Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Six months ago, Claire Sato, an agricultural consultant then domiciled in State A, hired Suncrest Energy Systems Inc. ("Suncrest") to design and install a $140,000 commercial solar microgrid at Claire's Riverbend produce warehouse in State A. Suncrest is incorporated in State C and maintains its corporate headquarters and executive offices—where its senior officers direct and control all company operations—in State B. Suncrest also operates a regional panel-assembly plant in State A, and its sales team actively solicited agricultural buyers across State A, installing twelve similar microgrids in State A over the past two years.

During the Riverbend installation, Suncrest subcontracted the high-voltage inverter wiring to Kestrel Electrical LLC ("Kestrel"), a limited liability company organized in State C with two members: one individual domiciled in State C and one individual domiciled in State A. Two weeks after commissioning, an uninsulated inverter splice shorted out, destroying the warehouse battery bank ($110,000 in replacement costs) and shutting down Claire's cold-storage rooms ($40,000 in lost cold-storage rental revenue). Claire filed a diversity complaint in the United States District Court for the District of State A against Suncrest alone, seeking $150,000 under State A negligence and contract law. A private process server over age eighteen who was not a party served Suncrest's managing agent in State A.

Two months after filing the complaint, Claire accepted a permanent position and moved her domicile to State B. Suncrest then moved to dismiss for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction (arguing Claire's move to State B destroyed diversity), lack of personal jurisdiction (arguing its State A assembly plant does not make it at home in State A), and improper service (citing a State A statute requiring summonses to be served solely by a county sheriff). Assume State A's long-arm statute reaches the full extent of constitutional due process, and a separate State A statute caps consequential lost-revenue damages on commercial installation claims at $25,000.

Claire comes to your law office seeking counseling on Suncrest's motions, whether she must or may add Kestrel as a defendant, how discovery and sanctions disputes should be handled, and help drafting her opposition to a later summary judgment motion and an internal relation-back memorandum.

Checked: 0 of 3 · Score: 0 / 3

Question 1 of 5 Select One of Four

Counseling — Diversity Timing and Specific Personal Jurisdiction

During the client counseling meeting, Claire asks whether Suncrest's motions to dismiss for lack of diversity jurisdiction and lack of personal jurisdiction are likely to succeed. Which advice is MOST accurate? (Select one.)

Select one option.

Question 2 of 5 Select Two of Six

Counseling — Rule 14 Impleader, Rule 19, and Supplemental Jurisdiction

Suppose the district court denies Suncrest's threshold motions, and Suncrest serves an answer followed within ten days by a third-party complaint under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 14(a) against Kestrel Electrical LLC seeking contractual indemnity for the inverter wiring. Claire asks whether Kestrel is a required party under Rule 19 that must be joined for the case to proceed, and whether Claire can amend her complaint to assert a direct $60,000 state-law negligence claim against Kestrel. Which TWO legal points should you explain to Claire? (Select two.)

Select two options.

Question 3 of 5 Select One of Four

Counseling — Erie Doctrine and Federal Rules Enabling Act Analysis

Claire asks how the federal district court should resolve two State A laws invoked by Suncrest: (1) the State A statute requiring civil summonses to be served solely by a county sheriff rather than a private nonparty adult, and (2) the State A statute capping consequential lost-revenue damages on commercial installation claims at $25,000. Which counseling advice is MOST accurate under the Erie doctrine? (Select one.)

Select one option.

Question 4 of 5 Short Written Response

Counseling — Rule 37(e) Electronically Stored Information and Rule 11 Limits

During discovery, Suncrest's project manager realizes that a routine thirty-day server auto-purge deleted two weeks of installation diagnostic logs after Claire sent a formal litigation demand letter, although there is no evidence that Suncrest intended to hide evidence. Separately, Suncrest's attorney serves Claire's counsel with a Rule 11 sanctions motion accusing Claire's Rule 34 document requests of being overly broad and files that Rule 11 motion with the district court the very next morning without waiting. Draft a concise four-to-six sentence counseling explanation advising Claire on (a) whether the court may give an adverse-inference instruction or enter default judgment under Rule 37(e) for the lost logs, and (b) two independent reasons why Suncrest's Rule 11 motion must be denied.

Question 5 of 5 Short Written Response

Drafting — Summary Judgment Opposition and Rule 15(c) Relation-Back Note

Later in the case, Suncrest moves for summary judgment on Claire's negligence claim, submitting a sworn field-engineer affidavit stating that the inverter wiring complied with all industry standards. Claire possesses a signed inspection report from an independent electrical inspector identifying bare, uninsulated splices and a sworn deposition transcript in which Suncrest's installer admits leaving two splices uncapped, yet Claire suggests saving time by submitting a brief that merely quotes her unverified complaint. Separately, Claire asks whether an amended complaint changing the named installer on an added claim to a corporate subsidiary, "Suncrest Grid Services LLC," relates back past the expired statute of limitations when the subsidiary's general counsel received actual notice of the original lawsuit forty days after filing and knew the subsidiary had performed part of the work. Draft: (a) two or three sentences for Claire's summary judgment opposition brief explaining why summary judgment must be denied (and why quoting the complaint alone would fail); and (b) two or three sentences for an internal file note analyzing relation back under Rule 15(c)(1)(C).