Part I: Case File
Document 1: Assigning Memorandum
To: Associate
From: Jordan Mercer, Senior Partner, Mercer Family Law PC (Oakridge, Linden)
Date: November 12, Year 6
Re: Priya Nair — Client Counseling Letter on Relocation, Support, and Counsel Contact
I met with prospective client Priya Nair this morning regarding threats made by her former husband, Owen Bell. Please draft a client counseling letter to Priya answering each of her four questions clearly in plain English (explaining any legal terms simply), assessing practical risks, and recommending concrete next steps:
- Which state's court (Linden or the neighboring State of Oak) has authority over custody and Priya's planned job move to the State of Pine, and how should she seek permission to relocate?
- May Priya withhold Owen's Thanksgiving weekend parenting time until he pays the $4,400 in overdue child support?
- Can Owen succeed if he files in a Linden court to erase the $4,400 arrears, reduce future monthly support to match his startup income, or end support at age 18 instead of age 21?
- May our firm call Owen directly to propose a settlement before hiring Oak counsel, given that Owen's Oak lawyer is actively advising him?
Document 2: Client Intake Note (Priya Nair)
Date: November 12, Year 6 | Client: Priya Nair (Oakridge, Linden)
- Prior Decree (State of Oak): Priya and Owen Bell divorced in Oak County District Court, State of Oak, in Year 3. The Oak decree gave Priya primary physical custody of their daughter, Maya (now age 8), awarded Owen alternating weekend and summer parenting time, and ordered Owen to pay $1,100 per month in child support until Maya turns age 21 (Oak's statutory cutoff).
- Move to Linden: In Year 4, Priya moved with Maya to Oakridge, Linden, with Owen's signed written consent, and Maya has lived in Linden for two years. Owen never moved out of Oak; he still lives and works in Oak and exercises monthly weekend visits and three summer weeks with Maya in Oak. Neither party has ever asked Oak to transfer or decline jurisdiction.
- New Promotion & Move to Pine: Last week, Priya accepted a regional director promotion requiring her to move with Maya to the State of Pine in six weeks (January 2, Year 7). Her new salary rises by 35%, and she has researched schools in Pine.
- Support Arrears: Four months ago, Owen voluntarily cut his corporate accounting hours to part time to launch a solo consulting firm. He stopped paying the $1,100 monthly support and now owes $4,400 in accrued arrears. Last month, Priya registered the Oak support order in Elm County Court, Linden, hoping to start wage-withholding enforcement locally.
- Priya's Questions: Priya is angry about the $4,400 arrears and asked: (a) whether she can keep Maya home from Owen's Thanksgiving visit in Oak until he pays; (b) whether Owen can get Linden's court to wipe out the $4,400, lower his monthly payment, or stop support at age 18 (Linden's age of majority); (c) which court controls her move to Pine; and (d) whether we can just call Owen directly since he hasn't hired a Linden lawyer yet.
Document 3: Email from Owen Bell to Priya Nair (November 10, Year 6)
From: Owen Bell | To: Priya Nair | Cc: Marcus Webb, Esq. (Oak Family Law Group)
Priya — You have no right to take Maya to Pine, and I do not consent. Since Maya has lived in Linden for two years, I am going to file in Linden court next week to block the relocation and seek primary custody myself. I am also asking the Linden judge to wipe out the $4,400 back support from the past four months because my consulting startup barely broke even, to cut future support to $300/month, and to apply Linden's rule ending child support at age 18 instead of 21. I have copied my Oak attorney, Marcus Webb, who has represented me on the decree and is advising me on all of this.
Document 4: Summary of Oak Divorce Decree & Linden Registration Receipt
- Oak Divorce Decree (Entered June 14, Year 3, State of Oak): Grants primary physical custody of Maya to Priya; alternating weekends/holidays and summer weeks to Owen; orders Owen to pay $1,100/month child support until Maya reaches age 21 under Oak Stat. § 19-4. Neither parent has filed any consent in Oak court transferring support or custody jurisdiction.
- Linden Clerk Receipt (October 18, Year 6): Confirms registration of the Oak Child Support Order in Linden under Linden Code § 41-603 for enforcement only.
Part II: Library — Law of the State of Linden (Supplied for This Task)
Notice: The statutes, ethics rule, and appellate decision below are the controlling law of the invented jurisdiction of Linden, modeled on the UCCJEA, UIFSA, federal child-support law, and ABA Model Rules, and supplied solely for this performance task.
Linden Code § 41-202 & § 41-203 (UCCJEA Continuing & Modification Jurisdiction)
(a) Except for temporary emergency protection, a Linden court may not modify a child-custody determination made by a court of another state unless a Linden court has initial-jurisdiction status (such as six months' home-state residence) AND:
- The court of the other state determines it no longer has exclusive, continuing jurisdiction or that a Linden court would be a more convenient forum; OR
- A Linden court or a court of the other state determines that the child, the child's parents, and any person acting as a parent do not presently reside in the other state.
(b) While one parent continues to reside in the issuing state, only the issuing state's court may decide whether neither the child, nor the child and that parent, has a significant connection and substantial evidence no longer exists there.
Linden Code § 41-205, § 41-603 & § 41-611 (UIFSA Enforcement, Modification & Duration)
(a) Enforcement Only: Registration of another state's child-support order in Linden under § 41-603 authorizes Linden to enforce the order—not modify it—provided the obligor or the obligor's employer or property is subject to jurisdiction in Linden; when the obligor lives and works solely in the issuing state without an employer or assets in Linden, income withholding and arrears enforcement must proceed where the obligor, employer, or assets are subject to jurisdiction.
(b) Continuing, Exclusive Jurisdiction (CEJ): Under § 41-205(b), the issuing state retains CEJ to modify its child-support order as long as the obligor, individual obligee, or child continues to reside in the issuing state, unless all individual parties file consents in a record in the issuing tribunal permitting another state where the child resides or an individual party is subject to personal jurisdiction to modify.
(c) Choice of Law on Duration: Under § 41-611(c)–(d), the law of the original issuing state governs the duration of the child-support obligation, even if another state later assumes modification jurisdiction.
Linden Code § 41-310 (Arrears, Imputed Income & Independence of Parenting Time)
(a) Consistent with federal law (the Bradley Amendment), each child-support installment becomes a final judgment when due and may never be retroactively modified or forgiven, even for involuntary hardship.
(b) Prospective modification requires a substantial, continuing, good-faith change in circumstances; a court may impute prior earning capacity where an obligor voluntarily reduces income in bad faith or without justification.
(c) Independent Obligations: Child support and court-ordered parenting time are legally independent duties. A custodial parent may not withhold court-ordered visitation because child support is unpaid.
Linden Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2
In representing a client, a lawyer shall not communicate about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented by another lawyer in the matter, unless the lawyer has the consent of the other lawyer or is authorized to do so by law or a court order.
Bramwell v. Bramwell, 22 Linden App. 114 (Linden Ct. App.)
First, although a child's two-year residence in Linden makes Linden the child's current home state for new filings, a Linden court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction to modify an out-of-state custody decree while the noncustodial parent still lives in the issuing state unless the issuing court first declines jurisdiction or transfers on inconvenient-forum grounds.
Second, registering a sister-state support order in Linden under § 41-603 confers enforcement power only (where jurisdiction exists over the obligor, an employer, or property in Linden); a trial court must dismiss an obligor's motion to reduce support or shorten its duration while the obligor still resides in the issuing state without filed consents in the issuing tribunal for a qualifying state.
Third, self-help denial of court-ordered parenting time due to unpaid child support exposes the custodial parent to contempt sanctions and adverse custody findings, even when the obligor owes substantial arrears.
Part III: Written Assignment (60 Minutes)
Draft the client counseling letter from Jordan Mercer's firm to Priya Nair. Address all four of Priya's questions in clear, accessible, non-technical language while accurately applying the supplied Linden statutes, ethics rule, and Bramwell. Explain why each outcome follows, identify risks (especially around the upcoming Thanksgiving visit and the six-week relocation timeline), and lay out a practical step-by-step action plan.
Model Answer — Client Counseling Letter
Opening & Summary
Mercer Family Law PC · Oakridge, Linden
November 12, Year 6
Dear Priya,
Thank you for meeting with me today to review Owen's email and your upcoming promotion in the State of Pine. I know how stressful it is to face threats over your move while carrying Maya's expenses on your own with $4,400 in unpaid child support. The short takeaway is reassuring on support—Owen cannot use a Linden court to erase his $4,400 debt or end support at age 18—but you must handle the relocation and Owen's Thanksgiving visit carefully so you do not violate an existing court order.
1. Which Court Controls Custody and Your Move to Pine
Even though you and Maya have lived in Linden for two years—making Linden Maya's current "home state" in everyday terms—Linden's courts do not currently have legal authority to change your Oak custody decree. Under Linden's interstate custody law (Linden Code §§ 41-202 and 41-203, as interpreted in Bramwell v. Bramwell), the state that issued the original custody order (Oak) keeps exclusive power to modify custody as long as one parent still lives there, unless the Oak court decides that neither Maya, nor Maya and Owen together, still has a meaningful connection to Oak and that substantial evidence about Maya's care, training, and relationships is no longer available in Oak—or that Linden is a more convenient forum. Because Owen still lives in Oak and sees Maya there monthly and during the summer, and Oak has never declined jurisdiction, neither Owen nor you can ask a Linden judge to modify custody right now.
What this means for you: First, if Owen files in Linden to block your move or take custody, we can ask the Linden court to dismiss his custody request because only Oak has modification power (unless Oak transfers the case). Second, however, you should not move Maya to Pine unilaterally in six weeks without either Owen's written agreement or permission from the Oak court (or an Oak transfer to Linden). Moving a child out of state over the other parent's objection without court approval risks an emergency order requiring Maya's return. We should immediately retain Oak counsel to either (a) negotiate an agreed modified long-distance parenting schedule with Owen, or (b) file a relocation/modification petition—or a motion asking Oak to decline jurisdiction in favor of Linden—highlighting your 35% promotion, Pine school options, and a generous holiday/summer travel plan to preserve Owen's bond with Maya.
2. Do Not Withhold Owen's Thanksgiving Visit
I strongly advise you not to withhold Owen's Thanksgiving parenting time, even though he owes $4,400. Under Linden Code § 41-310(c) and Bramwell, child support and parenting time are completely separate legal obligations. One parent's failure to pay support never gives the other parent legal permission to block court-ordered visits. If you cancel Owen's Thanksgiving visit as leverage, a judge (in Oak or Linden) can hold you in contempt of court, award Owen makeup time or legal fees, and view your self-help negatively when deciding whether to approve your move to Pine.
Instead, allow the Thanksgiving visit as scheduled while we aggressively pursue the unpaid support through Oak counsel in Oak—where Owen lives, works, and holds assets (because Owen has no Linden employer, assets, or personal jurisdiction contacts, your Linden registration alone cannot garnish his Oak consulting or accounting income).
3. Why Owen Cannot Erase Arrears, Cut Support, or End It at Age 18 in Linden
Owen's threats regarding child support fail on multiple independent grounds under Linden's interstate support law (UIFSA) and federal-modeled arrears rules:
- Linden Lacks Power to Modify (and Oak Controls Enforcement): Registering the Oak support order in Linden last month under Linden Code § 41-603 could at most allow local collection if Owen, an employer, or assets were in Linden—never changing the order (Bramwell). Because Owen lives and works solely in Oak, Oak enforcement (through Oak counsel) is the proper channel to collect arrears, and Oak keeps exclusive authority to modify support unless both you and Owen file signed consents in the Oak court letting another state (where Maya resides or a party has personal jurisdiction, such as Linden) take over (§ 41-205(b)). We will not consent, so a Linden court must dismiss Owen's modification motion.
- The $4,400 Arrears Cannot Be Forgiven: Under Linden Code § 41-310(a) (and parallel federal law nationwide), every monthly support payment becomes a final judgment the day it comes due. No court—in Linden or Oak—can retroactively erase or reduce the $4,400 Owen already owes.
- Voluntary Career Cut Does Not Justify Lowering Future Support: Even if Owen later files in Oak, prospective reductions require a substantial, good-faith change in circumstances (§ 41-310(b)). Because Owen voluntarily cut his corporate accounting hours just four months ago to launch a consulting business, a court can "impute" (count) his prior full-time earning capacity rather than cutting Maya's support to $300/month.
- Oak's Age-21 Cutoff Controls Forever: Under Linden Code § 41-611(c)–(d) and Bramwell, the law of the state that issued the original support order (Oak) permanently governs how long child support lasts. Even if Linden later gained power to modify the dollar amount, Linden could never shorten Owen's obligation from Oak's age 21 to Linden's age 18.
4. Why Our Firm Cannot Call Owen Directly
Finally, you asked whether I can call Owen directly to settle before we bring in an Oak lawyer. Under Linden Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4.2, an attorney may not communicate about a legal dispute with someone the attorney knows is represented by a lawyer in that matter, unless that lawyer agrees. Owen's email states that Marcus Webb has represented him on the decree and is actively advising him on these issues, and Mr. Webb was copied on Owen's email. Therefore, our firm must direct any settlement outreach to Mr. Webb, not Owen directly. (Note that you and Owen may still communicate directly as co-parents about logistics if you choose, though keeping messages polite, brief, and in writing is safest while litigation is threatened.)
Recommended Next Steps
- Coordinate with Oak counsel to enforce the $1,100/month support order and $4,400 arrears directly in Oak (where Owen lives, works, and holds assets, rather than relying on the Linden registration alone).
- Honor Owen's Thanksgiving parenting time so you maintain a spotless compliance record.
- With your approval, let us contact Mr. Webb to propose a fair long-distance parenting schedule for Pine, while coordinating immediately with local Oak counsel to file a relocation petition (or inconvenient-forum transfer motion) well before your January 2 start date—and prepare to move to dismiss if Owen files in Linden.
Please let me know when you are available tomorrow so we can finalize our plan.
Sincerely,
Jordan Mercer, Esq.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 25 Points
Tone, Clarity & Structure (3 Points)
- 1 pt Uses proper client-letter format addressed to Priya Nair with clear organization around her four questions.
- 1 pt Translates legal rules (CEJ, registration for enforcement, imputation, Rule 4.2) into plain, empathetic English without unexplained jargon.
- 1 pt Provides concrete, realistic next steps aligned with the six-week timeline (January 2 move).
Question 1: Custody Jurisdiction & Relocation (7 Points)
- 1 pt Explains that even though Maya lived in Linden for two years (current home state), Linden lacks authority to modify Oak's decree under §§ 41-202/41-203 and Bramwell.
- 1 pt Identifies why Oak keeps exclusive continuing jurisdiction: Owen still resides in Oak and exercises visits there, and Oak has not declined jurisdiction or found inconvenient forum.
- 1 pt Notes Owen's threatened Linden custody filing should be dismissed for lack of modification jurisdiction.
- 1 pt Warns against moving Maya unilaterally to Pine without Owen's written consent or an Oak court order (risk of return order).
- 1 pt Recommends engaging Oak counsel to file a relocation/modification petition in Oak (or seek an inconvenient-forum transfer to Linden) and offering a concrete long-distance parenting proposal.
- 1 pt Notes supportive relocation facts (35% promotion, researched schools, preserved holiday/summer time).
- 1 pt Reaches clear conclusion on where and how to proceed.
Question 2: Withholding Thanksgiving Parenting Time (4 Points)
- 1 pt Advises firmly against withholding the Thanksgiving visit.
- 1 pt Explains Linden Code § 41-310(c) and Bramwell: support and parenting time are independent obligations.
- 1 pt Identifies consequences of self-help: contempt sanctions, makeup time/fees, and damage to Priya's relocation request.
- 1 pt Recommends honoring the visit while pursuing support and arrears enforcement in Oak (explaining why Linden lacks jurisdiction over an Oak-only obligor, employer, or assets).
Question 3: Child Support Arrears, Modification & Age Cutoff (7 Points)
- 1 pt Distinguishes enforcement registration (§ 41-603, requiring jurisdiction over obligor, employer, or assets) from authority to modify (§ 41-205(b); Bramwell).
- 1 pt Explains Oak retains UIFSA CEJ while Owen lives in Oak unless both parties file consents in a record in Oak court for a state where Maya resides or a party has personal jurisdiction.
- 1 pt Applies § 41-310(a) (Bradley Amendment rule): accrued $4,400 arrears are final judgments and can never be retroactively forgiven.
- 1 pt Explains § 41-310(b) income imputation: Owen's voluntary reduction in hours for a startup will not automatically lower future support even in Oak.
- 1 pt Applies § 41-611(c)–(d) and Bramwell: Oak's age-21 duration rule governs permanently and cannot be shortened to Linden's age 18.
- 1 pt Concludes Owen's threatened Linden support motions must be dismissed.
- 1 pt Advises Priya not to sign any consent transferring modification jurisdiction to Linden unless advised strategically.
Question 4: Direct Contact with Owen & Action Plan (4 Points)
- 1 pt Cites Linden Rule 4.2 barring lawyer communication with a person known to be represented by counsel without consent.
- 1 pt Applies facts: Owen's email confirms Marcus Webb represents him on the decree and is advising him, even though Webb is an Oak lawyer.
- 1 pt Explains the firm must contact Mr. Webb rather than Owen directly (while noting Priya herself may handle routine co-parenting logistics in writing).
- 1 pt Summarizes an integrated, chronological action plan ahead of Thanksgiving and January 2.