NextGen

1. Ownership

Present Estates and Future Interests, Concurrent Ownership, Landlord-Tenant Law, alienability, and fair housing.

Fee Simple Absolute and Defeasible Fees

Rule: Fee simple absolute is presumed absent limiting words. Fee simple determinable ("so long as," "until") ends automatically with possibility of reverter; condition subsequent ("but if" plus reentry) ends only on reentry; executory limitation shifts automatically to a third party.

Source (unverified): Restatement (First) §§ 14, 39, 44–46, 154–155, 158; Wills § 24.5; Mahrenholz.
Elements
  • Future Interests: reverter (automatic) vs. right of entry (election); executory interest shifts title to third party.
  • Construction: courts prefer condition subsequent over automatic forfeiture when ambiguous.
Invented Example

Grantor deeds "to Oak Club, provided if alcohol is served, Grantor may reenter." Serving wine leaves title until reentry.

Usual Traps
  • Motive words ("for park use") create a fee simple absolute.
  • Adverse possession begins immediately when a determinable fee ends.

Life Estates and Waste

Rule: A life tenant holds possession for a measuring life (own or pur autre vie) and owes ordinary taxes, mortgage interest, and routine repairs up to property income or rental value, while avoiding affirmative, permissive (neglect), or ameliorative waste (unless neighborhood change makes prior use obsolete).

Source (unverified): Restatement (First) §§ 117, 129, 138–140; Brokaw; Melms.
Elements
  • Carrying Costs: capped at rents received or fair rental value.
  • Waste: extraction (unless open mines), neglect, or material alteration.
Invented Example

Life Tenant occupies a house ($1,500/mo value), ignores roof leaks ($4,000), and skips $1,200 taxes: remainderman recovers both.

Usual Traps
  • Life tenants owe mortgage interest, never principal.
  • Open mines lets tenant continue mines active before the life estate.

Reversions, Remainders, and Executory Interests

Rule: Reversions stay in a grantor conveying a smaller estate. Remainders take immediately when a prior estate ends naturally (vested if ascertained taker with no condition precedent, else contingent). Executory interests cut short a prior estate (shifting) or follow a gap (springing).

Source (unverified): Restatement (First) §§ 154, 156–158.
Key Distinctions
  • Open Class: closes when any member can demand distribution (or at parent's death).
  • Gray's Rule: condition inside gift clause ("to B if B reaches 21") is contingent; separate divesting clause ("but if..., to C") is vested subject to divestment.
Invented Example

"To Spouse for life, then to Children." One living Child holds a vested remainder subject to open until Spouse dies.

Usual Traps
  • Remainders never follow defeasible fees; only executory interests do.
  • Conditions inside a gift clause make remainders contingent even after the taker's name.

Restraints on Alienation and Destructibility

Rule: Disabling restraints on legal estates (fee simple or legal life estate) and total restraints on fees (disabling, forfeiture, or promissory) are void. Statutes abolish destructibility, Shelley's Case, and Worthier Title.

Source (unverified): Restatement (First) §§ 404–406, 409; Wills §§ 16.2–16.3, 25.5.
Elements
  • Void vs. Valid: disabling restraints fail on all legal estates (valid only in spendthrift trusts); reasonable partial forfeiture or promissory restraints may stand.
  • NextGen Scope: alienability covers restraints only; RAP and options are Legacy-only (Section 6).
Invented Example

"To Sam for life, any transfer void." Disabling restraint fails; Sam may transfer.

Usual Traps
  • Disabling restraints fail on legal life estates too.
  • Total forfeiture restraints on fee simples are void.

Tenancy in Common, Joint Tenancy, and Entirety

Rule: Tenancy in common gives separate undivided shares without survivorship (presumed for unmarried co-owners). Joint tenancy requires four unities (time, title, interest, possession) plus express survivorship. Under majority law, tenancy by the entirety gives spouses survivorship immune from unilateral deeds or one spouse's ordinary creditors—except federal tax liens (United States v. Craft) and joint creditors.

Source (unverified): Presumption statutes; 2 Blackstone *180–186; Riddle; Harms; Sawada; Craft.
Elements
  • Severance: inter vivos deed, enforceable sales contract, or partition severs a joint share (mortgages sever in title-theory states only; wills never sever).
  • Entirety: ended by joint deed, death, or divorce; federal tax liens and joint creditors attach (minority reaches survivorship).
Invented Example

A, B, C hold as joint tenants; A deeds A's third to Buyer, creating tenancy in common with B and C.

Usual Traps
  • Lien-theory mortgages never sever joint tenancies; enforceable sales contracts do.
  • Divorce converts tenancy by the entirety into tenancy in common.

Co-Tenant Rights, Ouster, and Contribution

Rule: Co-tenants may possess the whole without owing rent absent ouster, but share third-party net rents. Mandatory carrying charges (taxes, mortgages) trigger affirmative contribution, whereas necessary repairs and improvements generally wait for partition or rent accounting.

Source (unverified): Spiller; Pico; Giles; Restitution Restatement § 26.
Key Distinctions
  • Carrying Costs: affirmative contribution (often offset by sole-possession rental value).
  • Repairs & Improvements: majority credits repairs at partition/accounting (minority allows contribution after advance notice); improvements earn added value at partition.
Invented Example

Cousin 1 occupies alone (no ouster), pays $3,000 taxes, adds $12,000 sunroom value: tax contribution plus $12,000 partition credit.

Usual Traps
  • Sole occupancy is not ouster; refusing entry is required.
  • Unilateral repairs earn partition/accounting credit under majority law, not an independent suit.

Leasehold Estates, Holdovers, and Possession

Rule: Tenancy for years has a fixed end (written if >1 year); periodic renews until one-period notice (6-month cap for year-to-year); tenancy at will ends by either party (usually statutory notice) or on death, landlord conveyance, or attempted assignment. On holdover, landlord may evict or bind a periodic term (1-year cap). Majority (English) law requires delivering actual possession; minority (American) law (Hannan v. Dusch) requires legal right to possession only.

Source (unverified): Restatement (Second) §§ 1.4–1.6, 6.2, 14.4; Hannan v. Dusch; Crechale.
Elements
  • Notice: precedes final period and ends on period boundary.
  • Holdover: cashing rent binds landlord; rent hike needs pre-expiration notice.
Invented Example

On March 10, month-to-month tenant notices March 31 exit: with under a month left, lease ends April 30.

Usual Traps
  • Mid-month notice ends at the next full month's end.
  • Electing eviction bars later binding a holdover term.

Quiet Enjoyment, Constructive Eviction, and Habitability

Rule: Leases imply quiet enjoyment, breached by actual eviction or constructive eviction (landlord breach causing substantial interference, notice/cure chance, prompt vacating). Residential leases carry a non-waivable implied warranty of habitability plus anti-retaliation protection.

Source (unverified): Reste Realty; Javins; URLTA §§ 2.104, 4.101, 5.101.
Elements
  • Constructive Eviction: substantial interference, notice, failure to cure, prompt vacating.
  • Habitability (Residential): tenant may stay and abate/withhold rent, repair and deduct, or vacate.
Invented Example

Flat lacks heat after notice: residential tenant may stay and abate; commercial tenant must vacate.

Usual Traps
  • Staying in possession defeats constructive eviction.
  • Commercial leases lack an implied warranty of habitability.

Assignments, Subleases, and Transfer Clauses

Rule: Assignments transfer the entire remaining term (creating privity of estate with landlord while original tenant stays in privity of contract); subleases transfer less than the full term (creating no landlord privity). Anti-transfer clauses are strictly construed (minority requires reasonable grounds to withhold consent).

Source (unverified): Restatement (Second) §§ 15.1–15.2, 16.1; Kendall.
Key Distinctions
  • Assignment: assignee owes rent in privity of estate until reassigning (or permanently if assuming).
  • Sublease: no direct landlord-sublessee suit absent assumption; banning assignment allows subleasing.
Invented Example

Tenant assigns 18 remaining months to A1; 12 months later, A1 assigns all 6 remaining months to A2. A1's privity of estate ends; Tenant keeps contract privity.

Usual Traps
  • Keeping one day (or transferring 6 of 18 remaining months) creates a sublease regardless of label.
  • Abandoning without reassigning leaves an assignee in privity of estate.

Abandonment and Mitigation

Rule: Upon unjustified abandonment, landlord may accept surrender (ending future rent), re-let on tenant's account, or—under majority law—must make reasonable efforts to mitigate damages.

Source (unverified): Sommer v. Kridel; URLTA § 4.203.
Elements
  • Surrender: accepting keys for landlord's use ends future rent.
  • Mitigation: ordinary re-letting efforts; bars avoidable rent.
Invented Example

Tenant abandons with 6 months left; Landlord refuses applicants: majority bars avoidable rent.

Usual Traps
  • Minority common law imposed no duty to mitigate.
  • Trade fixtures appear under Legacy MBE Topics below.

Fair Housing

Rule: The FHA bars housing discrimination (including disparate impact) by race, color, religion, sex, familial status, national origin, or disability (reasonable policy accommodations without fee; physical modifications at tenant's expense). Under § 3603(b), Mrs. Murphy (≤4 owner-occupied units) and owner-sold or owner-rented single-family homes (≤3 owned, no broker) never excuse § 3604(c) ads; § 1982 bars all racial bias without exemption.

Source (unverified): 42 U.S.C. §§ 3603–3607, 1982; Jones; Inclusive Communities.
Elements
  • § 3603(b) Exemptions: Mrs. Murphy (≤4 owner-occupied); owner-sold/rented single-family (≤3 owned, no broker)—never cover § 3604(c) ads.
  • § 3607 Exemptions: § 3607(b) senior housing exempts familial-status ads/limits; § 3607(a) covers qualifying religious/club limits.
Invented Example

Owner lives in a triplex and posts "No children": § 3603(b) never covers § 3604(c) ads.

Usual Traps
  • Brokers forfeit single-family exemption; disabled tenants pay for physical modifications.
  • Senior housing (§ 3607(b)) is exempt from familial-status rules (including ads), never race or disability.
↑ Back to Contents
NextGen

2. Rights

Easements, Covenants, and Servitudes: easements, licenses, profits, and restrictive covenants.

Easement Types and Creation

Rule: Appurtenant benefits pass with the dominant parcel; servient burdens bind buyers unless cut off by a recording act without actual, record, or inquiry notice. Traditional MBE law transfers easements in gross only if commercial (Third Restatement allows transfer unless personal). Easements arise by writing, implication, strict necessity, prescription, or estoppel.

Source (unverified): Restatement (First) §§ 489–491; Servitudes §§ 1.5, 2.1, 2.10, 2.12, 2.15 (Reporter's Note), 2.16–2.17, 4.6; Van Sandt.
Elements
  • Implied vs. Necessity: common title plus apparent, continuous, reasonably necessary prior use (some courts require strict necessity for implied reservations), or strict landlocking.
  • Prescription & Estoppel: open, notorious, adverse, continuous use for the statutory period (no exclusivity); or substantial reliance on a license.
Invented Example

Owner paves a needed driveway across Lot 1 to Lot 2, then sells Lot 2 silently: implied prior-use easement.

Usual Traps
  • Necessity easements end once public road access opens.
  • Negative easements (light, air, support, stream water) never arise by prescription.

Scope, Termination, Licenses, and Profits

Rule: Easements allow normal dominant-land growth, but serving nondominant land is enjoinable misuse, not forfeiture. Licenses are revocable absent estoppel; profits allow resource removal.

Source (unverified): Servitudes §§ 1.2, 4.10–4.11, 7.1–7.8; Brown v. Voss.
Termination (END CRAMP)
  • END C: Estoppel, ended Necessity, Destruction of servient building, Condemnation.
  • RAMP: Release, Abandonment (physical act + intent), Merger, Prescription.
Invented Example

Skipping driveway use for 12 years without blocking it is nonuse, not abandonment.

Usual Traps
  • Nonuse alone never terminates an easement.
  • Merger permanently destroys an easement; reselling never revives it.

Real Covenants vs. Equitable Servitudes

Rule: Real covenants run at law (damages): burden needs writing, intent, touch and concern, horizontal privity, strict vertical privity, and notice; benefit omits horizontal privity/notice and needs relaxed vertical privity (any lesser estate). Equitable servitudes run in equity (injunction) without privity via writing—or an implied reciprocal negative servitude (negative restrictions only, from a pre-existing developer plan)—plus actual, record, or inquiry notice.

Source (unverified): Spencer's Case; Tulk; Sanborn v. McLean; Neponsit.
Elements
  • Privity Defined: horizontal = shared/conveyed interest at creation (e.g., grantor-grantee, never independent neighbors); strict vertical = entire estate.
  • Common Scheme: implies negative building/use restrictions only from pre-existing plan, never affirmative covenants.
Invented Example

Developer sells 19 lots with recorded residential covenants, then Lot 20 silently: uniform homes give inquiry notice.

Usual Traps
  • Equitable defenses: subdivision-wide changed conditions, acquiescence, unclean hands, laches, estoppel.
  • HOA dues touch and concern land (require writing—never implied by common scheme).
↑ Back to Contents
NextGen

3. Sales Contracts

Creation, remedies, disclosure, and marketable title (see Titles for deeds; Legacy for conversion, merger, fitness).

Creation, Remedies, and Seller Disclosure

Rule: Land contracts need a writing signed by party charged (parties, property, price) unless equitable part performance applies (two of possession, payment, improvements). Closing time is not of the essence unless stated or implied. Sellers must disclose known latent material physical defects.

Source (unverified): Statute of Frauds § 4; Restatement (Second) of Contracts §§ 129, 161; Johnson v. Davis.
Elements
  • Part Performance: yields specific performance in equity only, never legal damages.
  • Remedies: specific performance (with abatement for minor defects), contract-minus-market damages, or seller retaining ~10% earnest money.
Invented Example

Oral lot buyer pays half, takes possession, builds garage: specific performance via part performance.

Usual Traps
  • "As is" clauses never shield fraud or active concealment.
  • Time is not of the essence unless stated or implied by notice.

Marketable Title

Rule: Land contracts imply marketable title—free from reasonable doubt or litigation risk—at closing. Encumbrances, encroachments, existing zoning violations, and completed adverse possession (unless quieted of record or released) defeat marketability; zoning ordinances alone or visible beneficial utility easements generally do not.

Source (unverified): Lohmeyer v. Bower; Wallach v. Riverside Bank.
Key Distinctions
  • Closing Date & AP: marketable at closing; unquieted adverse-possession title is unmarketable.
  • Easements & Zoning: burdensome private easements breach marketability; beneficial visible utilities do not.
Invented Example

Before closing, Buyer finds garage violates setback: unmarketable unless cured by closing.

Usual Traps
  • Zoning ordinances alone leave title marketable; existing violations breach it.
  • Buyers cannot rescind early over mortgages payable from closing proceeds.
↑ Back to Contents
NextGen

4. Mortgages and Foreclosure

Theories, due-on-sale, transfers, foreclosure, and Recording Acts and Mortgages priority.

Mortgage Theories, Due-on-Sale, Assumption, and Redemption

Rule: Lien theory (majority) leaves title/possession in owner until foreclosure; title theory gives lender legal title at execution; intermediate theory shifts title/possession to lender at default. Equitable redemption requires paying the full accelerated balance (plus interest/costs) before sale. Due-on-sale clauses are federally enforceable (Garn–St. Germain).

Source (unverified): Mortgages Restatement §§ 3.1, 4.1, 5.1–5.3; 12 U.S.C. § 1701j-3; Harms.
Key Distinctions
  • Clogging vs. Deed in Lieu: waiving redemption at creation is void; post-default deed in lieu is valid but leaves junior liens intact.
  • Subject To vs. Assumes: default is "subject to" (no buyer liability); "assumes" makes buyer primary and borrower a surety.
Invented Example

Buyer takes "subject to" a $100,000 mortgage; foreclosure yields $80,000: Owner alone owes $20,000 deficiency.

Usual Traps
  • Unconsented material modification discharges surety completely (common law) or to extent of prejudice (Restatement).
  • Residential family/death/trust transfers enjoy federal due-on-sale exceptions.

Foreclosure, Priority, and PMMs

Rule: Foreclosure destroys joined junior interests while leaving senior liens intact; proceeds pay costs, foreclosing debt, junior liens in order, then debtor. Purchase-money mortgages (PMMs) beat prior general judgment liens and after-acquired property clauses against buyer.

Source (unverified): Mortgages Restatement §§ 3.1, 7.1–7.2, 7.4, 8.2; Murphy; Syracuse Savings.
Priority Rules
  • Priority & Omitted Juniors: recording acts and PMM super-priority modify first-in-time; unjoined juniors survive.
  • Statutory Redemption: some states allow post-sale repurchase at foreclosure sale price.
Invented Example

Junior lender forecloses $30,000 lien behind $120,000 senior mortgage: Buyer takes subject to senior lien.

Usual Traps
  • Junior foreclosure proceeds never pay senior mortgages; senior liens stay on the land.
  • A seller PMM beats a third-party PMM unless a recording act (BFP without notice) or subordination gives the third-party PMM priority.
↑ Back to Contents
NextGen

5. Titles

Adverse Possession, Land Sale Contracts and Deeds, and recording acts.

Adverse Possession: Elements, Tacking, and Disabilities

Rule: Title passes by continuous, open and notorious, actual, exclusive, and hostile possession for the statutory period; majority tests hostility objectively (minorities require good/bad faith). Voluntary privity permits tacking; disabilities toll only if present at entry; time never runs against future interests or government land.

Source (unverified): Ewing; Mannillo; Howard v. Kunto.
Elements (COAH)
  • Continuous & Open: regular owner-like use (even seasonal cabins) visible to attentive owners.
  • Actual, Exclusive & Hostile: physical unshared occupation without permission.
Invented Example

In 10-year state, Trespasser uses seasonal cabin 6 summers and deeds to Successor (4 summers): tacking vests title.

Usual Traps
  • Disabilities never tack; only a disability at entry tolls the clock.
  • Color of title extends constructively only to contiguous land of the same owner not possessed by others.

Transfer by Deed and Title Covenants

Rule: Deeds require a writing signed by grantor (grantor, grantee, grant words, land description; no consideration needed) and delivery (present intent to convey). Direct delivery drops oral conditions (written deed conditions stand); escrow delivery is valid. Forged/undelivered deeds are void even against a BFP; fraudulently induced deeds are voidable (BFP wins). Quitclaim gives no covenants; special warranty covers grantor's period; general warranty gives six covenants, damages capped at grantor's received price.

Source (unverified): Sweeney; Rosengrant; Brown v. Lober; Rockafellor.
Six General Warranty Covenants
  • Present (at delivery; do not run): Seisin, Right to Convey, Against Encumbrances.
  • Future (eviction by pre-existing claim; run): Quiet Enjoyment, Warranty, Further Assurances.
Invented Example

Grantor gives general warranty deed despite recorded easement; Buyer sells to B2, whom Holder blocks: B2 sues Grantor on future covenants.

Usual Traps
  • Buyer notice is no defense to encumbrance/future covenants (split only on visible physical easements); future covenants require eviction.
  • Destroying or returning a delivered deed never restores title.

Recording Acts, Estoppel by Deed, and Shelter

Rule: Race favors first to record; notice protects a subsequent BFP without notice at conveyance; race-notice protects a BFP who records first. Under the shelter rule, transferees from a BFP take BFP protection even with notice; wild deeds give no record notice. Under estoppel by deed, after-acquired title passes automatically to a prior warranty grantee (subject to a later BFP if recorded early outside the chain).

Source (unverified): State recording acts; Luthi; Guillette; Sabo v. Horvath.
Elements of BFP Status
  • Value & No Notice: value includes mortgagees for new value (usually not judgment creditors or donees); no actual, record, or inquiry notice.
  • Wild Deed: recorded deed from unrecorded grantor sits outside chain.
Invented Example

Owner deeds to B1 (unrecorded), then B2 (BFP), who records and gifts to Niece (with notice): shelter protects Niece.

Usual Traps
  • Visible occupancy gives inquiry notice, defeating BFP status.
  • "Without notice" alone = notice; "first recorded" alone = race; both = race-notice.
↑ Back to Contents
Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

6. Legacy MBE Topics

Legacy Real Property MBE topics (through Feb. 2028): RAP, fixtures, conversion, options, fitness, merger, brokerage, wills, Zoning, Takings (Takings stays on NextGen Con Law), support, and water.

Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP)

Rule: Common-law RAP voids contingent remainders, executory interests, open classes, options in gross, and rights of first refusal unless they must vest, if at all, within 21 years after a life in being at creation (USRAP: 90 years/wait-and-see). Class gifts fail all-or-nothing (Jee v. Audley); striking a void executory interest leaves FSD + reverter after durational words ("so long as..., then to B"), or fee simple absolute if inside the stricken divesting clause (", but if..., then to B").

Source (unverified): Duke of Norfolk's Case; Jee v. Audley; USRAP § 1.
Elements
  • Exempt: grantor interests, indefeasibly vested or divestible remainders (divesting interest tested), charity-to-charity shifts, tenant lease options.
  • All-or-Nothing: if any potential class member could vest late, the entire class fails.
Invented Example

"To Child for life, then to Child's first grandchild to reach 25": grandchild gift fails at common law.

Usual Traps
  • Fertile octogenarian presumes any living person can have children.
  • RAP spares grantor future interests and current-tenant lease options.
Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

Fixtures and Trade Fixtures

Rule: Chattels annexed to realty with objective permanence intent become fixtures passing with the land. Tenants may remove commercial trade fixtures before lease end (or promptly after unpredictable termination) if repairing physical damage.

Source (unverified): Teaff v. Hewitt; Restatement (Second) § 12.2.
Elements
  • Fixture Test: annexation, adaptation, objective permanence intent.
  • Trade Fixtures: removable before lease end with damage repair.
Invented Example

Baker bolts ovens into shop, unbolts them and patches floor before lease end: trade fixtures.

Usual Traps
  • Trade fixtures left past lease end pass to landlord.
  • Landowner's fixtures pass to a buyer or mortgagee.
Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

Equitable Conversion, Merger, Fitness, and Options

Rule: Equitable conversion puts equitable title and majority pre-closing casualty risk on buyer; UVPRA keeps risk on seller until legal title or possession transfers (even if vacant). Closing merges title promises except collateral duties; builder-vendors warrant new homes for latent defects (reaching later buyers).

Source (unverified): Skelly Oil; UVPRA § 1; Lempke; Petersen.
Key Distinctions
  • Conversion & Options: pre-closing death turns seller's claim into personalty, buyer's into realty; options in gross face RAP.
  • Merger & Fitness: deed merges title claims; builder fitness protects later buyers.
Invented Example

Lightning destroys a Linden house between signing and closing: under majority law, Buyer still owes the price.

Usual Traps
  • Collateral promises (repairs, builder fitness) survive merger.
  • UVPRA keeps risk on seller even if vacant until title or possession transfers.
Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

Brokerage and Transfer by Will

Rule: Traditional brokerage earns commission on producing a ready, willing, able buyer; modern majority (Ellsworth Dobbs) requires closing unless seller defaults. Specific devises adeem by extinction if unowned at death (UPC exceptions); modern law abolishes mortgage exoneration; anti-lapse substitutes a predeceased kindred devisee's issue.

Source (unverified): Ellsworth Dobbs; UPC §§ 2-603, 2-606, 2-607.
Elements
  • Brokerage: exclusive right-to-sell covers owner sales; exclusive agency excludes owner's buyer.
  • Wills: devisee takes subject to mortgage absent express payoff; survival words defeat anti-lapse (majority, not UPC).
Invented Example

Testator devises mortgaged Oak Lot to Son; residue to Daughter. Under modern statutes, Son takes subject to the mortgage.

Usual Traps
  • Common law presumed mortgage exoneration; modern/UPC law reverses it.
  • Anti-lapse covers kindred only (not spouses/friends) leaving issue.
Zoning: Legacy only (through Feb. 2028) · Takings: NextGen Con Law & Legacy

Zoning, Variances, and Takings

Rule: Zoning (Legacy MBE) is valid unless arbitrary, protects prior nonconforming uses (no expansion), and allows variances for unique, non-self-created hardship. Under the Fifth Amendment (NextGen Con Law & Legacy), permanent physical invasions or total economic wipeouts (absent nuisance law) are per se takings; others use Penn Central; permit/fee exactions need nexus and rough proportionality (Koontz; Sheetz).

Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. V; Euclid; Loretto; Lucas; Penn Central; Nollan; Dolan; Koontz; Sheetz.
Elements
  • Takings: physical occupation or 100% wipeout (per se); else Penn Central.
  • Exactions: nexus and rough proportionality for administrative and legislative land/fee exactions.
Invented Example

Linden conditions a bakery permit on deeding a bike trail without added bike traffic: unconstitutional exaction.

Usual Traps
  • An 85% value drop is not a Lucas taking if viable use remains.
  • Zoning never overrides a stricter private covenant; Takings is active on NextGen Con Law.
Legacy only (through Feb. 2028)

Lateral Support and Water Rights

Rule: Excavators are strictly liable for natural land subsidence; for improved land, majority law (Restatement § 817(2)) imposes strict liability for land and buildings if natural soil would collapse, requiring negligence only if building weight caused collapse (minority: land only). Eastern states use reasonable-use riparianism; western states use prior appropriation.

Source (unverified): Torts Restatement §§ 817, 819–820, 850–850A; Coffin; Keys.
Key Distinctions
  • Subjacent Support: strict liability for surface buildings existing at severance.
  • Water: riparian ties to abutting land; appropriation gives priority by first beneficial use; surface uses common-enemy, natural-flow, or reasonable use.
Invented Example

Careful excavation causes subsidence only from heavy warehouse weight: no strict liability.

Usual Traps
  • Prior appropriation rights can be lost by nonuse; riparian rights cannot.
  • Lateral support strict liability covers buildings too if natural soil would fail.
↑ Back to Contents

More memory hooks

↑ Back to Contents