zero present recollection of the digits even after silently reading the report. Defense counsel objects that police investigative observations are barred against criminal defendants under all hearsay exceptions. How should the judge rule under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 803(8)(A)(ii), a public record setting out a matter observed by law-enforcement personnel is inadmissible against a criminal defendant, and federal courts prohibit using the business-records exception (Rule 803(6)) to bypass that restriction when the author does not testify. However, Rule 803(8)(A)(ii) does not bar a testifying police officer whose present memory is exhausted from reading the officer's own accurate report aloud into evidence as a recorded recollection under Federal Rule of Evidence 803(5), because the officer is on the witness stand subject to cross-examination. Under Rule 803(5), the record may be read into evidence, and may be received as an exhibit only if offered by an adverse party—not by the prosecution.
Question 10 of 10Select Two of Six
Impeachment and Rehabilitation — Criminal Convictions and Ten-Year Calculation
In a federal civil fraud trial, Plaintiff calls Witness to testify. Twelve years before trial, Witness was convicted of felony perjury and served three years in prison, being released from confinement nine years before trial. Fourteen years before trial, Witness was convicted of misdemeanor passing a bad check (whose elements required proving a dishonest act or false statement) and paid a fine with no jail sentence. On cross-examination, Defendant seeks to impeach Witness with both convictions, and also asks Witness about an unconvicted lie on a contractor license application three years ago, which Witness denies. Which TWO rulings are correct under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Federal Rule of Evidence 609(b), the ten-year clock is measured from the witness's conviction or release from confinement for it, whichever is later. Because Witness was released from prison for felony perjury nine years before trial, that conviction is within ten years and—because perjury's elements required proving a dishonest act or false statement—must be admitted automatically under Rule 609(a)(2) without Rule 403 balancing (unless barred by a pardon or rehabilitation certificate under Rule 609(c)). By contrast, the misdemeanor bad-check conviction had no confinement and is fourteen years old; past ten years, any conviction—including a dishonesty conviction under Rule 609(a)(2)—triggers Rule 609(b)'s strict reverse-403 balancing test and reasonable written notice requirement. Finally, under Rule 608(b), extrinsic evidence is never admissible to prove specific instances of untruthful conduct not resulting in a criminal conviction.