Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Buyer is Millford Supply, a dealer that buys and resells restaurant goods. Seller is Kiln, a manufacturer of ceramic mugs. Both deal in mugs.

On June 1, Buyer sent Kiln a signed purchase order: "400 model C-12 mugs at $8 each. Delivery by July 1. Payment on delivery." On June 1, Kiln replied with a signed acknowledgment. It repeated the quantity, the model, the price, and the July 1 date. In the same ordinary type as the rest of the page, it added two sentences: "All implied warranties are disclaimed. Any dispute shall be arbitrated in Millford." The acknowledgment did not say that Kiln's acceptance was conditional on Buyer's assent to those sentences. Buyer never signed the acknowledgment.

On June 10, Buyer wired Kiln $800, with the memo "deposit on the C-12 order." On June 20, Kiln shipped 400 mugs. Forty were cracked when they arrived. Kiln did not write or call about a replacement. July 1 had not yet arrived.

On June 21, Buyer rejected the entire shipment in a signed note that described the cracks, and held the mugs for Kiln. Kiln did not answer. On June 28, after a full week of silence and with July 1 still ahead, Buyer bought 400 comparable mugs from another maker at $11 each. The cover was in good faith and was not rushed past a cure Kiln had offered. Buyer spent nothing extra on freight beyond what the Kiln contract would have cost.

Call of the Question

Under general United States contract law, including Article 2, did a contract form, which terms are in it, was Buyer's rejection proper, and what sum may Buyer recover from Kiln?