Fact Pattern
Baker and Chef opened a coffee shop in the town of Linden under the trade name "Linden Cafe" without filing any corporate or LLC documents with the state. Baker and Chef orally agreed to run the cafe together and split net profits evenly. Needing startup cash, they signed a written agreement with Designer titled "Loan Agreement," under which Designer advanced $20,000 to Linden Cafe in exchange for 25% of monthly net profits until repaid plus an ongoing seat with an equal vote at weekly cafe menu and pricing meetings. Designer regularly attended those meetings and voted on menu prices.
Baker and Chef hired Clerk as cafe manager. In Clerk's written employment instructions, Baker stated: "Clerk may purchase routine weekly supplies up to $1,000, but Clerk has zero authority to sign any contract over $1,000 without Baker's written co-signature." Later that month, Baker introduced Clerk to Roaster at a regional coffee trade show, telling Roaster, "Clerk handles all our bean purchasing." Baker never mentioned the $1,000 cap to Roaster.
Two weeks later, Clerk ordered $4,500 of specialty coffee beans from Roaster, signing the contract solely as "Clerk, Manager, Linden Cafe" without disclosing the names of Baker, Chef, or Designer. Roaster delivered the beans, and Linden Cafe has not paid.
Separately, after Baker explicitly told Clerk not to buy any new display cases, Clerk signed a $1,200 written contract with Vendor to buy a refrigerated pastry case, signing "Linden Cafe, by Clerk, Manager." When Vendor delivered the pastry case to the cafe the next day, Baker saw the invoice showing the $1,200 price and terms, placed the case on the counter, and used it to display pastries for two weeks before emailing Vendor to cancel and demand removal because Clerk lacked authority.
Linden Cafe's bank account currently holds only $1,500.
Call of the Question
Under general United States agency and partnership law: (1) Is Designer a general partner of Linden Cafe, and who may be held personally liable for valid cafe debts? (2) Are Linden Cafe, Baker, Chef, Designer, or Clerk liable to Roaster on the $4,500 bean contract? (3) Are Linden Cafe and its owners bound to Vendor on the $1,200 pastry case contract? (4) What claims, if any, does Linden Cafe have against Clerk?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Partnership Formation, Designer's Status, and Partner Liability
Issue: Did Baker, Chef, and Designer form a general partnership, making Designer personally liable alongside Baker and Chef for partnership obligations?
Rule: Under the Revised Uniform Partnership Act (RUPA § 202(a)), a general partnership forms whenever two or more persons associate to carry on as co-owners a business for profit, regardless of subjective intent or written labels. Receiving a share of business profits creates a rebuttable presumption of partnership, unless the profits are received in payment of a debt by installments or otherwise (§ 202(c)(3)(i)) or of interest or other charge on a loan, even if the payment varies with profits (§ 202(c)(3)(v)), or as wages or rent. When an exception applies, co-ownership is evaluated under the totality of circumstances, including governance participation and control. Under RUPA §§ 306 and 307(c)–(d), all general partners are jointly and severally liable for all partnership obligations, though to execute against a partner's personal assets a creditor must both obtain a judgment against the partner personally (§ 307(c)) and exhaust partnership assets or satisfy a § 307(d) exception.
Application: Baker and Chef clearly formed a general partnership because they associated to operate Linden Cafe for profit and agreed to split net profits and manage the business as co-owners without forming a corporation or LLC. As to Designer, although the contract was labeled a "Loan Agreement," receiving 25% of monthly net profits "until repaid" falls within RUPA § 202(c)(3)(i) and (v)'s debt-repayment and variable-interest exceptions and therefore does not trigger the statutory presumption of partnership. Nevertheless, under RUPA § 202(a)'s totality of circumstances, Designer did not remain a passive lender: Designer held an ongoing seat with an equal vote at weekly menu and pricing meetings—extending beyond loan repayment and conferring co-management control over core business decisions. Labeling the document a loan cannot overcome actual co-ownership. Consequently, Designer is a general partner. Because Linden Cafe holds only $1,500 in partnership assets, once a creditor obtains judgments against the partnership and the partners personally (§ 307(c)) and exhausts that $1,500 (§ 307(d)), Baker, Chef, and Designer are jointly and severally personally liable for any remaining balance.
Conclusion: Linden Cafe is a general partnership consisting of Baker, Chef, and Designer, all three of whom face joint and several personal liability once judgments are obtained against them and partnership assets are exhausted.
2. Roaster's $4,500 Bean Contract: Authority and Disclosed vs. Unidentified Principal Rules
Issue: Did Clerk bind Linden Cafe to Roaster's $4,500 bean contract, and is Clerk also personally liable on the contract?
Rule: An agent has actual authority only to act in a manner the agent reasonably believes the principal authorized based on the principal's manifestations to the agent. Apparent authority exists when a third party reasonably believes the agent has authority based on the principal's manifestations to the third party, regardless of secret internal limits. Under Restatement (Third) of Agency §§ 1.04(2)(a) and 6.01, when an authorized agent contracts on behalf of a disclosed principal—meaning the third party has notice that the agent acts for a principal and knows the principal's identity—only the principal is a party to the contract and the agent is not personally liable unless agreed otherwise. Under RUPA §§ 201(a) and 307(a), a general partnership is a distinct legal entity that contracts and is sued in its own name, so disclosing the partnership entity's name in a representative capacity makes the partnership a disclosed principal without listing every partner's individual name (by contrast, signing only an unregistered trade name for a corporation without identifying the corporate entity leaves the principal unidentified under Restatement (Third) § 6.02 cmt. d). Where a principal truly is unidentified (or undisclosed), both principal and agent become parties until satisfaction under § 6.09 (and even under traditional common law, the election rule applied only to undisclosed principals, requiring election before taking judgment—never to unidentified principals).
Application: Clerk lacked actual authority to sign the $4,500 bean contract because Baker explicitly capped Clerk's purchasing authority at $1,000 without written co-signature. However, Baker—acting as a general partner in the ordinary course of business—personally introduced Clerk to Roaster as the person who "handles all our bean purchasing" without mentioning the $1,000 limit. Buying specialty beans is ordinary for a coffee shop, so Roaster reasonably relied on Baker's direct manifestation, giving Clerk apparent authority to bind Linden Cafe. Moreover, because Linden Cafe is a general partnership entity under RUPA § 201(a), Baker personally introduced Clerk as acting for Linden Cafe, and Clerk signed in a representative capacity as "Clerk, Manager, Linden Cafe," Roaster knew both that Clerk was acting for a principal and the identity of the partnership entity itself. Listing the individual names of Baker, Chef, or Designer was unnecessary to make the partnership a disclosed principal. Therefore, Linden Cafe (and its partners once firm assets are exhausted after judgments against them) is bound on the $4,500 contract, and Clerk is not personally liable.
Conclusion: Linden Cafe (and Baker, Chef, and Designer upon judgments against them and exhaustion of firm funds) is bound by Clerk's apparent authority, and Clerk is not personally liable because Linden Cafe was a disclosed partnership principal.
3. Vendor's $1,200 Pastry Case Contract: Ratification
Issue: Did Baker's receipt and two-week use of the pastry case ratify Clerk's unauthorized $1,200 contract with Vendor?
Rule: Where an agent lacks both actual and apparent authority, the principal is not initially bound. However, a principal ratifies a prior unauthorized contract by manifesting assent or engaging in conduct—such as knowingly accepting or retaining the contract's benefits—that justifies a reasonable assumption of consent. Valid ratification under Restatement (Third) of Agency §§ 4.01–4.07 requires that the actor acted or purported to act as an agent on the principal's behalf, the principal existed and had capacity at both the original act and affirmance, the principal knew all material facts, the principal affirmed the entire transaction (all-or-nothing, § 4.07), and the third party had not withdrawn before affirmance.
Application: Clerk lacked actual authority to buy the display case (due to both the $1,000 cap and Baker's explicit prohibition) and no facts show Baker made any manifestation to Vendor creating apparent authority. Nevertheless, Clerk acted and purported to contract on behalf of Linden Cafe, which existed at signing. The next day, Baker saw the invoice displaying the $1,200 price and terms—giving Baker knowledge of all material facts—yet placed the case on the counter and used it in the business for two weeks before trying to cancel. Knowingly retaining and using the asset for two weeks constitutes implied ratification of the entire contract, and Vendor had not withdrawn. Because Baker acted in the ordinary course as managing partner, ratification binds Linden Cafe.
Conclusion: Baker's informed retention and use of the pastry case ratified the $1,200 contract, binding Linden Cafe (and its partners) to Vendor.
4. Linden Cafe's Claims Against Clerk (Fiduciary Duty of Obedience)
Issue: May Linden Cafe recover damages or indemnification from Clerk for exceeding Clerk's express instructions on the bean and pastry case contracts?
Rule: An agent owes the principal a fiduciary duty of obedience to act within the scope of actual authority and obey all lawful instructions. An agent who exceeds actual authority and binds the principal via apparent authority is liable to indemnify the principal for any resulting loss. However, if the principal subsequently ratifies the unauthorized transaction, ratification generally releases the agent from liability to the principal for acting without authority.
Application: Clerk knowingly violated Baker's explicit $1,000 limit and specific instruction not to purchase display cases. On the $4,500 Roaster contract, Clerk's breach of the duty of obedience bound Linden Cafe via apparent authority, and Linden Cafe did not ratify it; thus, Linden Cafe may hold Clerk liable for losses caused by exceeding the $1,000 cap. By contrast, because Baker ratified the $1,200 Vendor contract by using the case for two weeks with full knowledge of the terms, ratification extinguishes Linden Cafe's claim against Clerk for lack of authority on the pastry case.
Conclusion: Linden Cafe can recover from Clerk for breaching the duty of obedience on the unratified $4,500 bean order, but ratification bars recovery against Clerk on the $1,200 pastry case.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Partnership Formation & Partner Liability (6 Points)
- 1 pt States the RUPA § 202(a) test for general partnership formation (two or more persons carrying on as co-owners a business for profit; no intent or writing needed).
- 1 pt Identifies the profit-sharing presumption and explains that RUPA § 202(c)(3)(i) and (v) exclude profit shares paid toward debt repayment or variable loan interest.
- 1 pt Applies facts under § 202(a): although the 25% profit share "until repaid" falls within the debt exception, Designer's ongoing equal vote at weekly pricing/menu meetings proves co-ownership despite the "Loan Agreement" label.
- 1 pt States RUPA's joint and several liability rule for all partners on partnership obligations.
- 1 pt Identifies the RUPA § 307(c)–(d) personal execution rules: creditors must obtain judgments against the partners personally and exhaust the $1,500 firm account before executing on personal assets.
- 1 pt Concludes Baker, Chef, and Designer are all general partners facing personal liability.
Issue 2: Roaster's $4,500 Contract (5 Points)
- 1 pt Explains why Clerk lacked actual authority ($1,000 written cap without co-signature).
- 1 pt States the apparent authority rule (principal's manifestation to third party creates reasonable belief) and finds Baker's trade-show statement bound Linden Cafe.
- 1 pt Explains why Linden Cafe is a disclosed principal under RUPA § 201(a) and Restatement (Third) §§ 1.04(2)(a), 6.01 after Baker's direct introduction and Clerk's representative signature ("Clerk, Manager, Linden Cafe"), rather than an unidentified corporate trade name.
- 1 pt Applies the disclosed-principal rule (Clerk is not personally liable) and notes that even if treated as unidentified, both would remain liable until satisfaction under § 6.09 (election applied only to undisclosed principals before judgment).
- 1 pt Concludes Roaster can enforce the $4,500 contract against Linden Cafe (and its partners upon judgment and exhaustion), and Clerk is not personally liable.
Issue 3: Vendor's $1,200 Contract & Ratification (5 Points)
- 1 pt Notes Clerk had neither actual authority (expressly forbidden) nor apparent authority (no manifestation from Baker to Vendor).
- 1 pt States the elements of ratification (actor acted or purported to act for principal, affirmance or knowing retention of benefits, knowledge of material facts, existence/capacity, all-or-nothing under § 4.07, no withdrawal).
- 1 pt Applies facts: Baker read the invoice terms, placed the case on the counter, and used it for two weeks.
- 1 pt Explains that Baker's later email cannot undo a completed ratification (all-or-nothing).
- 1 pt Concludes Linden Cafe is bound to Vendor for $1,200.
Issue 4: Principal's Claims Against Clerk (4 Points)
- 1 pt States an agent's fiduciary duty of obedience to lawful instructions and duty to indemnify for losses from unauthorized acts binding via apparent authority.
- 1 pt Concludes Clerk owes indemnification/damages to Linden Cafe for exceeding the $1,000 limit on the Roaster contract.
- 1 pt Recognizes the ratification defense: a principal's ratification generally releases the agent from breach-of-authority liability.
- 1 pt Concludes Linden Cafe cannot recover from Clerk on the ratified $1,200 Vendor contract.