To: Associate
From: Martin Delgado, Partner
Re: State v. Devon Park — Pretrial Suppression Evaluation (File No. LC-209)
Date: November 12
Our client, Devon Park, is charged in the State of Linden with felony receiving stolen property arising from a break-in at Northgate Electronics last month. Police recovered three items that the State plans to offer at trial: (a) a sealed Northgate Electronics laptop box found inside the shared living-room coat closet of Devon’s apartment; (b) a handwritten pawn-shop receipt found inside a closed nightstand drawer in Devon’s private bedroom; and (c) Devon’s recorded station-house statement admitting that Devon bought two laptops knowing they were stolen from Northgate Electronics.
Ahead of Friday’s suppression hearing, Devon needs a candid, objective assessment of which items we are likely to suppress and which items will likely be admitted. Please organize your memorandum under three clear headings:
- Whether roommate Maya Lin’s signed consent validly authorized police to search both the shared living-room coat closet and Devon’s separate bedroom under Linden Code § 19-405(a)–(b) and State v. Mercer;
- Whether Officer Cho’s search of the bedroom nightstand drawer can be upheld as a protective sweep under Linden Code § 19-405(c) or saved by inevitable discovery under Linden Code § 19-408; and
- Whether Devon’s station-house admission must be suppressed based on Devon’s initial statement at 8:15 p.m. or Detective Hollis’s false statement at 10:20 p.m. under Linden Code § 19-512 and State v. Alvarez.
Ground every conclusion in the attached Police Incident Report, Client Interview and Stipulations, and our State of Linden Library.
On November 2 at 7:30 p.m., Detective Hollis and Officer Cho arrived at 418 Linden Court, Apartment 2B, holding a valid arrest warrant for Devon Park based on probable cause for receiving stolen property. Devon Park and Maya Lin share Apartment 2B on a joint lease with a shared kitchen, shared living room, shared hallway coat closet, and two separate bedrooms on opposite ends of the back hallway.
When Detective Hollis knocked, Devon opened the front door and stepped into the foyer. After Detective Hollis announced the arrest warrant, Devon stated loudly, “You can arrest me, but you do not have permission to search this apartment.” Officers lawfully arrested Devon inside the foyer at 7:35 p.m., placed handcuffs on Devon, and escorted Devon downstairs to sit locked inside Officer Cho’s patrol car. Immediately after arresting Devon in the foyer, Officer Cho opened the unlocked hallway coat closet three feet from the foyer door to check whether anyone was hiding inside, saw a sealed Northgate Electronics laptop box on the floor, and left it untouched while walking down the back hallway. Without any report or indication that anyone else was in the apartment, Officer Cho walked into Devon’s separate bedroom at the end of the hall, opened the closed wooden drawer of Devon’s bedside nightstand, and seized a handwritten pawn-shop receipt listing a laptop serial number.
At 7:48 p.m., while Devon remained locked in the patrol car outside, Maya Lin walked into the building carrying groceries. Detective Hollis informed Maya that Devon had been arrested and asked if Maya would consent to a search of the apartment. Maya stated, “I never go into Devon’s bedroom—we keep our own bedrooms completely private—so I am only comfortable consenting to the shared living room, kitchen, and hallway closet.” Maya voluntarily signed a written consent form covering those shared spaces. Detective Hollis then opened the shared living-room coat closet and seized the sealed Northgate Electronics laptop box.
At the police station at 8:15 p.m., Detective Hollis read Devon full warnings of the right to remain silent and the right to an attorney. Devon stated clearly, “I understand my rights, and I don’t want to talk about the laptops right now.” Devon did not ask for a lawyer. Detective Hollis immediately ended the interview, returned Devon to a holding cell, and gave Devon dinner and water. At 10:20 p.m.—two hours and five minutes later—Detective Hollis brought Devon back to the interview room, read fresh warnings, and asked if Devon wanted to talk. Before Devon answered, Detective Hollis said falsely, “Your roommate Maya already gave a statement telling us you brought the stolen Northgate laptops home yesterday.” Relying on that claim, Devon signed a waiver and admitted buying two laptops from an acquaintance while knowing they were stolen from Northgate Electronics. The 10:20 p.m. session lasted twelve minutes.
Client Interview Notes (Devon Park):
Devon confirmed that Devon and Maya Lin maintain strictly separate bedrooms and never enter each other’s bedrooms without knocking and asking permission, though Devon’s bedroom door did not have a deadbolt and stood ajar when Devon walked to the front door. Devon also confirmed that both Devon and Maya routinely hang jackets and store boxes in the shared living-room coat closet. Regarding the station-house interview, Devon confirmed that Detective Hollis never raised a voice, never threatened Devon, never made any promise of bail or reduced charges, and stopped talking at 8:15 p.m. the moment Devon said Devon did not want to talk right then. Devon stated that the only reason Devon decided to confess at 10:20 p.m. was Detective Hollis’s false claim that Maya had already implicated Devon.
Joint Pretrial Hearing Stipulations:
1. Both parties stipulate that at 7:35 p.m., when Officer Cho searched Devon’s bedside nightstand drawer, no officer or prosecutor had begun preparing an affidavit or application for a search warrant for Apartment 2B, and no standardized apartment inventory was underway.
2. The State stipulates that Maya Lin never actually gave any statement implicating Devon prior to 10:20 p.m.
3. To justify the nightstand receipt, the prosecution relies solely on Maya’s consent, the protective-sweep doctrine, and inevitable discovery based on its argument that police had probable cause and could have sought a search warrant later that night.