Fact Pattern
Studio is a window-display business in the town of Cedar Bend. Owner runs a single shop there. On March 1, Studio and Owner signed this writing: "Studio will design and install one new window display each week for fourteen months, beginning April 1, for $2,000 a month. Signed: Studio. Signed: Owner."
On March 20, Owner called Studio and said, "My own cash is tighter than I like. Make the monthly price $1,500." Studio answered, "Alright, I'll try." They wrote nothing down. Nothing unexpected had happened to the work itself. Owner's cash position was a risk Owner already carried on March 1.
Studio can staff only one weekly retainer at a time. Studio installed the April displays. Owner paid $2,000 for April. On May 2, before any May work, Owner wrote to Studio: "I will not pay for June or any later month. Do not come back." Studio stopped on May 3 and, the same day, took the only comparable opening, a different shop at $1,200 a month for every month left in the fourteen-month term. Studio could not have held that opening and Owner's weekly work together.
Separately, on March 5, Studio's manager told Owner's sibling, Sibling: "If you send me three shop owners who sign retainers on the same weekly-display terms as Owner's, for a season after Owner's term ends, I will pay you $600." Sibling did send three owners, and each one signed such a retainer for that later season. Studio then refused to pay Sibling. Those later retainers did not fill any week of Owner's term.
Call of the Question
Under general United States contract law, what are the rights and liabilities of Studio, Owner, and Sibling? Discuss formation and defenses, the effect of the May 2 writing, damages, and Sibling's claim.
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Which law, and whether the March 1 contract is enforceable
Issue: Does the common law govern, and does the statute of frauds bar the March 1 retainer?
Rule: A contract for personal services is governed by the common law, not by UCC Article 2. A contract that by its terms cannot be performed within one year of its making is unenforceable unless a writing signed by the party to be charged identifies the contract and its essential terms. The year is measured from the making, not from the start of work.
Application: Weekly design and installation is a service. Goods are not the point of the bargain, so Article 2 does not apply. The fourteen-month term, starting April 1, cannot be finished within one year of the March 1 signing, so the one-year clause applies. Both parties signed a writing that states the work, the term, and the price. That writing charges both of them.
Conclusion: The common law governs, and the March 1 contract is enforceable at $2,000 a month.
2. The March 20 price cut
Issue: Did the parties modify the price to $1,500?
Rule: At common law, a promise to pay more or to accept less for a duty the promisor already owes is not binding without new consideration, unless the old duty is honestly disputed, the parties fairly rescind, or the modification is fair and equitable in view of circumstances not anticipated when the contract was made. A modification must satisfy the statute of frauds when the contract as modified falls inside the statute. An uncertain "I'll try" is also a weak acceptance.
Application: Studio was already bound to do the same weekly work. Owner offered no new duty in exchange for the lower price. Owner's tighter cash was not a new circumstance of performance. It was a risk Owner already bore, so the unanticipated-circumstances exception does not apply. The modified term would still last more than a year from March 20, and nothing was signed. Studio's "I'll try" does not clearly assent. April's payment of $2,000 confirms that the parties went on at the written price.
Conclusion: The price stayed $2,000 a month.
3. Owner's May 2 writing
Issue: Was Owner's May 2 writing a repudiation, and could Studio stop performing?
Rule: A repudiation is a clear statement that a party will commit a total breach. The injured party may sue at once for total breach and may suspend its own performance. The injured party should not keep running up costs after a clear repudiation.
Application: Owner's writing is clear: no payment for June or any later month, and Studio is told not to return. That is a repudiation of the remaining term, not a negotiation. Studio was entitled to stop on May 3 and to treat the contract as totally breached. Studio did not have to wait until June.
Conclusion: Owner repudiated, and Studio's stop was proper.
4. Studio's damages
Issue: What expectation damages may Studio recover, after mitigation?
Rule: Expectation damages are the lost value of the contract minus costs and losses avoided. The injured party cannot recover loss it could have avoided without undue risk or burden. Taking the only comparable substitute is reasonable mitigation. Damages must be reasonably certain, and special losses are recoverable only if foreseeable at formation.
Application: April was performed and paid, so it drops out. Thirteen months remained, May through the end of the term. Studio stopped on May 3 and the same day took the only comparable job, at $1,200 a month, for every one of those months. The offset therefore includes May. It is not a partial month. Studio can staff only one weekly retainer at a time, so this job is mitigation of Owner's contract, not a second sale Studio could have kept alongside it. The three later-season retainers do not occupy Owner's weeks and do not reduce these damages. Studio's expectancy on the remainder was $2,000 a month. The substitute avoids $1,200 a month. The difference is $800 a month for thirteen months, or $10,400, assuming no separate saved cost is proved. There is no claim for displays Studio properly did not build after May 3. No special consequential loss is described.
Conclusion: Studio recovers about $10,400 from Owner, and does not recover the cost of work it correctly stopped.
5. Sibling's $600 claim
Issue: May Sibling enforce the March 5 statement?
Rule: An offer that invites acceptance by performance, and that does not require a return promise, is accepted when the invited performance is completed. The performance is the consideration. This is a contract between Studio and Sibling. It is not a third-party claim on Owner's retainer. An incidental hope of gain does not create beneficiary rights, but Sibling is the offeree of a separate offer, not a bystander.
Application: Studio asked Sibling to send three shop owners who sign the same kind of retainer, and promised $600 for that act. Sibling completed the act. Studio's duty to pay $600 came due on completion. Sibling does not need to be a beneficiary of Owner's contract, and Owner is not liable for the $600.
Conclusion: Studio owes Sibling $600. Owner does not.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Body of law and the statute of frauds (4 Points)
- 1 pt Common law governs because the retainer is a service, not a sale of goods.
- 1 pt The fourteen-month term cannot be performed within one year of March 1, so the statute applies.
- 1 pt The signed writing states the work, the term, and the price.
- 1 pt Concludes the March 1 contract is enforceable against both signers.
Issue 2: The price cut (4 Points)
- 1 pt States the pre-existing-duty rule: the same work is not new consideration.
- 1 pt Rejects the unanticipated-circumstances exception because Owner's cash tightness was not a new event in the work.
- 1 pt Notes that an oral change fails the statute of frauds when the contract as modified remains inside the statute.
- 1 pt Concludes the price remained $2,000, and treats "I'll try" as unclear assent.
Issue 3: Repudiation (4 Points)
- 1 pt Defines repudiation as a clear statement of total breach.
- 1 pt Applies that definition to the May 2 writing.
- 1 pt States that the injured party may stop and sue at once.
- 1 pt Concludes Studio's May 3 stop was proper.
Issue 4: Damages (4 Points)
- 1 pt Uses expectation: contract rate minus the substitute rate.
- 1 pt Treats the $1,200 shop as reasonable mitigation and comparable work.
- 1 pt Counts the unpaid remainder (about thirteen months) and not the paid April month.
- 1 pt Refuses damages for work Studio correctly did not perform after the repudiation.
Issue 5: Sibling (4 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies a separate offer accepted by performance.
- 1 pt Finds the invited performance complete when three owners signed.
- 1 pt Concludes Studio owes $600.
- 1 pt Says Sibling is not enforcing Owner's contract, and Owner is not liable for the $600.