Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Pedestrian sued Freight Co. in federal district court under diversity jurisdiction, alleging that Driver, an employee of Freight Co., negligently backed a delivery truck into Pedestrian on a commercial loading dock in the town of Linden. Freight Co. stipulated that it owned and controlled the truck, that Driver acted within the scope of employment, and that installing backup cameras or audible alarms on its trucks was technically and financially feasible before the collision. State law in the forum recognizes a statutory physician-patient privilege that is waived when a patient places a physical condition in controversy in litigation.

At trial, Pedestrian seeks to introduce the following items of evidence, to each of which Freight Co. objects:

(1) Evidence that two days after the collision, Freight Co. installed audible backup alarms and convex blind-spot mirrors on all of its loading-dock trucks, together with Freight Co.'s commercial liability insurance policy showing coverage limits of five million dollars, offered to prove Freight Co. failed to exercise reasonable care before the crash.

(2) An authenticated official police accident report prepared by Officer, who responded to the scene. The report quotes Driver—who was still employed by Freight Co. as a delivery driver and stood visibly shaking beside the truck five minutes after the collision—as telling Officer, "I never checked my side mirror because my dispatch boss ordered me to rush this drop." The report also quotes Bystander, who walked up calmly twenty minutes later, as saying, "I saw the truck moving much too fast for a loading dock."

In its defense case, Freight Co. calls Dock Worker, who testifies that Pedestrian stepped suddenly behind the reversing truck. On cross-examination, Pedestrian asks Dock Worker (a) whether Dock Worker was convicted six years ago of misdemeanor check fraud carrying a maximum six-month sentence, and (b) whether Dock Worker lied about prior job dates on an employment application four years ago. Dock Worker admits the check-fraud conviction but denies lying on the application. Pedestrian moves to introduce the written job application and call Former Employer to prove the lie.

Finally, Freight Co. subpoenas Doctor, Pedestrian's treating orthopedist, to testify that during a medical exam after the collision, Pedestrian told Doctor: "My lower back was already hurt two years ago lifting crates, and today the truck barely tapped me because the dock boss yelled at me to hurry." Pedestrian objects based on physician-patient privilege and hearsay.

Call of the Question

Under the Federal Rules of Evidence, how should the court rule on each of the four evidentiary disputes, and why?