Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Crestline Seafood Corporation ("Crestline") sued Harborview Cold Storage LLC ("Harborview") in federal district court under a federal interstate cargo-liability statute—meaning federal substantive law and federal common law of privilege govern the action—after an overhead refrigeration evaporator unit detached inside Harborview's cold-storage warehouse and crushed $120,000 worth of Crestline's frozen scallops. Harborview denies negligence and contends the ceiling hanger snapped because of an unforeseeable internal metal fatigue defect. In the pretrial order, Harborview stipulated that it owned and controlled the cold-storage room and that installing heavy-duty steel hangers was technically and economically feasible before the incident.

Two days after the collapse, Harborview's maintenance supervisor replaced all ceiling brackets in the cold-storage room with heavy-duty steel hangers. Before any lawsuit was filed, Harborview's general counsel instructed a mid-level warehouse clerk (who is not a senior corporate executive) to inspect the fallen bolts and write a confidential email directly to general counsel explaining what the clerk saw so general counsel could advise Harborview on its legal exposure. During discovery, Harborview's outside counsel applied reasonable electronic keyword searches and quality-control review, yet accidentally produced that confidential email among 12,000 pages of warehouse files. Two days after realizing the mistake, Harborview's counsel notified Crestline's counsel in writing and requested the email's return under Federal Rule of Evidence 502(b).

Separately, before suit was filed, Crestline sent Harborview a formal demand letter seeking $120,000 for the spoiled scallops. Harborview formally disputed both liability and the valuation of the scallops. At a settlement conference attended by both companies' attorneys to compromise the disputed claim, Harborview's general manager, Nora Halvorsen, stated: "We will offer $40,000 to settle this whole dispute, and frankly our night crew never tightened the rear anchor bolts last month." At trial, Crestline also plans to introduce a printed daily warehouse maintenance log accompanied by a custodian certification complying with Federal Rule of Evidence 902(11), which Crestline served with reasonable written pretrial notice and inspection access two weeks before trial. One entry in that maintenance log quotes an outside trucking company's delivery driver who visited the dock and told the log keeper, "Those ceiling bolts looked loose to me last week."

Finally, three additional trial disputes have arisen: (1) Immediately as the evaporator unit crashed to the floor, a Harborview forklift operator standing ten feet away yelled in panic while staring at the wreckage, "The main beam tore right out of the rotted joist!" (The forklift operator later moved abroad and is unavailable for trial.) (2) Crestline intends to cross-examine Harborview's structural engineering expert using a well-known engineering manual; Harborview's expert refuses to concede the manual is authoritative, although Crestline's own engineering expert testified on direct examination that the manual is a standard reliable authority in the field. Crestline wants to read a key paragraph aloud on cross-examination and submit the entire manual to the jury as an exhibit. (3) Twelve years before trial, Nora Halvorsen was convicted of felony embezzlement and served four years in federal prison, being released from confinement eight years before trial.

Nora Halvorsen meets with you, Harborview's trial counsel, to learn which evidentiary items are likely to be admitted or excluded at trial and to review your draft motion-in-limine and trial-preparation arguments.

Checked: 0 of 3 · Score: 0 / 3

Question 1 of 5 Select One of Four

Counseling — Subsequent Remedial Measures and Corporate Attorney-Client Privilege

During your trial-preparation meeting, Nora Halvorsen asks whether Crestline can introduce Harborview's post-collapse installation of heavy-duty steel hangers to show pre-accident carelessness, and whether Crestline can keep and use the warehouse clerk's inadvertently produced email to general counsel. Which statement gives Nora the MOST accurate legal advice? (Select one.)

Select one option.

Question 2 of 5 Select Two of Six

Counseling — Compromise Negotiations and Hearsay Within Business Records

Nora asks whether Crestline can introduce Nora's settlement-conference statement ("We will offer $40,000... and frankly our night crew never tightened the rear anchor bolts") to prove liability or to impeach Nora if Nora testifies differently at trial, and whether the outside delivery driver's remark inside Harborview's certified maintenance log is admissible. Which TWO legal conclusions should you explain to Nora? (Select two.)

Select two options.

Question 3 of 5 Select One of Four

Counseling — Excited Utterances and Learned Treatises

Nora asks whether the unavailable forklift operator's exclamation at the moment of the collapse and the engineering manual paragraph can come into evidence at trial. Which advice is MOST accurate under the Federal Rules of Evidence? (Select one.)

Select one option.

Question 4 of 5 Short Written Response

Counseling — Impeachment by Prior Conviction Under Federal Rule of Evidence 609

Nora asks whether Crestline will be allowed to impeach Nora on cross-examination with Nora's felony embezzlement conviction, noting that the conviction occurred twelve years ago and Nora was released from prison eight years ago. Draft a concise three-to-five sentence counseling explanation advising Nora how the court will rule under Federal Rule of Evidence 609.

Question 5 of 5 Short Written Response

Drafting — Motion in Limine Argument and Privilege Non-Waiver File Note

Draft: (a) two to three sentences for Harborview's Motion in Limine seeking to exclude both Nora's settlement-conference statement under Federal Rule of Evidence 408 and the outside delivery driver's quoted remark in the maintenance log under Federal Rules of Evidence 803(6), 805, and Johnson v. Lutz; and (b) two sentences for an internal trial-file note explaining why Crestline cannot use the warehouse clerk's inadvertently produced email under Upjohn Co. v. United States and Federal Rule of Evidence 502(b).