Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Studio is a window-display business in the town of Cedar Bend. Owner runs a single shop there. On March 1, Studio and Owner signed this writing: "Studio will design and install one new window display each week for fourteen months, beginning April 1, for $2,000 a month. Signed: Studio. Signed: Owner."

On March 20, Owner called Studio and said, "My own cash is tighter than I like. Make the monthly price $1,500." Studio answered, "Alright, I'll try." They wrote nothing down. Nothing unexpected had happened to the work itself. Owner's cash position was a risk Owner already carried on March 1.

Studio can staff only one weekly retainer at a time. Studio installed the April displays. Owner paid $2,000 for April. On May 2, before any May work, Owner wrote to Studio: "I will not pay for June or any later month. Do not come back." Studio stopped on May 3 and, the same day, took the only comparable opening, a different shop at $1,200 a month for every month left in the fourteen-month term. Studio could not have held that opening and Owner's weekly work together.

Separately, on March 5, Studio's manager told Owner's sibling, Sibling: "If you send me three shop owners who sign retainers on the same weekly-display terms as Owner's, for a season after Owner's term ends, I will pay you $600." Sibling did send three owners, and each one signed such a retainer for that later season. Studio then refused to pay Sibling. Those later retainers did not fill any week of Owner's term.

Call of the Question

Under general United States contract law, what are the rights and liabilities of Studio, Owner, and Sibling? Discuss formation and defenses, the effect of the May 2 writing, damages, and Sibling's claim.