Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Owner is on trial in federal district court for federal arson after a fire destroyed Owner's heavily insured warehouse in the town of Oakridge. No homicide charge was filed. Owner pleads not guilty and claims the fire was an electrical accident.

During its case-in-chief—before Owner puts on any evidence—the prosecution offers four items of proof, to all of which Owner timely objects:

(1) Testimony from Former Partner (a) that Owner has a reputation in Oakridge for dishonesty and financial greed, and (b), offered after the prosecution gave proper written pretrial notice, that three years earlier Owner intentionally burned down a failing retail kiosk to collect insurance money.

(2) Testimony from Spouse, whom Owner married six months before the warehouse fire and remains married to at trial. Spouse is willing to testify for the prosecution (a) that Spouse saw Owner load five red gasoline cans into Owner's van on the night of the fire, and (b) that two nights before the fire, Owner privately told Spouse at their kitchen table with nobody else home: "Don't worry about the mortgage—the warehouse won't be standing Friday." Owner invokes both spousal privileges.

(3) Testimony from Store Clerk to prove Owner bought five gasoline cans on the afternoon of the fire. On the witness stand, Clerk testifies, "I genuinely have no memory of selling anyone gas cans that day." The prosecutor shows Clerk a handwritten receipt Clerk made immediately after the sale; Clerk reads it silently and says, "I still do not remember the sale, though I know I wrote this receipt accurately right after ringing up the customer." The prosecutor asks to read the receipt aloud and admit the paper receipt as a prosecution exhibit. On cross-examination, defense counsel confronts Clerk with an unsworn signed statement Clerk gave a defense investigator saying Owner never entered the store that afternoon; Clerk denies making the statement, and defense counsel offers the signed statement both to impeach Clerk and to prove Owner was absent.

(4) Two out-of-court accusations: First, a recording of a 911 call placed while the warehouse was actively burning by Night Guard, who was trapped inside suffering severe smoke inhalation and gasped, "The building is on fire—Owner locked the side door and ran out with a torch!" Night Guard died at the hospital two days later. Second, testimony from Cellmate that Accomplice—who properly invoked the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination and refused to testify—bragged to Cellmate in jail: "I disabled the warehouse sprinklers because Owner paid me five hundred dollars."

Call of the Question

Under the Federal Rules of Evidence and the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause, how should the court rule on each of the four evidentiary disputes, and why?