Fact Pattern
Planner and Helper lived in the town of Linden. One Tuesday evening, Planner proposed that the two of them break into an old commercial storage warehouse owned by Owner at midnight to steal valuable copper cable stored inside. Believing the warehouse was empty at night, Helper agreed to help break in and load the cable, though Planner warned, "Bring a bolt cutter for the gate padlock, and do not hurt anyone." Unknown to Helper, Planner privately planned to sell the cable to Buyer and keep all the money without telling Helper.
Before midnight, Helper used Helper's own money to buy heavy bolt cutters from a hardware store and placed them inside Planner's car trunk. At 11:00 p.m., while waiting at a diner two miles from the warehouse, Helper got cold feet. Helper texted Planner: "I'm out. Don't do this. I'm going home." Helper then walked straight home without retrieving the bolt cutters from Planner's trunk and without warning Owner or the Linden police.
At 11:45 p.m., Planner drove alone to the warehouse, took Helper's bolt cutters from the trunk, cut the padlock off the side door, and pushed the door open to enter. As Planner began unspooling copper cable, Watchman—a security guard who occasionally napped on a folding cot in a back office during night shifts—heard the noise, walked into the storage bay, and swung a heavy flashlight at Planner's shoulder. Planner ducked, grabbed a steel pipe from the floor, and struck Watchman forcefully across the head, killing Watchman instantly. Hearing sirens in the distance, Planner panicked and fled empty-handed without taking any copper cable.
Call of the Question
Under general United States criminal law (addressing both common law and the Model Penal Code where they differ), what crimes, theories of liability, and defenses apply to Planner and Helper, and what are the likely outcomes?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Conspiracy and Withdrawal (Planner and Helper)
Issue: Are Planner and Helper guilty of conspiracy to commit burglary and larceny, and did either Planner's secret plan to cheat Helper or Helper's text message defeat conspiracy liability?
Rule: Conspiracy requires (1) an agreement between two or more persons, (2) intent to agree, and (3) specific intent to achieve an unlawful objective. Common law (the MBE default rule) and federal law follow a bilateral rule (at least two guilty minds must genuinely agree, so agreeing solely with an undercover officer or feigning informant is not a conspiracy), whereas the Model Penal Code (MPC) and many modern state statutes adopt a unilateral rule (one party's genuine agreement suffices). Separately, common law requires no overt act, whereas the MPC, federal general conspiracy, and most modern statutes require an overt act by any conspirator. Under common law, withdrawal is never a defense to the conspiracy itself once formed (though timely notice to co-conspirators cuts off future Pinkerton vicarious liability for later crimes); under the MPC, renunciation is a defense only if the conspirator thwarts the conspiracy's success.
Application: Both Planner and Helper genuinely agreed to break into Owner's warehouse and steal copper cable. Even though Planner secretly intended to keep the resale proceeds from Buyer, both parties shared the unlawful objective of breaking in and stealing Owner's cable, satisfying even the common-law bilateral rule. Helper's purchase of the bolt cutters also satisfied the modern/MPC overt-act requirement. Helper's 11:00 p.m. text message ("I'm out") came after the agreement and overt act were complete, so under common law Helper remains guilty of conspiracy; under the MPC, Helper likewise fails to establish renunciation because Helper did not thwart the crime by retrieving the bolt cutters or alerting police. However, by explicitly communicating withdrawal to Planner before Planner drove to the warehouse, Helper terminated Pinkerton vicarious liability for Planner's subsequent substantive offenses.
Conclusion: Both Planner and Helper are guilty of conspiracy to commit burglary/larceny (which does not merge at common law, though the MPC merges conspiracy into the target offense), while Helper's notice cuts off Pinkerton liability for Planner's later crimes.
2. Accomplice Liability and Withdrawal (Helper for Planner's Later Crimes)
Issue: Is Helper liable as an accomplice for Planner's break-in, attempted theft, and the killing of Watchman despite texting "I'm out" beforehand?
Rule: An accomplice is liable for the principal's substantive crime if the accomplice aids, counsels, or encourages the principal with the purpose or intent that the crime be committed. At common law (the traditional MBE default rule), an accomplice is also liable for any other crimes that are a natural and probable (foreseeable) consequence of the aided offense, whereas the MPC and a substantial modern trend reject natural-and-probable-consequences liability and limit accomplice liability to offenses the accomplice purposely promoted (though an accomplice to an inherently dangerous felony may still face distinct felony-murder accomplice liability if a death occurs in furtherance of that felony). To withdraw effectively from accomplice liability before the crime becomes unstoppable, one who merely gave verbal encouragement need only repudiate it, whereas one who supplied physical aid must neutralize that assistance—by retrieving the tool or making a timely warning to authorities.
Application: Helper supplied the heavy bolt cutters with the specific purpose of helping Planner cut the warehouse lock, and Planner actually used those bolt cutters to break in. Because Helper provided physical aid, merely texting "I'm out, don't do this" from the diner did not neutralize Helper's contribution; Helper left the bolt cutters in Planner's trunk and neither recovered them nor warned Owner or Linden police. Thus, Helper did not effectively withdraw as an accomplice and remains liable for Planner's burglary and attempted larceny. As to Watchman's death, Planner had told Helper "do not hurt anyone" and both believed the warehouse was empty. Under the MPC and modern jurisdictions rejecting natural-and-probable-consequences liability (and where commercial burglary is not an inherently dangerous predicate), Helper lacked purpose to promote homicide and is not liable for it. Under the traditional common-law natural-and-probable-consequences rule, however, a prosecutor will argue that a violent confrontation during a nighttime break-in is foreseeable; separately, in a jurisdiction treating statutory commercial burglary as an inherently dangerous felony, Helper could face felony-murder accomplice liability because Watchman died during and in furtherance of the aided burglary.
Conclusion: Helper failed to neutralize physical aid, leaving Helper liable as an accomplice for the break-in and attempted larceny, and potentially for Watchman's death under traditional common-law natural-and-probable-consequences jurisdictions or felony-murder accomplice principles where statutory burglary qualifies as inherently dangerous (though not under the MPC).
3. Burglary and Attempted Larceny (Planner)
Issue: Is Planner guilty of common-law burglary, statutory burglary, and larceny or attempted larceny?
Rule: Common-law burglary requires (1) a breaking, (2) and entering, (3) of the dwelling house of another, (4) at nighttime, (5) with the specific intent to commit a felony therein at the moment of entry. A structure is a "dwelling" only if regularly used for sleeping; an industrial warehouse where a guard occasionally naps is generally not a dwelling. Modern statutory burglary eliminates the breaking, dwelling, and nighttime elements, covering unauthorized entry into any structure with intent to commit a felony or theft. Larceny is the trespassory taking and carrying away of another's personal property with intent to permanently deprive; attempt requires specific intent plus a substantial step beyond mere preparation.
Application: Planner cut the padlock and pushed open the side door (breaking), walked inside (entering), at 11:45 p.m. (nighttime), intending to steal copper cable (felony/theft). However, the building was a commercial storage warehouse, not a residence regularly used for sleeping—Watchman's occasional napping on a cot during shifts does not convert a commercial warehouse into a common-law dwelling. Thus, common-law burglary fails, though Planner is clearly guilty of modern statutory burglary. Because Planner panicked and fled without carrying away any copper cable, completed larceny fails for lack of asportation, but unspooling the cable after breaking in is a substantial step with specific intent to steal, establishing attempted larceny.
Conclusion: Planner is not guilty of common-law burglary (no dwelling) or completed larceny (no asportation), but is guilty of modern statutory burglary and attempted larceny.
4. Homicide: Felony Murder, Murder, and Self-Defense (Planner)
Issue: Is Planner guilty of felony murder or common-law murder for striking and killing Watchman, or can Planner claim self-defense or provocation?
Rule: Common-law murder is an unlawful killing with malice aforethought: intent to kill, intent to cause grievous bodily harm, depraved-heart recklessness, or felony murder (a death caused during an inherently dangerous independent felony). An initial aggressor—including a burglar unlawfully invading property—loses the right of self-defense unless the aggressor withdraws or a non-deadly aggressor is met with disproportionate deadly force. Voluntary manslaughter requires adequate provocation, never satisfied by a lawful property defender resisting a crime.
Application: By striking Watchman across the head with a heavy steel pipe, Planner acted with at least intent to inflict grievous bodily harm (if not intent to kill) or depraved-heart indifference to life, establishing malice aforethought for second-degree murder. In addition, Watchman died during Planner's statutory burglary. (Attempted grand larceny is a non-violent property offense and is not inherently dangerous to human life, so it cannot serve as a felony-murder predicate.) Where statutory commercial burglary is treated as an inherently dangerous independent felony (it does not merge into homicide because its purpose is theft, not assault), felony murder also applies. Self-defense fails: Planner was an unlawful intruder committing a felony, never withdrew, and responded to Watchman swinging a flashlight—likely non-deadly defensive force by a guard—with lethal force to the head. Nor does a guard defending premises supply adequate provocation for voluntary manslaughter.
Conclusion: Planner has no valid self-defense or provocation claim and is guilty of murder (second-degree malice murder and, where statutory burglary qualifies as inherently dangerous, felony murder).
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Conspiracy and Withdrawal (5 Points)
- 1 pt States conspiracy elements (agreement, intent to agree, intent for unlawful objective; bilateral at common law/federal vs. unilateral under MPC, plus overt act under modern/federal/MPC law).
- 1 pt Explains why Planner's secret plan to cheat Helper out of resale money does not negate bilateral agreement to steal Owner's cable.
- 1 pt Identifies buying the bolt cutters as an overt act completing the conspiracy before Helper's text.
- 1 pt Distinguishes common law (no withdrawal from conspiracy itself) vs. MPC (renunciation requires thwarting the crime).
- 1 pt Concludes Helper's notice terminated Pinkerton liability for Planner's future crimes, while leaving both guilty of conspiracy.
Issue 2: Accomplice Liability and Withdrawal (5 Points)
- 1 pt States accomplice liability elements (affirmative aid/encouragement with intent the target crime succeed).
- 1 pt States the withdrawal rule for physical aid (must neutralize aid by retrieving tools or warning police, not mere words).
- 1 pt Applies facts: Helper left bolt cutters in Planner's trunk and did not retrieve them or warn authorities, so withdrawal failed.
- 1 pt Distinguishes traditional common-law natural-and-probable-consequences liability (and distinct felony-murder accomplice liability for an inherently dangerous predicate) from the MPC/modern rule limiting accomplice liability to purposely promoted crimes.
- 1 pt Concludes Helper is guilty of burglary/attempted larceny and analyzes the split on Watchman's homicide.
Issue 3: Burglary and Attempted Larceny (5 Points)
- 1 pt Lists all five elements of common-law burglary (breaking, entering, dwelling of another, nighttime, felonious intent at entry).
- 1 pt Evaluates the dwelling element: a commercial warehouse where a guard occasionally naps is not a common-law dwelling.
- 1 pt Contrasts modern statutory burglary (covers any structure regardless of dwelling or nighttime) and concludes Planner committed statutory burglary.
- 1 pt Rules out completed larceny because Planner fled empty-handed without carrying away (asportation) the cable.
- 1 pt Establishes attempted larceny via specific intent to steal plus breaking in and unspooling cable (substantial step).
Issue 4: Homicide and Self-Defense (5 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies malice aforethought for second-degree murder via intent to inflict grievous bodily harm or depraved-heart recklessness (steel pipe to the head).
- 1 pt Analyzes felony murder (explaining that attempted larceny is not inherently dangerous, whereas statutory burglary may qualify where treated as inherently dangerous and does not merge because its purpose is theft rather than assault).
- 1 pt Rejects self-defense because Planner was an unlawful felonious aggressor who never withdrew and used disproportionate deadly force against a flashlight.
- 1 pt Rejects voluntary manslaughter / provocation because a guard lawfully resisting a break-in is not adequate provocation.
- 1 pt Concludes Planner is guilty of murder.