NextGen Contracts · 24-Minute Integrated Question Set
Integrated Set 1: Counseling & Drafting — The Delayed Mixers at Hearthstone Bakehouse
Read the client intake facts below and complete all five mixed-form counseling and drafting questions.
Fact Pattern
On April 1, Nadia Okafor, owner of Hearthstone Bakehouse LLC ('Hearthstone'), a retail and wholesale bakery in the town of Alderwood, signed a written contract with Summit Kitchen Equipment Co. ('Summit'), a merchant manufacturer and dealer of commercial bakery machinery. Under the contract, Summit agreed to manufacture and deliver two custom heavy-duty commercial dough mixers (Model M-400) for a total price of $40,000 ($20,000 each), with delivery due on June 1. Hearthstone paid an $8,000 deposit at signing and agreed to pay the $32,000 balance upon delivery.
The signed written contract included a typed specification near the top: 'Each mixer includes a reinforced planetary gearbox guaranteed to handle 150-pound high-hydration dough batches.' In bold capital letters on the front signature page, the contract also stated: 'ALL GOODS SOLD AS IS.' Nothing in the contract mentioned warranty of title.
On May 10, Summit's sales manager emailed Nadia that factory steel delays prevented delivery on June 1 and asked whether Hearthstone would accept delivery on June 15 instead. Hoping to avoid finding a replacement supplier, Nadia replied by email: 'We can live with June 15 as a one-time courtesy, provided you confirm both mixers will arrive in time for our wholesale launch.' Neither party signed a formal amendment, and Summit gave no consideration for the extra two weeks. On May 15, Crestline Foods ('Crestline'), a regional grocery chain, notified Hearthstone that Crestline was moving its wholesale launch up to June 5 and would cancel its launch order unless Hearthstone had full mixer capacity by June 5. On May 16—before Summit had shipped the mixers, paid overtime freight, or changed its production schedule—Nadia emailed Summit: 'Our grocery launch moved up to June 5; we are retracting our courtesy extension and require delivery on the original June 1 contract date.'
On May 20, Summit replied in writing: 'We reject your retraction, and because our raw steel costs jumped 15 percent last month, we will not deliver on June 1 or June 15 unless you agree to pay $46,000 total instead of $40,000.' On May 22, Hearthstone sent Summit a formal written demand for adequate assurance under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-609, requesting written confirmation within five days (given the imminent June 1 deadline) that Summit would deliver at the $40,000 contract price. Summit ignored the demand for six days and then emailed on May 28 refusing to deliver for less than $46,000.
On May 29, Hearthstone canceled the Summit contract and promptly purchased two comparable replacement mixers in good faith from Ironwood Machinery for $47,000 total ($7,000 above the $40,000 contract price), plus $600 in expedited freight charges, while saving $200 in local rigging fees that Hearthstone would have paid under Summit's delivery terms. Ironwood delivered the mixers on June 3, so Hearthstone missed Crestline's June 5 launch and lost $5,000 in documented net profit on the Crestline order. Summit had never been told at the April 1 signing about Crestline Foods or any June launch deadline. Nadia comes to your law office for advice on warranties, waiver and repudiation, recoverable damages, and drafting a pre-suit demand letter and file note.
Checked: 0 of 3 · Score: 0 / 3
Question 1 of 5Select One of Four
Counseling — Express Warranty, Warranty of Title & 'As Is' Disclaimer
During the intake conference, Nadia points to the bold 'ALL GOODS SOLD AS IS' clause on the April 1 contract and asks whether that language would have wiped out Summit's promise about the 150-pound planetary gearbox as well as Summit's implied warranties and warranty of title if the mixers had been delivered. Which legal advice is MOST accurate? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-316(3)(a), a conspicuous 'as is' clause excludes implied warranties of quality (the implied warranty of merchantability and any implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose) without needing to use the word 'merchantability.' However, under Section 2-316(1), general disclaimer or 'as is' language cannot negate an express warranty created by a factual specification such as the typed 150-pound gearbox guarantee, because the disclaimer and express guarantee cannot be read consistently together. Likewise, under Section 2-312(2), the statutory warranty of title is not treated as an implied warranty under Section 2-316 and cannot be disclaimed by 'as is' language; excluding title requires specific language or circumstances alerting the buyer that the seller does not claim title.
Nadia asks whether her May 10 email permanently locked Hearthstone into a June 15 delivery date, and whether Summit was entitled to 30 full days to answer Hearthstone's May 22 assurance letter. Which TWO legal points should you explain to Nadia? (Select two.)
Select two options.
Explanation
Under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-209(4) and (5), a party who waives an executory term (such as Nadia's May 10 email offering a 'one-time courtesy' extension conditioned on Summit confirming timely arrival for the wholesale launch—which Summit never confirmed—without executing an unconditional modification) may retract the waiver by reasonable notification received by the other party unless retraction would be unjust because of a material change of position in reliance on the waiver. Because Summit had not shipped, paid overtime freight, or altered its schedule before May 16, Nadia's retraction reinstated the June 1 deadline. Furthermore, under Section 2-609(1) and (4), a party with reasonable grounds for insecurity may demand adequate assurance in writing, and failure to provide assurance within a reasonable time not exceeding 30 days constitutes a repudiation. Thirty days is an outer ceiling rather than a guaranteed minimum grace period; with June 1 only ten days away, ignoring the demand for six days and then refusing to deliver at $40,000 confirmed Summit's repudiation.
Nadia asks for the exact dollar amount Hearthstone can recover from Summit under UCC Article 2, including whether Hearthstone can recover the $5,000 lost profit from Crestline Foods' canceled launch order. Which calculation and legal explanation is MOST accurate? (Select one.)
Select one option.
Explanation
Under Uniform Commercial Code Sections 2-711(1) and 2-712(2), an aggrieved buyer who rightfully cancels and covers in good faith without unreasonable delay recovers so much of the price as has been paid ($8,000 deposit), plus the difference between the cost of cover ($47,000) and the contract price ($40,000), which is $7,000, together with incidental damages ($600 expedited freight), less expenses saved in consequence of the seller's breach ($200 local rigging fees), totaling $15,400. Under Section 2-715(2)(a) and Hadley v. Baxendale, consequential damages are recoverable only for loss resulting from general or particular requirements of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know. Because Summit was never informed on April 1 about Crestline Foods or a June launch deadline—and Crestline moved its launch up only on May 15—the $5,000 lost profit is unforeseeable and excluded.
Nadia tells you Summit's sales manager insisted that the 15 percent steel price spike excused Summit from delivering at $40,000 and that UCC Article 2 lets a seller raise the price without new consideration. Draft a concise 3-to-5 sentence counseling explanation advising Nadia why both of Summit's arguments fail.
Model Response
Both of Summit's arguments fail under Uniform Commercial Code Article 2. First, under Section 2-615, commercial impracticability excuses a seller only when an unforeseen event whose non-occurrence was a basic assumption of the contract makes performance impracticable, and a modest 15 percent rise in raw steel costs is an ordinary market risk that a fixed-price manufacturer assumes rather than an excuse for non-delivery. Second, while Section 2-209(1) allows a modification of a goods contract without new consideration, any modification still requires mutual assent and must meet the duty of good faith—defined in Section 1-201(b)(20) as honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing. Because Hearthstone never agreed to $46,000 and Summit used an unjustified threat of non-delivery to extort a higher price, no enforceable modification occurred.
Key Points
Explains that under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-615, a 15 percent increase in steel costs is an ordinary market fluctuation assumed by a fixed-price seller and does not establish commercial impracticability.
Notes that while Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-209(1) dispenses with consideration, a modification still requires mutual assent, which Hearthstone never gave.
Explains that every Article 2 modification requires good faith under Sections 1-201(b)(20) and 2-209 (honesty in fact and reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing).
Concludes that threatening to withhold delivery without an adequate commercial excuse in order to extract $6,000 violates good faith.
Explanation
Under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-615, commercial impracticability discharges performance only when an unforeseen contingency whose non-occurrence was a basic assumption of the contract makes performance impracticable, and an ordinary 15 percent raw-material cost increase does not satisfy that high standard because a fixed-price seller assumes normal market price fluctuations. Under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-209(1), although a contract modification needs no consideration, it still requires mutual assent and must satisfy the obligation of good faith—honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing under Section 1-201(b)(20). Hearthstone never assented to $46,000, and threatening to withhold delivery over a modest 15 percent steel increase in order to extract an extra $6,000 lacks a legitimate commercial reason and violates good faith.
Question 5 of 5Short Written Response
Drafting — Demand Letter Paragraph & Internal Damages/Deposit Note
You are preparing a pre-suit demand letter to Summit and an internal memorandum note for your supervising partner. Draft: (a) two to three sentences for the demand letter explaining Summit's anticipatory repudiation and demanding the exact $15,400 recovery under Uniform Commercial Code Article 2; and (b) two to three sentences for the internal file note explaining whether Summit could have recovered consequential damages if Hearthstone had been the breaching buyer, and how Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-718(2) would treat a breaching buyer's $8,000 deposit refund claim in the absence of a liquidated-damages clause.
Model Response
(a) Demand Letter Paragraph: Summit Kitchen Equipment Co. committed an anticipatory repudiation of the April 1 mixer contract when it demanded an unexcused $6,000 price increase, failed to provide timely written assurance after Hearthstone Bakehouse LLC's May 22 demand under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-609, and flatly refused on May 28 to deliver at the $40,000 contract price. Following Summit's breach, Hearthstone lawfully canceled and covered in good faith under Sections 2-711 and 2-712, entitling Hearthstone to $15,400 in total damages—comprising the $8,000 deposit refund, $7,000 in cover price difference, and $600 in expedited freight, less $200 in saved local rigging expenses. Please remit $15,400 within ten business days to avoid litigation.
(b) Internal Damages and Deposit Note: Had Hearthstone been the breaching buyer instead, Summit could have recovered resale or market damages plus incidental damages, but could not have recovered consequential damages because Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-710 denies consequential damages to aggrieved sellers. Furthermore, absent a valid liquidated-damages clause, Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-718(2)(b) would allow Summit to retain out of Hearthstone's $8,000 deposit only the smaller of 20 percent of the $40,000 contract price ($8,000) or $500—meaning $500—unless Summit proves greater actual damages under Section 2-718(3) (retaining the greater of $500 or provable actual damages rather than stacking $500 on top of actual damages), requiring restitution of the remaining deposit.
Key Points
Demand letter identifies Summit's May 20 price demand, failure to give timely written assurance under Section 2-609, and May 28 refusal as an anticipatory repudiation.
Demand letter states the $15,400 total and breaks down the $8,000 deposit refund, $7,000 cover difference, $600 expedited freight, and $200 saved rigging expenses.
Internal note states that under Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-710, an aggrieved seller may recover incidental damages but cannot recover consequential damages.
Internal note applies Uniform Commercial Code Section 2-718(2)(b) and (3) to explain that absent a liquidated-damages clause, a withholding seller keeps the smaller of 20 percent of contract value ($8,000) or $500 ($500 here), or any greater actual damages the seller proves under Section 2-718(3), and returns the balance.
Explanation
The demand letter should clearly identify Summit's May 20 demand for an unexcused $6,000 price increase, Summit's failure to provide written assurance under Section 2-609, and Summit's May 28 refusal to perform as an anticipatory repudiation, and demand $15,400 ($8,000 deposit refund plus $7,000 cover differential plus $600 expedited shipping minus $200 saved rigging costs). The internal file note should address the Article 2 asymmetry under Section 2-710: an aggrieved seller may recover incidental damages, but may never recover consequential damages. Finally, under Section 2-718(2)(b) and (3), if a buyer breaches and there is no liquidated-damages clause, the withholding seller may retain the smaller of 20 percent of the total contract value ($8,000) or $500—here $500—unless the seller proves greater actual damages under Section 2-718(3) (in which case the seller retains the greater of $500 or provable actual damages, not both stacked), and must return the balance of the $8,000 deposit.