Fact Pattern
Alpha, Beta, and Gamma properly filed articles of organization for Maplewood Green LLC, a landscaping business in the town of Maplewood. They did not adopt a written operating agreement, and the filed articles made no mention of managers. Each member contributed $30,000 in cash. Over the prior year, Beta and Gamma had regularly allowed Alpha to place spring supply orders with Supplier on behalf of Maplewood Green LLC, though they never notified Supplier of any spending limits and had privately told Alpha to obtain their approval before signing new contracts.
Without consulting Beta or Gamma, Alpha signed two agreements in the name of Maplewood Green LLC. First, Alpha signed a routine $3,000 contract with Supplier to purchase mulch and fertilizer for spring jobs; Supplier had no reason to doubt Alpha's authority. Second, Alpha signed a contract with Buyer to sell Maplewood Green LLC's sole commercial storage warehouse—its primary capital asset—for $200,000. Buyer knew the warehouse was Maplewood Green LLC's only building and also secretly paid Alpha a $5,000 personal "finder's fee" to close the sale without telling Beta or Gamma. Beta and Gamma learned of both contracts the next week and objected to both.
Frustrated by Alpha's conduct, Beta sent a written notice to Alpha and Gamma stating, "I am withdrawing as a member today, and I have sold and assigned my entire LLC interest to Outsider so Outsider can take my place and vote at LLC meetings." Alpha and Gamma refused to consent to Outsider becoming a member.
Separately, Alpha is the sole shareholder and director of Alpha Hauling Inc., a properly incorporated trucking corporation formed with $100 in initial capital and no liability insurance. Alpha Hauling Inc. has never held shareholder or director meetings, has no separate bank account, and deposits all customer checks directly into Alpha's personal checking account, from which Alpha pays both personal household bills and occasional truck fuel expenses. Last month, while driving a delivery truck for Alpha Hauling Inc., Alpha's employee negligently ran a red light in Maplewood and seriously injured Pedestrian. Alpha Hauling Inc. has zero assets.
Call of the Question
Under general United States LLC and corporate law (applying the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act where applicable): (1) Is Maplewood Green LLC bound by Alpha's $3,000 contract with Supplier and the $200,000 warehouse contract with Buyer? (2) Did Alpha breach any fiduciary duty to Maplewood Green LLC, and what remedies exist? (3) What is the legal effect of Beta's withdrawal and assignment to Outsider? (4) May Pedestrian hold Alpha personally liable for the truck accident by piercing Alpha Hauling Inc.'s corporate veil?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Member-Managed LLC Authority: Ordinary Supply Contract vs. Warehouse Sale
Issue: Is Maplewood Green LLC bound by Alpha's $3,000 contract with Supplier and Alpha's $200,000 contract to sell the LLC's sole warehouse to Buyer?
Rule: Under the Revised Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (RULLCA § 407(a)), an LLC is member-managed by default unless its operating agreement expressly provides that it is manager-managed (whereas 1996 ULLCA § 203(a)(6) required that election in the articles). Under RULLCA § 301(a) ("No Agency Power of Member as Member"), member status alone never creates statutory apparent authority; instead, under § 301(b), an LLC is bound only through actual authority (§ 407(b), requiring majority member consent for ordinary-course matters), common-law apparent authority (Restatement (Third) of Agency § 2.03), or a filed Statement of Authority (§ 302). By contrast, under 1996 ULLCA § 301 (and first-generation LLC statutes), each member in a member-managed LLC has statutory apparent authority for ordinary-course acts unless the third party knows or has notice of lack of authority. Under both RULLCA § 407(b)(4) and 1996 ULLCA, an extraordinary act outside the ordinary course—such as selling substantially all of the LLC's property—requires unanimous member consent.
Application: Because Maplewood Green LLC adopted no operating agreement electing manager management (and its articles mentioned no managers), it is member-managed by default under both RULLCA § 407(a) and 1996 ULLCA. Alpha lacked actual authority under RULLCA § 407(b) to sign the $3,000 mulch and fertilizer order because Alpha acted without majority consent and contrary to Beta and Gamma's private instruction. Under RULLCA § 301(a), Alpha's member status alone does not bind the LLC; however, because Beta and Gamma had routinely allowed Alpha to place spring supply orders with Supplier on Maplewood Green LLC's behalf without communicating any restriction to Supplier, Supplier reasonably relied on the LLC's prior course of dealing, giving Alpha common-law apparent authority under RULLCA § 301(b) (and Supplier would likewise prevail under 1996 ULLCA § 301's statutory apparent authority). Conversely, selling the LLC's sole commercial warehouse for $200,000 is an extraordinary transaction requiring unanimous consent of Alpha, Beta, and Gamma. Alpha lacked actual authority, and Buyer knew the warehouse was the LLC's sole building and paid Alpha a secret $5,000 kickback, defeating common-law apparent authority and good-faith reliance under any statute.
Conclusion: Maplewood Green LLC is bound on the $3,000 supply contract with Supplier via common-law apparent authority under RULLCA § 301(b) (or statutory apparent authority under 1996 ULLCA), but is not bound on the $200,000 warehouse contract with Buyer.
2. Alpha's Fiduciary Duty of Loyalty in a Member-Managed LLC
Issue: Did Alpha breach a fiduciary duty to Maplewood Green LLC by accepting a secret $5,000 fee from Buyer and attempting an unauthorized sale of LLC property?
Rule: Under RULLCA, members in a member-managed LLC owe the LLC and the other members a fiduciary duty of loyalty, a duty of care (refraining from grossly negligent or reckless conduct, intentional misconduct, or knowing law violations), and an obligation of good faith and fair dealing. The duty of loyalty requires a member to account to the LLC and hold as trustee any property, profit, or benefit derived from the use of LLC property or from an LLC transaction, and to refrain from dealing with the LLC on behalf of a party having an adverse interest.
Application: Because Maplewood Green LLC is member-managed, Alpha owed the LLC and Beta and Gamma full duties of loyalty and good faith. By accepting a secret $5,000 personal kickback from Buyer in connection with selling the LLC's warehouse—and trying to conceal the transaction from Beta and Gamma—Alpha placed personal financial gain ahead of the LLC and dealt on behalf of an adverse counterparty. Even though the warehouse sale is unenforceable against the LLC, Alpha violated the duty of loyalty and good faith.
Conclusion: Alpha breached the fiduciary duty of loyalty and must disgorge and account to Maplewood Green LLC for the $5,000 secret fee (plus any damages caused to the LLC).
3. Beta's Dissociation and Attempted Transfer of Membership Rights
Issue: What are the legal consequences of Beta's notice of withdrawal and assignment of Beta's LLC interest to Outsider?
Rule: Under RULLCA, a member has the power to dissociate from the LLC at any time by express will (which is rightful in an at-will LLC with no fixed term). Upon dissociation, the dissociated member immediately loses all management and voting rights in the LLC and retains only the economic rights of a transferee—meaning the right to receive distributions when and if declared, without causing automatic dissolution unless the operating agreement or statute triggers it. Similarly, a member's transfer of an LLC interest conveys only the transferable economic right to receive distributions; it does not entitle the transferee to participate in management or vote unless all remaining members consent to admit the transferee as a member.
Application: Because Maplewood Green LLC had no fixed term in an operating agreement, Beta's written withdrawal was a rightful dissociation. Upon giving notice, Beta ceased to be a member with management authority, leaving Alpha and Gamma as the remaining voting members (the LLC itself continues unless remaining members vote to dissolve). Furthermore, Beta's assignment to Outsider transferred solely Beta's economic right to future distributions (and right to winding-up capital/proceeds if the LLC dissolves). Because Alpha and Gamma refused to consent to admit Outsider as a member, Outsider cannot attend meetings, vote, or exercise management authority.
Conclusion: Beta rightfully dissociated and lost management rights, and Outsider holds only an economic transferee interest with no voting or management rights.
4. Piercing the Corporate Veil of Alpha Hauling Inc.
Issue: May Pedestrian pierce the corporate veil of Alpha Hauling Inc. to hold Alpha personally liable for the delivery truck injury?
Rule: Although a corporation's shareholders are normally shielded from personal liability for corporate torts (leaving Alpha Hauling Inc. vicariously liable under respondeat superior for its driver's negligence), a court will pierce the corporate veil and hold an active shareholder personally liable when necessary to prevent fraud or injustice and the plaintiff shows the corporation was an alter ego or mere instrumentality of the owner. Courts weigh factors including complete disregard of corporate formalities, commingling of personal and corporate assets, siphoning funds, and gross undercapitalization at formation relative to foreseeable business risks. Courts are significantly more willing to pierce the veil for involuntary tort creditors than for voluntary contract creditors who could investigate the corporation before extending credit.
Application: Alpha Hauling Inc. exhibits classic alter-ego abuse across every factor. Alpha completely disregarded corporate formalities by holding zero shareholder or director meetings. Alpha severely commingled personal and corporate assets by maintaining no corporate bank account, depositing all corporate receipts directly into Alpha's personal checking account, and paying household bills from those funds. Moreover, operating a commercial trucking company with $100 in initial capital and zero liability insurance demonstrates gross undercapitalization relative to obvious highway collision risks. Pedestrian is an involuntary tort victim who never chose to deal with an undercapitalized entity, and respecting the corporate shield here would work a severe injustice by leaving Pedestrian uncompensated while Alpha treated corporate revenues as a personal pocketbook.
Conclusion: A court will likely pierce the corporate veil of Alpha Hauling Inc. and hold Alpha personally liable to Pedestrian for the driver's tort.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Member-Managed LLC Authority (6 Points)
- 1 pt Explains that an LLC is member-managed by default unless the operating agreement provides for manager management under RULLCA § 407(a) (contrast 1996 ULLCA § 203(a)(6) articles election).
- 1 pt States RULLCA § 301(a)–(b): member status alone confers no statutory apparent authority, so ordinary-course binding requires actual authority (§ 407(b)), common-law apparent authority, or a § 302 Statement of Authority (contrasting 1996 ULLCA § 301).
- 1 pt Applies rule to Supplier: Alpha lacked actual authority, but prior regular dealings with Supplier without notice of private limits gave Alpha common-law apparent authority under RULLCA § 301(b) (and statutory apparent authority under 1996 ULLCA).
- 1 pt States the rule for extraordinary acts (selling substantially all assets requires unanimous member consent).
- 1 pt Applies rule to Buyer: selling the sole warehouse lacked Beta and Gamma's consent, and Buyer knew it was the sole building and paid a secret fee.
- 1 pt Concludes LLC is bound to Supplier but not to Buyer.
Issue 2: Fiduciary Duty of Loyalty (4 Points)
- 1 pt Notes that members in a member-managed LLC owe fiduciary duties of loyalty, care, and good faith.
- 1 pt Identifies the loyalty prohibition on secret profits, self-dealing, and acting for an adverse party.
- 1 pt Applies facts: Alpha accepted a secret $5,000 fee from Buyer while concealing the warehouse sale.
- 1 pt Concludes Alpha breached loyalty and must disgorge the $5,000 to the LLC.
Issue 3: Dissociation & Transfer of LLC Interest (4 Points)
- 1 pt Explains Beta had power to dissociate rightfully in an at-will LLC, terminating Beta's management/voting rights without dissolving the LLC.
- 1 pt States the transferability rule: assigning an LLC interest transfers only economic distribution rights, not governance or voting rights.
- 1 pt Explains that admitting Outsider as a full member requires unanimous consent of remaining members (Alpha and Gamma), which was refused.
- 1 pt Concludes Outsider receives economic distributions only and cannot vote or manage.
Issue 4: Piercing the Corporate Veil (6 Points)
- 1 pt Notes Alpha Hauling Inc. is vicariously liable for its driver's negligence under respondeat superior, and states the shareholder limited-liability baseline.
- 1 pt States the two-part veil-piercing standard (alter ego/unity of interest + fraud or injustice).
- 1 pt Identifies commingling and disregard of formalities (no meetings, no corporate bank account, personal household expenses paid from business checks).
- 1 pt Identifies gross undercapitalization ($100 capital and zero insurance for a trucking business).
- 1 pt Notes courts pierce more readily for involuntary tort creditors like Pedestrian than for voluntary contract creditors.
- 1 pt Concludes a court will likely pierce the veil to hold Alpha personally liable.