Fact Pattern
Buyer is Millford Supply, a dealer that buys and resells restaurant goods. Seller is Kiln, a manufacturer of ceramic mugs. Both deal in mugs.
On June 1, Buyer sent Kiln a signed purchase order: "400 model C-12 mugs at $8 each. Delivery by July 1. Payment on delivery." On June 1, Kiln replied with a signed acknowledgment. It repeated the quantity, the model, the price, and the July 1 date. In the same ordinary type as the rest of the page, it added two sentences: "All implied warranties are disclaimed. Any dispute shall be arbitrated in Millford." The acknowledgment did not say that Kiln's acceptance was conditional on Buyer's assent to those sentences. Buyer never signed the acknowledgment.
On June 10, Buyer wired Kiln $800, with the memo "deposit on the C-12 order." On June 20, Kiln shipped 400 mugs. Forty were cracked when they arrived. Kiln did not write or call about a replacement. July 1 had not yet arrived.
On June 21, Buyer rejected the entire shipment in a signed note that described the cracks, and held the mugs for Kiln. Kiln did not answer. On June 28, after a full week of silence and with July 1 still ahead, Buyer bought 400 comparable mugs from another maker at $11 each. The cover was in good faith and was not rushed past a cure Kiln had offered. Buyer spent nothing extra on freight beyond what the Kiln contract would have cost.
Call of the Question
Under general United States contract law, including Article 2, did a contract form, which terms are in it, was Buyer's rejection proper, and what sum may Buyer recover from Kiln?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Article 2 and formation despite the extra sentences
Issue: Did a contract for the sale of goods form on June 1?
Rule: Article 2 applies to a transaction in goods. A definite and seasonable expression of acceptance operates as an acceptance even though it states additional terms, unless the offeree makes acceptance expressly conditional on assent to those terms. The common-law mirror-image rule does not apply.
Application: Mugs are movable goods, and both parties deal in them. Kiln's acknowledgment repeats the quantity, model, price, and date, so it is a definite expression of acceptance. It adds sentences, but it does not say Kiln will accept only if Buyer agrees to them. A contract formed on June 1. Buyer's later deposit is further conduct recognizing the contract, not the thing that created it.
Conclusion: The parties have an Article 2 contract for 400 model C-12 mugs at $8, due by July 1.
2. Whether the disclaimer and the arbitration sentence entered
Issue: Are the disclaimer and the arbitration sentence part of the contract?
Rule: Between merchants, additional terms become part of the contract unless they materially alter it, the offer limits acceptance to its terms, or the offeror objects within a reasonable time. A warranty disclaimer and an arbitration clause are commonly material alterations. A disclaimer of merchantability must also mention merchantability and, in writing, be conspicuous. A fitness disclaimer must be in a conspicuous writing. Ordinary type, matching the rest of the form, is not conspicuous.
Application: Both parties are merchants. Buyer's order did not limit acceptance to its terms, and Buyer did not object before shipment. The two added sentences still materially alter a sale that was silent on remedies and forums, so they do not enter. Even if the disclaimer entered, it does not mention merchantability, and it is not conspicuous, so it would not remove the implied warranties. The arbitration sentence likewise stays out.
Conclusion: The contract does not include the disclaimer or the arbitration sentence. Implied warranties remain.
3. The statute of frauds
Issue: Is the contract enforceable under the statute of frauds?
Rule: A contract for goods priced at $500 or more is enforceable only up to the quantity stated in a writing signed by the party to be charged. A signed offer and a signed acceptance can charge each signer. Payment for goods also makes the contract enforceable as to the quantity paid for.
Application: The price is $3,200, so the statute applies. Buyer's signed order states 400 mugs and charges Buyer. Kiln's signed acknowledgment states 400 mugs and charges Kiln. The $800 deposit would independently cover the quantity it pays for, but the writings already cover the full 400.
Conclusion: The statute does not bar enforcement of the 400-mug contract against either party.
4. Rejection and the missed cure
Issue: Could Buyer reject all 400 mugs, and did Kiln cure?
Rule: If the goods fail in any respect to conform, the buyer may reject the whole, accept the whole, or accept any commercial unit and reject the rest. Where the buyer rejects and time for performance remains, the seller may seasonably notify the buyer of an intention to cure and then make a conforming delivery. Cracked goods also fail the warranty of merchantability, because they are not fit for the ordinary purpose of a new mug.
Application: Forty cracked mugs mean the tender did not conform. Buyer was entitled to reject the whole shipment, and the June 21 note did so effectively while Buyer held the goods for Kiln. July 1 had not arrived, so a cure was still possible in time, but only if Kiln seasonably said it would cure. Kiln had a week, through June 28, and said nothing. Buyer did not cover until that week had passed, so the cover did not cut off a cure notice Kiln never sent. There was no cure. This is not a substantial-performance case. That common-law limit does not replace perfect tender on a one-delivery sale of goods.
Conclusion: The rejection was proper, and Kiln did not cure.
5. Cover damages and the deposit
Issue: What may Buyer recover?
Rule: After a rightful rejection, the buyer may cancel, recover so much of the price as has been paid, and cover in good faith without unreasonable delay. Cover damages are the cover price minus the contract price, plus incidental and consequential damages, minus expenses saved. The buyer does not also collect the market-difference measure when a proper cover was made. Money paid is returned so the buyer is not paying both the deposit and the full cover difference on the same dollars.
Application: The June 28 purchase of 400 comparable mugs at $11 was in good faith and came only after a week of silence from Kiln, so it is a cover. The difference is $3 a mug, or $1,200. No extra freight and no other consequential loss are described, and no expense was saved. Buyer also gets the $800 deposit back, because that sum was paid toward a contract Buyer rightfully cancelled. The $800 is not a second damages measure. It is the price paid. Buyer should not be awarded both a $1,200 cover award and a further credit that treats the deposit as if it were unpaid contract price already counted inside the $1,200.
Conclusion: Buyer recovers the $1,200 cover difference plus return of the $800 deposit.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Formation under Article 2 (4 Points)
- 1 pt Article 2 applies because the mugs are goods.
- 1 pt A definite acceptance can add terms and still accept.
- 1 pt Kiln's form was not expressly conditional on assent to the new sentences.
- 1 pt Concludes a contract formed for 400 mugs at $8, due July 1.
Issue 2: The added sentences (4 Points)
- 1 pt Both parties are merchants, so the between-merchants rule applies.
- 1 pt A material alteration does not enter. Names the disclaimer, the arbitration sentence, or both.
- 1 pt A written disclaimer must be conspicuous and, for merchantability, must say merchantability.
- 1 pt Concludes neither added sentence is in the contract and implied warranties remain.
Issue 3: Statute of frauds (3 Points)
- 1 pt The $500 threshold is met.
- 1 pt Each signed writing states the quantity of 400 and charges that signer.
- 1 pt Notes that the deposit is an additional path only for the quantity it pays for.
Issue 4: Rejection and cure (5 Points)
- 1 pt States perfect tender: any nonconformity supports rejection of the whole.
- 1 pt Applies it to the forty cracked mugs.
- 1 pt Finds the June 21 rejection effective.
- 1 pt States that cure inside the contract time requires seasonable notice of intent to cure.
- 1 pt Concludes Kiln did not cure, and does not substitute substantial performance.
Issue 5: Cover and the deposit (4 Points)
- 1 pt Uses the cover formula because the June 28 purchase was in good faith and followed a week of silence.
- 1 pt Computes the $3 difference, or $1,200, and notes that no expense was saved.
- 1 pt Returns the $800 as price paid, without using the market measure on top of cover.
- 1 pt Avoids double-counting the deposit inside the cover difference.