Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Before marrying Jordan, Pat owned a small house in Linden valued at $220,000, subject to a $160,000 mortgage. Two days before the wedding—after out-of-town relatives had arrived and nonrefundable reception deposits had been paid—Pat presented Jordan with a premarital agreement drafted by Pat's attorney. The agreement stated that all property titled in either spouse's sole name would remain separate property and that neither spouse could receive spousal support upon divorce. Pat attached no list of assets or debts, told Jordan there was no time to consult a lawyer, and warned that the wedding would be canceled unless Jordan signed immediately. Jordan signed without reading the financial clauses.

During the seven-year marriage, Jordan worked full time as a retail manager earning $52,000 per year to cover household bills while Pat attended dental school and opened a solo dental practice in Linden. Using marital earnings from a joint account, the couple paid down $50,000 of the mortgage principal on Pat's house and spent $30,000 remodeling the kitchen. By the time Pat filed for no-fault divorce, the house was worth $360,000 (due both to the remodel and general neighborhood appreciation), Pat's dental license and practice were flourishing, and Pat had secretly spent $40,000 from the couple's joint savings account on casino trips over the prior three months while preparing to file.

Jordan seeks to set aside the premarital agreement, claim a share of the house, the dental degree, and the dental practice, obtain an offset for the casino spending, and receive spousal support.

Call of the Question

Under general United States family law (an equitable-distribution jurisdiction that has adopted the Uniform Premarital Agreement Act), how should the court rule on: (1) the premarital agreement, (2) property classification and division (including the house, dental degree/practice, and casino spending), and (3) Jordan's request for spousal support?