Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Owner, a citizen of State A, hired Contractor, a citizen of State B, to construct a warehouse in the city of Oakridge, State B. Owner paid Contractor a $120,000 progress deposit. After the roof trusses failed a municipal inspection, Owner filed a diversity action against Contractor in federal district court in State A seeking $120,000 for breach of the warehouse contract. Proper diversity jurisdiction existed.

Contractor timely responded by filing a pre-answer motion to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) for failure to state a claim, arguing that Owner's complaint did not adequately allege satisfaction of a contractual inspection clause. Contractor did not raise lack of personal jurisdiction or insufficient service of process in that motion. After the court denied the Rule 12(b)(6) motion, Contractor timely filed an answer that (1) asserted affirmative defenses of lack of personal jurisdiction under Rule 12(b)(2) and insufficient service of process under Rule 12(b)(5), and (2) asserted a counterclaim against Owner for $60,000 in unpaid framing work performed under the same Oakridge warehouse contract.

Ten days after serving its answer, Contractor also filed a third-party complaint under Rule 14(a) against Truss Co. (incorporated and headquartered in State B), alleging that Truss Co. manufactured the defective trusses and is contractually obligated to indemnify Contractor for any liability to Owner. Meanwhile, after the applicable statute of limitations expired, Owner moved for leave to amend its complaint under Rule 15 to add a new claim against Contractor for $30,000 in temporary storage expenses caused by the same Oakridge truss failure.

Finally, Contractor moved to dismiss Owner's warehouse suit as barred by claim preclusion based on an earlier final summary judgment Contractor won against Owner in State B court on an unrelated paving contract at a different site. In the alternative, Contractor moved for summary judgment on the warehouse claim, submitting sworn engineer affidavits and certified inspection logs showing the trusses met all contractual specifications. Owner opposed summary judgment solely by pointing to the unverified allegations in Owner's complaint.

Call of the Question

How should the federal district court rule on (1) Contractor's Rule 12(b)(2) and 12(b)(5) defenses, (2) subject-matter jurisdiction and propriety of Contractor's counterclaim and Rule 14(a) third-party complaint, (3) Owner's motion to amend under Rule 15, and (4) Contractor's claim-preclusion defense and summary judgment motion?