Constitutional Law Study Guide
Black-letter rules, elements, examples, and traps across Judicial Review and Justiciability, Separation of Powers, Federalism, Due Process, Equal Protection, Freedom of Speech, and Freedom of Religion.
Written for study. Not legal advice.
Exam Labels: Numbered parts follow NextGen; Legacy exam only (through February 2028) marks MBE-only topics.
1. Federal Judicial Power
Authority to Interpret
Rule: Federal courts review constitutionality of federal and state acts; Supreme Court reviews state judgments resting on federal law, binding all officials.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. III, § 2; art. VI; Marbury; Martin; Cooper.- Supremacy: Constitution overrides statutes; states cannot nullify federal rulings.
- Finality: Supreme Court review requires final judgment from state's highest court.
State A statute declares U.S. Supreme Court ruling void. Invalid (Cooper).
- Congress cannot expand Supreme Court original jurisdiction beyond Article III.
- Congress may regulate Supreme Court appellate jurisdiction (Exceptions Clause).
Case or Controversy and Standing
Rule: Standing requires concrete, particularized, actual/imminent injury traceable to defendant and redressable. Taxpayer standing covers only specific congressional Article I spending violating Establishment Clause.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. III, § 2; art. IV, § 3; Lujan; TransUnion; Flast; Valley Forge; Hein; Hunt.- Personal Stake: Concrete injury; generalized citizen grievances fail.
- Associational: Member standing, germane claim, no individual proof needed.
Taxpayer challenges agency Article IV land transfer to religious camp. No standing (Flast excludes property transfers/general spending).
- Congress cannot waive Article III concrete injury.
- Third-party standing needs close relationship and obstacle to suing.
Advisory Opinions, Ripeness, and Mootness
Rule: Federal courts bar advisory opinions; disputes must be ripe (fit, hardship from delay) and live absent mootness exceptions.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. III, § 2; Muskrat; Abbott Labs; DeFunis; Roe; Laidlaw; Sosna.- Voluntary Cessation: Moots case only if defendant makes it absolutely clear wrongful behavior cannot reasonably recur.
- Capable of Repetition: Brief injury likely to recur against same plaintiff.
- Class Actions: Certified classes stay live while unnamed members retain live claims (Sosna).
Linden bans leaflets at two-week fair; fair ends before trial. Live as evading review.
- Past-damages claims stay live after law's repeal.
- State courts may issue advisory opinions under state law; federal courts cannot.
The Eleventh Amendment
Rule: Eleventh Amendment bars private federal suits naming unconsenting states/agencies for any relief (damages or injunctive), and official-capacity suits for retroactive treasury damages or "equitable restitution." Under Ex parte Young, prospective officer injunctions against ongoing federal-law (never state-law) violations proceed despite ancillary costs; personal-capacity damages also proceed.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. XI; Ex parte Young; Edelman; Pugh; Pennhurst; Hafer; Seminole Tribe; Katz; Torres; Fitzpatrick; Mt. Healthy.- Exceptions: Consent, 14th § 5 abrogation, plan-of-Convention suits (U.S./states, Bankruptcy, War Powers), Ex parte Young federal-law suits.
- Municipalities: Cities, counties, and school boards lack immunity.
Contractor sues State A directly for injunction and Director for $50,000 back pay plus federal injunction. State suit and back pay fail; officer injunction proceeds.
- No Article I Commerce/IP abrogation (unlike Bankruptcy/War Powers); Ex parte Young excludes state law (Pennhurst).
- Retroactive treasury awards remain barred even if styled "equitable restitution."
Adequate and Independent State Grounds
Rule: Supreme Court lacks jurisdiction over state judgments resting on adequate, independent state-law grounds, even if federal law was discussed.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. III, § 2; Michigan v. Long.- Adequate: State law alone supports judgment.
- Independent: Ruling does not rely on federal law; plain statement controls.
State A's high court voids rule under both constitutions, stating state law independently compels result. Review barred.
- Absent plain statement of independence when interwoven with federal law, review is presumed.
- States may grant broader rights than federal minima, never fewer.
Political Question Doctrine
Rule: Federal courts decline political questions textually committed to another branch or lacking judicially manageable standards.
Source (unverified): Baker v. Carr; Nixon v. United States; Rucho.- Nonjusticiable: Impeachment procedures, foreign recognition, federal partisan gerrymandering.
- Justiciable: Malapportionment (one person, one vote) and racial gerrymandering.
Voters challenge State B's congressional map in federal court solely as partisan gerrymandering. Nonjusticiable (Rucho).
- Racial gerrymandering remains justiciable under Equal Protection.
- State courts may review partisan gerrymandering under state law.
2. Legislative Powers
Enumerated Powers, Necessary and Proper, Taxing, and Spending
Rule: Congress acts via enumerated powers plus Necessary and Proper means, lacking general police power. Conditional grants must be unambiguous, germane, constitutional, and non-coercive.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, § 8; McCulloch; Comstock; Dole; NFIB.- Necessary & Proper: Executes enumerated power; never stands alone.
- Tax vs. Penalty: Revenue-raising, non-punitive exactions without scienter are taxes.
Congress cuts 100% of State B hospital grants (18% of budget) unless zoning passes. Coercive.
- Congress holds general police power only over D.C. and territories.
- Modest cuts (5% highway funds) are valid encouragement.
Interstate Commerce Power
Rule: Congress regulates channels, instrumentalities/items in interstate commerce, and intrastate economic acts substantially affecting interstate commerce in aggregate.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, § 8, cl. 3; Wickard; Lopez; Morrison; Raich; NFIB.- Channels & Instrumentalities: Highways, telecom, vehicles, goods crossing borders.
- Substantial Effects: Aggregation requires economic activity; non-economic local conduct fails.
Congress bans backyard wheat for home use under national farm-price law. Market substitution supports aggregation.
- Congress cannot compel inactive people to buy products under Commerce Clause.
- Interstate jurisdictional hook usually validates statute.
Enforcement of the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments
Rule: Thirteenth Amendment § 2 reaches private racial discrimination as badge of slavery. Fourteenth Amendment § 5 remedies must be congruent and proportional to unconstitutional state conduct; Fifteenth Amendment § 2 voting remedies need current justification.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amends. XIII–XV; Jones; City of Boerne; Shelby County.- 13th § 2: Reaches private racial bias in housing and contracts.
- 14th § 5: Enforces—cannot redefine—rights; must fit documented state violations.
Under 14th § 5, Congress applies strict scrutiny to neutral state zoning without animus pattern. Fails Boerne.
- 14th § 5 reaches state action, not purely private conduct.
- Valid § 5 statutes abrogate state Eleventh Amendment immunity.
Presentment, Veto, and Nondelegation
Rule: Legislative acts altering legal rights require bicameral passage and presentment to President, barring legislative and line-item vetoes. Congress may delegate rulemaking guided by intelligible principle.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, §§ 1, 7; Chadha; Clinton v. City of New York; Whitman.- Bicameralism & Presentment: House, Senate, and President must act on legislative changes.
- Intelligible Principle: Broad standards like "public interest" satisfy nondelegation.
Statute lets one House veto agency deportation waivers. Violates bicameralism/presentment.
- Two-House legislative vetoes without presentment are equally unconstitutional.
- Presidents cannot cancel single spending items in signed bills (line-item veto).
3. Executive Powers
Commander in Chief, Domestic Power, and Immunities
Rule: Under Youngstown, domestic presidential power peaks with congressional authorization, enters twilight in silence, and hits lowest ebb when defying Congress. Presidents hold official-act immunity (core criminal absolute; non-core criminal at least presumptive; civil absolute), not private-act immunity.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. II; Youngstown; Nixon; Fitzgerald; Clinton v. Jones; Trump.- Commander in Chief: Directs military forces; grants no domestic lawmaking or seizure power.
- Privilege & Immunity: Executive privilege yields to criminal subpoenas; none for private acts.
President seizes Oakridge steel mills during strike after Congress rejected seizure. Zone 3 seizure fails.
- Civil suits for pre-office private conduct proceed against sitting Presidents.
- Pardons cover federal crimes only, never state crimes or impeachment.
Appointment and Removal
Rule: Principal officers need Senate confirmation; inferior officers (supervised by principal officers) may be vested in President, courts, or department heads. President removes principal executive officers—single agency heads and multimember regulatory commissioners—at will; single-tier good-cause limits work only for limited-duty inferior officers (leaving open Federal Reserve and non-Article III judges).
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. II, § 2; Buckley; Edmond; Myers; Bowsher; Morrison; Free Enterprise Fund; Seila Law; Trump v. Slaughter (overruling Humphrey's Executor).- No Congressional Control: Congress cannot appoint or remove officers (beyond impeachment).
- Good-Cause Limits: Barred for principal heads/commissioners; valid only for limited inferior officers without two-tier shields.
Congress creates single-Director safety agency removable only for cause. Invalid (Seila Law).
- Congress cannot assign executive duties to officers it can remove.
- Multimember regulatory commissioners cannot get for-cause tenure (Slaughter).
Federal Administrative Agencies
Rule: Agencies wield only statutorily delegated power. Under major questions doctrine, rules of vast economic or political significance need clear congressional authorization; courts exercise independent judgment on ambiguous text.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, § 1; art. II; West Virginia v. EPA; Loper Bright.- Major Questions: Transformative rules cannot rest on vague ancillary clauses.
- Independent Review: Courts resolve statutory ambiguity independently while respecting express delegations.
Citing minor clause, agency orders nationwide plant closures. Lacks clear authorization (West Virginia v. EPA).
- Major-questions rules fail even when Congress could have enacted them.
- Courts do not defer automatically to agency readings of ambiguous statutes.
War/Foreign Affairs, Take Care, and Treaties
Rule: Congress declares war and funds forces; President commands troops, recognizes foreign states, and faithfully executes laws (Take Care). Self-executing treaties and congressional-executive agreements equal statutes (last in time); sole executive agreements override state law only.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. II, §§ 2–3; art. VI; Medellin; Whitney; Belmont; Pink; Dames & Moore; Zivotofsky.- Hierarchy: Constitution > Statutes / Self-Executing Treaties / Congressional-Executive Agreements > Sole Executive Agreements > State Law.
- Take Care: President cannot dispense with statutes or refuse appropriated spending.
Sole executive agreement conflicts with state law and prior federal statute. Overrides state law, not statute.
- Sole executive agreements never override federal statutes (congressional-executive agreements can).
- Non-self-executing treaties require implementing legislation.
4. Nation and States
Intergovernmental Immunities
Rule: States cannot directly tax or regulate federal entities or discriminate against federal workers, retirees, or contractors without congressional consent. Nondiscriminatory state income taxes on federal workers are valid.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 2; McCulloch; Mayo; Graves; Dawson v. Steager.- Direct Burden: No state taxes or licensing mandates laid directly on federal agencies.
- No Discrimination: Cannot exempt state retirees while taxing comparable federal retirees.
State A taxes federal postal pensions while exempting State A police pensions without job differences. Invalid.
- Nondiscriminatory sales or income taxes borne indirectly by contractors are valid.
- Congress may apply generally applicable wage laws to state employers.
Federalism Limits: Preemption and Anti-Commandeering
Rule: Under Supremacy Clause, valid federal law overrides state law via express, field, or conflict preemption. Under Tenth Amendment, Congress cannot commandeer state legislatures or conscript state officers to enforce federal programs.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. VI; amend. X; Arizona; Gade; Testa; New York; Printz; Murphy.- Preemption: Express bar, occupied field, impossibility, or obstacle to federal purpose.
- Anti-Commandeering: Cannot compel state laws, bar repeals, or conscript sheriffs.
Federal law orders sheriffs to inspect depots while expressly preempting stricter brake rules. Mandate fails; preemption holds.
- State courts must hear federal claims under Supremacy Clause (Testa).
- State laws mirroring federal goals fail when Congress occupies field.
Federalism Limits: Dormant Commerce and Full Faith and Credit
Rule: Absent congressional approval, discriminatory state laws fail unless necessary for non-protectionist purpose with no alternative; neutral laws fail under Pike only if interstate burdens clearly exceed local benefits. Interstate taxes must meet Complete Auto. States honor sister-state final judgments.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, § 8; art. IV, § 1; Philadelphia v. New Jersey; Pike; Complete Auto; Wayfair; Alexandria Scrap; Reeves; Wunnicke; Baker.- Interstate Taxes (Complete Auto): Substantial nexus (economic/virtual presence suffices, Wayfair), fair apportionment, non-discrimination, fair relation to services.
- Market Participant & FFC: Direct state buyers/sellers may favor locals (not downstream markets); final merits judgments from courts with jurisdiction bind sister states.
State A requires state-timber buyers to mill in-state. Downstream rules in separate markets violate Dormant Commerce.
- Local-processing mandates fail when nondiscriminatory inspection works.
- Full Faith and Credit applies even if rendering court misapplied law.
Privileges and Immunities Clauses
Rule: Article IV bars state bias against out-of-state citizens on livelihood/fundamental rights absent substantial justification (peculiar harm source, no less restrictive means). 14th Amendment protects new residents' travel rights.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. IV, § 2; amend. XIV; United Building; Piper; Baldwin; Paul; Saenz.- Claimants: Out-of-state individual U.S. citizens (not corporations or noncitizens).
- Interests: Livelihood, property, court access (not hobbies).
Linden requires 75% resident hiring. Out-of-state individual Worker has valid Article IV claim.
- No market-participant exception for Article IV Privileges and Immunities.
- Corporations sue under Dormant Commerce, not Article IV.
5. Individual Rights
State Action and Selective Incorporation
Rule: Rights bind government unless private actors perform traditional, exclusive public functions or state entanglement, coercion, or enforcement (e.g., judicial covenant enforcement) applies; 13th Amendment bars private slavery directly. Most Bill of Rights guarantees bind states via 14th Amendment.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amends. XIII, XIV; Marsh; Shelley; Burton; Moose Lodge; Halleck; Hurtado; Bombolis; McDonald; Ramos.- State Action: Elections, company towns, joint leasing, or judicial racial-covenant enforcement (Shelley) qualify; licensing, utilities, funding fail.
- Unincorporated: 5th grand jury and 7th civil jury (held not incorporated); 3rd quartering, Excessive Bail, Vicinage (never incorporated).
Club with state liquor license bars Guest by race. Licensing is not state action.
- Unanimous criminal juries (Ramos) and Excessive Fines (Timbs) are incorporated.
- Congress reaches private racial bias under Thirteenth Amendment § 2.
Procedural Due Process
Rule: Deliberate government deprivations of life, liberty, or property entitlements require notice and meaningful hearing under Mathews balancing; mere official negligence is not a deprivation (recklessness left open in Daniels).
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amends. V, XIV; Mathews; Goldberg; Roth; Paul v. Davis; Loudermill; Daniels v. Williams; Hudson v. Palmer.- Liberty & Property: Stigma-plus (reputation plus lost status/job, Paul v. Davis); statutory/for-cause entitlements (not at-will jobs).
- Hearings & Mathews: Balance private interest, error risk/safeguards, government burden; tenured staff get pre-termination notice/reply plus post-termination hearing (Loudermill).
Linden revokes for-cause license without notice or hearing. Violates Due Process.
- Negligence is not a deprivation (Daniels); random unauthorized property loss uses state post-deprivation remedies (Hudson).
- Welfare needs pre-termination hearings; emergencies allow post-deprivation hearings.
Substantive Due Process
Rule: Infringing fundamental rights (marriage, contraception, parenting, related family living, voting, travel) triggers strict scrutiny (government proves narrowly tailored to compelling interest); economic laws and unrelated-household caps get rational basis (challenger proves no rational relation to any conceivable legitimate interest). Unenumerated rights need deep historical roots.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amends. V, XIV; Loving; Griswold; Moore; Belle Terre; Troxel; Lee Optical; Glucksberg; Dobbs.- Family: Extended related family gets strict scrutiny (Moore); unrelated roommates get rational basis (Belle Terre).
- Tradition: Rights lacking deep historical roots (abortion) get rational basis.
Linden bars grandmother from living with grandchildren. Fails strict scrutiny.
- Unrelated-roommate caps pass rational basis (Belle Terre).
- Fit parents' custody choices hold fundamental-right protection (Troxel).
Equal Protection
Rule: Heightened scrutiny requires intentional discrimination (facial, application, or purpose plus impact). Race, national origin, state alienage (outside political functions), and severe voting/travel burdens get strict scrutiny; sex and non-marital parentage get intermediate scrutiny; ordinary election rules use Anderson-Burdick; age, disability, and federal alienage get rational basis.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amends. V, XIV; Bolling; Davis; Yick Wo; SFFA; Graham; Foley; Diaz; Plyler; VMI; Clark; Cleburne; Romer; Allegheny Pittsburgh; Reynolds; Harper; Anderson; Burdick; Crawford; Shapiro; Saenz.- Tiers & Burdens: Strict: government proves narrowly tailored to compelling interest (specific past discrimination, not diversity, SFFA). Intermediate: government proves substantially related to important objective (sex needs exceedingly persuasive justification, no stereotypes, VMI). Rational basis: challenger proves arbitrary/irrational or illegitimate animus, not rationally related to any conceivable legitimate interest.
- Voting, Travel & Alienage: Poll taxes, one-person-one-vote malapportionment, 1-year welfare/voting bars fail strict scrutiny (1-year tuition/divorce residency and photo ID or 30–50 day cutoffs pass); state alienage fails outside political functions (police, teachers, probation).
State B bars noncitizens from CPA licenses; State A denies disabled group-home permits from animus. Both fail.
- Undocumented immigrants are not a suspect class, yet K–12 schooling cannot be denied absent a substantial state interest (Plyler).
- 5th Amendment Due Process reverse-incorporates Equal Protection against Congress.
Takings Clause
Rule: Taking property requires rationally related public use and just compensation (fair market value). Per se takings are physical invasions and 100% land wipeouts (absent background nuisance/property limits); partial rules use Penn Central (economic impact, investment-backed expectations, character); legislative or administrative exactions need nexus and rough proportionality.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. V; Kelo; Loretto; Cedar Point; Lucas; Penn Central; Nollan; Dolan; Sheetz.- Per Se: Permanent/intermittent physical invasion or total land wipeout (excluding background property/nuisance limits).
- Exactions: Legislative/administrative permit land/fee demands need nexus and rough proportionality.
City conditions shed permit on deeding unrelated 30-foot bike trail. Unconstitutional taking.
- 75% value drop is not per se Lucas taking if viable use remains.
- Public use covers economic redevelopment to private owners (Kelo).
Ex Post Facto Laws
Rule: Ex Post Facto bars retroactive criminal laws criminalizing innocent acts, increasing punishment, or lowering proof; civil laws stand unless punitive.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, §§ 9–10; Calder v. Bull; Stogner; Bouie.- Criminal Scope: Retroactive crimes, harsher penalties, or reviving expired criminal limitations.
- Judicial Rulings: Unforeseeable retroactive judicial expansions violate Due Process notice, not Ex Post Facto.
State A extends expired criminal limitations period to prosecute Speaker. Invalid (Stogner).
- Extending unexpired limitations periods or civil registration is valid.
- Procedural rules leaving elements, defenses, and proof standards intact are valid.
Free Speech
Rule: NextGen unites speech under one heading: content/viewpoint rules get strict scrutiny; content-neutral, conduct, and commercial rules use intermediate tests; nonpublic forums allow reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rules; vague/overbroad or compelled-speech laws fail; prior restraints presumptively fail; unprotected categories receive no protection.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. I; Reed; Austin; Ward; Broadrick; Shuttlesworth; Forsyth; Perry; ISKCON; Matal; O'Brien; Brandenburg; Black; Counterman; Miller; Pope; Stanley; Osborne; Central Hudson; Garcetti; Pickering; Tinker; Fraser; Morse; Hazelwood; Mahanoy; Barnette; Janus; 303 Creative.- Forums, Permits & Overbreadth: Public-forum TPM rules must be content-neutral, narrowly tailored to a significant interest, leaving ample alternative channels (Ward); nonpublic forums (airports, jails) need reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rules; government speech is exempt. Permits require narrow, objective, definite standards—no unbridled discretion (Shuttlesworth) or hostile-crowd heckler's vetoes/fees (Forsyth). Laws cannot be vague or ban substantial protected speech (Broadrick).
- Conduct, Commercial & Unprotected: O'Brien: within power, substantial non-speech interest, no greater burden than essential. Lawful non-misleading commercial speech: substantial interest, direct advancement, reasonable fit not more extensive than necessary (Central Hudson). Incitement: directed to and likely to produce imminent lawless action (Brandenburg); fighting words; threats: serious violent expression (no intent to act) plus recklessness; Miller: community standards (1–2), national standard (3); child pornography.
- Employees, Students & Compelled: Duty speech is unprotected (Garcetti); citizen public-concern speech balances against employer efficiency (Pickering). Schools curb substantial disruption (Tinker), lewdness (Fraser), drug advocacy (Morse), and control curricular speech for legitimate pedagogical concerns (Hazelwood); off-campus speech gets broader protection (Mahanoy). No forced salutes, custom designs, or union fees (Janus).
Oakridge denies permits offending values, adds hostile-crowd fees, and demotes inspector for duty memo. Permits fail; memo is unprotected.
- Home adult obscenity is protected (Stanley); child pornography never is (Osborne).
- Viewpoint discrimination fails; false commercial ads get zero protection.
Freedom of the Press
Rule: Press Clause bars prior restraints absent grave irreparable harm, protects qualified trial access, shields publishing lawfully obtained truthful public-interest facts, and grants no immunity from general laws.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. I; NYT v. United States; Sullivan; St. Amant; Gertz; Dun & Bradstreet; Richmond Newspapers; Florida Star; Branzburg; Cohen.- Defamation: Public officials/figures need clear actual malice (knowing falsity/subjective reckless disregard for truth, not ill will); private plaintiffs on public issues need negligence for actual damages and actual malice for presumed/punitive damages (private-concern: no actual malice).
- General Laws: Reporters obey grand jury subpoenas and neutral contract/tax laws.
Linden Reporter publishes witness name from public police report. Fining paper fails (Florida Star).
- Promissory estoppel for breaking source confidentiality applies to newspapers (Cohen).
- Prior restraints on leaked documents face virtually insurmountable presumption.
Religion Clauses: Free Exercise and Establishment
Rule: Neutral, generally applicable laws get rational basis; laws targeting religion, granting individualized discretionary exemptions, favoring any comparable secular activity, or barring religious actors from neutral grants trigger strict scrutiny. Establishment follows historical practices and coercion (not Lemon); private-choice aid is valid.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. I; Smith; Lukumi; Fulton; Tandon; Carson; Hosanna-Tabor; Ballard; Kennedy; Town of Greece; Engel; Zelman.- Free Exercise: Cannot bar churches from neutral grants by status/use; ministerial exception bars employment suits.
- Establishment: Coercive school prayer fails (Engel); silent coach prayer and vouchers pass (Kennedy; Zelman).
City bars church from neutral grants and fires coach for silent prayer. Exclusion fails; prayer passes.
- State no-aid bans cannot exclude religious groups from neutral grants.
- Courts examine religious sincerity (Ballard), never theological truth.
Contracts Clause and Bills of Attainder
Rule: Contracts Clause bars states from substantially impairing existing private contracts absent significant public purpose on reasonable, appropriate conditions; public contracts require reasonable and necessary means for important purpose. Bills of Attainder bar legislative punishment without trial.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. art. I, §§ 9–10; Energy Reserves; Sveen; U.S. Trust; Lovett.- Contracts: Binds states (not Congress) on existing contracts only.
- Bill of Attainder: Legislative punishment of named or ascertainable persons without trial.
State B diverts pledged bond revenues to roads. Impairing own public contract fails heightened scrutiny.
- Private-contract impairments use "reasonable and appropriate," not "narrowly tailored."
- Corporations may invoke Contracts Clause, unlike Article IV Privileges and Immunities.
Second Amendment
Rule: Second Amendment protects individual right to keep and bear arms at home and in public. When text covers conduct, law must match Nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. II; Heller; McDonald; Bruen; Rahimi.- Analogue: Needs relevantly similar principle (disarming dangerous persons), not a twin.
- No Balancing: Courts reject intermediate or strict scrutiny.
State A requires carry applicants to show "special threat" beyond self-defense. Subjective proper-cause fails.
- Apply plain text and historical tradition, never tiers of scrutiny.
- Objective checks and disarming judicially found dangerous persons remain valid.