Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

In Year 1, Casey married Alex in a ceremonial wedding in Cedar, State A, believing in good faith that Alex's prior marriage had already ended by divorce. Unknown to Casey, Alex's prior divorce decree was not signed and entered until six months after the Year 1 wedding. Casey and Alex continued living together in State A as spouses for four more years, during which their child, Child A, was born. In Year 5, Casey discovered the six-month overlap for the first time and filed for divorce in State A. Alex argues their marriage was void from the start so Casey has no spousal property or support rights. Assume State A follows the Uniform Marriage and Divorce Act (UMDA).

Before meeting Casey, Alex had a nonmarital infant, Child B, with Lee in State A. Alex never lived with Lee or Child B, never visited Child B, paid no support, and never registered on State A's putative-father registry despite knowing of Child B's birth. Two years later, Lee's new spouse petitioned to adopt Child B. Alex objected, claiming an absolute biological right to veto the adoption.

Meanwhile, in the Year 5 State A divorce action involving Child A, State A entered a valid child support order requiring Alex—an experienced architect earning $120,000 per year—to pay $1,800 monthly under State A's guidelines (under which support runs until age 21). After falling $5,400 behind on payments, Alex quit the architecture firm to take a $25,000 part-time tutoring job specifically to reduce support. Casey and Child A later moved permanently to State B (where child support ends at age 18), while Alex remained domiciled in State A. Casey registered the State A order in State B, and Alex then moved in State B court to forgive the $5,400 arrears, lower future monthly support based on Alex's $25,000 income, and cap support at age 18. Assume both states have enacted UIFSA.

Call of the Question

Under general United States family law and federal and uniform statutes, how should the courts rule on: (1) the validity of Casey and Alex's marriage and Casey's marital rights, (2) Alex's objection to the stepparent adoption of Child B, (3) Alex's motions to forgive the $5,400 arrears and reduce future child support based on the tutoring job, and (4) State B's authority under UIFSA to modify the State A support order or shorten its duration?