1. Jurisdiction and Venue

Federal Question (Subject-Matter Jurisdiction)

Rule: Federal courts hear claims arising under federal law on plaintiff's well-pleaded complaint. A state claim qualifies only if a federal issue is necessarily raised, actually disputed, substantial to the federal system, and resolvable without disrupting the congressionally approved federal-state balance.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. § 1331; Mottley; Holmes Group; Grable; Gunn v. Minton.
Elements
  • Federal law creates the claim, or an embedded federal issue meets all four Grable prongs.
  • Appears on plaintiff's well-pleaded complaint, never an anticipated defense.
Invented Example

Tenant sues Landlord on a Linden lease, pleading Landlord's expected federal defense. Dismissed: defenses never create § 1331 jurisdiction.

Usual Traps
  • Federal counterclaims cannot establish § 1331 jurisdiction.
  • No minimum dollar amount applies.

Diversity and Amount in Controversy

Rule: Diversity requires complete diversity at filing and an amount exceeding $75,000, excluding interest and costs. Individuals take domicile (presence plus intent to remain); corporations take incorporation states and nerve-center headquarters; unincorporated entities take every member's citizenship.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. § 1332(a), (c); Strawbridge; Hertz; Red Cab; Walter; Snyder; Troy Bank.
Elements
  • Good-faith amount controls unless legally certain to fail; $75,000.00 fails.
  • One plaintiff aggregates all claims against one defendant, never against multiple defendants unless jointly liable; multiple plaintiffs cannot aggregate separate claims (only one undivided right).
Invented Example

Buyer (State A) sues Seller Corp. (State B incorporated, State A nerve center) for $75,000.00. Fails on both citizenship and amount.

Usual Traps
  • LLCs and partnerships share every member's citizenship.
  • Post-filing domicile changes never destroy diversity.

Supplemental Jurisdiction

Rule: Claims sharing a common nucleus of operative fact with an anchor claim get supplemental jurisdiction. In diversity-only suits, § 1367(b) bars plaintiff claims against Rule 14, 19, 20, or 24 parties—and claims by Rule 19 plaintiffs or Rule 24 plaintiff-intervenors—if inconsistent with complete diversity or the over-$75,000 threshold.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. § 1367(a)–(c); Gibbs; Allapattah.
Elements
  • Allapattah: under-$75,000 Rule 20 co-plaintiffs ride along if one plaintiff exceeds $75,000; nondiverse/under-$75,000 plaintiff claims against Rule 20/14 parties fail § 1367(b) in diversity.
  • § 1367(c) Discretion: decline for novel state law, predominance, dismissed anchors, or compelling reasons.
Invented Example

Driver (State A) sues Maker Co. (State B) for $90,000, and Passenger (State A) joins for $20,000 from the Oakridge crash. Supplemental jurisdiction covers Passenger.

Usual Traps
  • Co-plaintiffs claiming $50,000 and $40,000 fail because neither exceeds $75,000.
  • Section 1367(b) limits plaintiffs, not defendant impleaders.

Removal and Remand

Rule: Defendants may remove within 30 days of formal service if federal SMJ exists and all served defendants join (barred in diversity if any served defendant is a forum citizen). Non-initially removable cases allow 30 days from an amended paper, capped at 1 year in diversity absent bad faith.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. §§ 1441(a)–(b), 1446(b)–(c), 1447(c); Shamrock Oil; Home Depot; Murphy Bros..
Elements
  • Plaintiffs and third-party counterclaim defendants cannot remove; venue embraces the state court.
  • Non-SMJ remand motions are due within 30 days; SMJ remand applies anytime.
Invented Example

Lender (State A) sues Borrower (State B) in State B court on a $150,000 note. Borrower cannot remove as a forum citizen.

Usual Traps
  • The 1-year diversity cap applies only if not initially removable.
  • Home-state bar never blocks federal-question removal.

Personal Jurisdiction: General, Tag, Consent, and Specific

Rule: General ("all-purpose") jurisdiction attaches where a defendant is at home (domicile; corporate incorporation and principal place of business) or registers under a statute expressly conditioning registration on general consent. Personal jurisdiction also attaches over an individual voluntarily tag-served in-state absent fraud or force, or for the scope of contractual consent or a Rule 12(h)(1) waiver in that suit. Specific jurisdiction requires purposeful availment (or forum-aimed intentional torts), claim relatedness, and fairness (defendant must show a compelling case of unreasonableness).

Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. XIV; Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(k); Daimler; Burnham; Mallory; International Shoe; Burger King; Ford Motor; Asahi; Walden.
Elements
  • Statutory & Specific: Rule 4(k) borrows state long-arms (+100-mile Rule 14/19 bulge); systematic market service meets relatedness; stream-of-commerce splits (awareness vs. targeting).
  • Five Fairness Factors: defendant's burden, forum interest, plaintiff's interest, judicial efficiency, shared social policies.
Invented Example

Oakridge Auto markets sedans in State A; Resident buys a used one in State B and crashes in State A. Specific jurisdiction attaches.

Usual Traps
  • High sales or tagging a traveling officer never create general jurisdiction over a corporation.
  • Harming a resident fails without conduct aimed at the forum state.

Service and Constitutional Notice

Rule: A nonparty adult serves process within 90 days via personal delivery, abode service (suitable resident), agent delivery, or forum- or service-state methods (officer or managing/registered agent for entities); absent good cause (mandatory extension), courts dismiss without prejudice or order service. Due process requires notice reasonably calculated to apprise parties.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 4(c)–(e), (h), (m), 12(a); U.S. Const. amends. V, XIV; Mullane.
Elements
  • Waiver gives 60 days to answer from request sent (90 abroad).
  • Publication fails if addresses are known or reasonably ascertainable.
Invented Example

Server leaves summons with Defendant's live-in 16-year-old sibling in Linden. Valid abode service.

Usual Traps
  • A plaintiff cannot personally serve process.
  • Waiving service preserves PJ and venue objections.

Venue, Transfer, Forum Clauses, and FNC

Rule: Original venue lies where any defendant resides if all reside in one state (individuals: domicile; entities: wherever subject to PJ), where substantial events or property lie, or—as a fallback—where any defendant is subject to PJ. When venue and PJ are proper, § 1404(a) transfers for convenience to a district where it might have been brought or all parties consent (transferor law absent forum clause); if venue is improper or PJ is lacking, courts dismiss or transfer under § 1406(a)/§ 1631 where it could have been brought (transferee law).

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391, 1404(a), 1406(a), 1631; Goldlawr; Van Dusen; Ferens; Atlantic Marine; Piper Aircraft.
Elements
  • FNC & Forum Clauses: general FNC requires an adequate alternative forum (unfavorable law alone does not defeat it) plus private/public balancing (less deference to foreign plaintiffs); federal clauses use § 1404(a) (transferee law), state/foreign clauses use FNC (no weight to plaintiff's choice or private factors).
  • Removal & Aliens: removal venue uses § 1441(a); nonresident aliens sued anywhere.
Invented Example

Ignoring a State B federal forum clause, Supplier sues in State A. Transferred under § 1404(a); State B law governs.

Usual Traps
  • Never use Rule 12(b)(3) or § 1406(a) for a forum clause when statutory venue is proper.
  • Never use forum non conveniens between federal districts.
↑ Back to Contents

2. State Law in Federal Court

Erie Doctrine and Klaxon

Rule: Diversity and supplemental courts apply state substantive law and federal procedure. A colliding Federal Rule valid under § 2072 governs; else state law applies if outcome-determinative under Erie's twin aims, absent strong federal interests. Forum conflict rules govern.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. §§ 1652, 2072; Erie; Hanna; York; Byrd; Shady Grove; Klaxon.
Elements
  • Hanna/Erie: valid colliding Rule wins (Shady Grove split); else weigh forum shopping and inequity against federal interests.
  • Klaxon: apply forum conflict rules (unless § 1404(a) transferred without a forum clause).
Invented Example

State A mandates personal service for estates; Rule 4(e)(2)(B) allows abode service. Valid under § 2072, Rule 4 governs.

Usual Traps
  • Limitations, tolling, burdens of proof, and damages caps are substantive.
  • Rule 3 never tolls state statutes of limitations in diversity.

Federal Common Law Legacy exam only (through February 2028)

Rule: Absent general federal common law, courts craft specialized federal common law for federal commercial paper, obligations, interstate disputes, and admiralty.

Source (unverified): Erie; Clearfield Trust Co. v. United States.
Elements
  • Requires uniquely federal interests or statutory authorization, never private diversity disputes.
  • Courts may borrow state law as the federal rule absent uniformity needs.
Invented Example

Dispute over a forged endorsement on a U.S. Treasury check in Oakridge. Federal common law governs.

Usual Traps
  • Clearfield Trust does not cover private contracts lacking federal duties.
↑ Back to Contents

3. Pretrial Procedures

Preliminary Injunctions and TROs

Rule: Preliminary injunctions require notice and four factors (merits likelihood, irreparable harm, equities, public interest). Ex parte TROs require sworn facts showing immediate irreparable injury before opposition and written certification of notice efforts, expiring in 14 days.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 65(a)–(c); Winter v. NRDC; Sampson v. Murray.
Elements
  • Preliminary Injunction: notice, Winter factors, appealable under § 1292(a)(1).
  • Ex Parte TRO: sworn facts + notice-effort certification; max 14 days (+14 days for good cause, or longer with adverse-party consent); bond required.
Invented Example

Builder seeks an ex parte TRO in Linden without certifying notice efforts. Denied.

Usual Traps
  • Ordinary TROs are unappealable under § 1292(a)(1) unless extended past 28 days without consent.

Pleadings: Plausibility and Rule 9(b)

Rule: Rule 8(a) requires jurisdictional grounds, a short, plain statement showing plausible entitlement to relief, and a demand. Rule 9(b) requires particularity for fraud or mistake (intent alleged generally).

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(a), 9(b); Twombly; Iqbal.
Elements
  • Strip legal conclusions; test remaining facts for plausibility.
  • Fraud/mistake: plead who, what, when, where, and how.
Invented Example

Investor sues Broker in Linden alleging only "fraudulent inducement." Fails Rules 8(a) and 9(b).

Usual Traps
  • Judges never weigh credibility on Rule 12(b)(6).
  • Rule 9(b) excludes negligence and civil rights.

Amendments, Relation Back, and Rule 11

Rule: Amend once as of right within 21 days of serving—or, if responsive pleading is required, 21 days after answer or Rule 12(b)/(e)/(f) motion, whichever is earlier—else by consent or leave freely given. Rule 11 certifies proper purpose, warranted law, and evidentiary support (21-day safe harbor).

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 11(a)–(d), 15(a), 15(c)(1); Foman; Krupski.
Elements
  • Relation Back (15(c)): same transaction for claims; for new parties, 15(c)(1)(A) limitations law or within 90 days of filing (+extensions), notice without defense prejudice + knowledge of identity mistake.
  • Rule 11 Limits: 11(d) excludes Rules 26–37 disclosures, requests, responses, objections, and motions; 11(c)(5) bars monetary sanctions on represented clients for legal errors or sua sponte post-dismissal/settlement without prior show-cause.
Invented Example

Worker sues "Oakridge Supply Inc.," serving counsel knowing "Oakridge Logistics LLC" runs the site. Relates back.

Usual Traps
  • A Rule 12(b) motion starts the 21-day clock; a later answer never reopens it.
  • Krupski checks defendant's knowledge, not plaintiff's diligence.

Joinder of Claims and Parties (Rules 13, 14, 18–20)

Rule: Rule 18(a) joins any claims against an opponent; same-transaction counterclaims are compulsory (§ 1367(a) SMJ; barred if omitted from an answer unless pending elsewhere or lacking PJ), while unrelated counterclaims (needing independent SMJ) and same-transaction co-party crossclaims are permissive. Rule 20 joins parties sharing a transaction and common question; Rule 19 joins required absentees if feasible or weighs dismissing the action; Rule 14(a) lets defendants implead derivatively liable nonparties within 14 days of answering.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 13, 14(a), 18(a), 19, 20; 28 U.S.C. § 1367; Temple.
Elements
  • Rule 19 & Impleader: absentee is required (19(a)) for complete relief, impaired interest, or double/inconsistent obligations (never joint tortfeasors); if infeasible, 19(b) weighs prejudice, shaping relief, judgment adequacy, and alternative forum. Rule 14(a) gets § 1367(a) SMJ and 100-mile bulge.
  • § 1367(b): in diversity, plaintiff's direct claim against a Rule 14(a) party needs complete diversity and over $75,000.
Invented Example

Owner (State A) sues Contractor (State B) for $120,000. Contractor impleads Subcontractor (State B); Owner cannot sue Subcontractor directly.

Usual Traps
  • Winning Rule 12(b)(6) dismissal without answering preserves compulsory counterclaims; crossclaims are never compulsory.
  • Rule 14(a) requires derivative liability, not sole nonparty fault.

Intervention, Interpleader, and Class Actions

Rule: Nonparties intervene of right under Rule 24(a) (impaired, inadequately represented interest) or permissively under Rule 24(b) (common question). Stakeholders use Rule 22 (§ 1331 or complete diversity + >$75,000) or § 1335 interpleader (minimal claimant diversity, $500+, claimant venue § 1397, nationwide service § 2361). Classes need Rule 23(a) (numerosity, commonality, typicality, adequacy) plus Rule 23(b)(1) (inconsistent standards/nonparty impairment), (b)(2) (indivisible injunctive/declaratory relief), or (b)(3) (predominance and superiority).

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 22–24; 28 U.S.C. §§ 1332(d), 1335, 1367(b), 1397, 2361; Tashire; Dukes; Ben-Hur.
Elements
  • Class SMJ & Notice: traditional diversity checks named representatives (one >$75,000); CAFA needs 100+ members, minimal diversity, >$5M; Rule 23(b)(3) mandates individual notice and opt-out.
  • Intervention: § 1367(b) bars nondiverse Rule 24 plaintiff-intervenors in diversity.
Invented Example

Insurer (State A) deposits $10,000 claimed by Creditor 1 (State A) and Creditor 2 (State B). Statutory § 1335 interpleader succeeds.

Usual Traps
  • Rule 23(b)(1)–(2) classes have no opt-out; settlements require court approval.
  • Rule 22 tests stakeholder vs. claimants (or § 1331); § 1335 tests claimant vs. claimant.

Discovery Scope, Disclosures, and Devices

Rule: After Rule 26(f), parties disclose supporting witnesses and documents/ESI (unless solely for impeachment), damages computations, and liability insurance. Rule 26(b)(1) allows nonprivileged, relevant, proportional discovery (even inadmissible) via depositions (10, 7h), interrogatories (25, parties only), production, Rule 35 exams (order for good cause + in controversy), and party admissions.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(1), (3), (b)(1), (f), 30, 33–36, 45; Schlagenhauf.
Elements
  • Disclosures: initial and pretrial disclosures exclude sole-impeachment material; insurance remains mandatory.
  • Nonparties: depositions (Rule 30) and production/inspection (Rule 34(c)) need a Rule 45 subpoena; Rules 33 and 36 bind only parties.
Invented Example

In a $25,000 Oakridge crash, Plaintiff seeks archives costing $400,000 to pull. Denied as disproportional.

Usual Traps
  • Inadmissible hearsay is discoverable if relevant, nonprivileged, and proportional.
  • Rule 36 admissions bind only in the pending action.

Privilege, Work Product, Experts, and ESI Sanctions

Rule: Privileged items are shielded unless waived; withheld privileged/work-product items must be expressly claimed and logged. Ordinary work product needs substantial need and undue hardship; opinion work product is virtually inviolable; anyone gets their prior statement on request. Retained testifying experts give reports and depositions; consulting experts need exceptional circumstances. Severe Rule 37(e) sanctions require intent to deprive.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(2), (b)(3)–(5), 37(e); Fed. R. Evid. 502; Hickman.
Elements
  • Experts: draft reports and counsel communications shielded except compensation, supplied facts/data, and relied-on assumptions; 26(b)(3)(C) grants own prior statements.
  • Rule 37(e) ESI: negligent loss brings curative steps; adverse inference or dismissal requires intent to deprive.
Invented Example

Seller's auto-purge negligently deletes Linden logs without bad faith. Curative steps apply, not an adverse inference.

Usual Traps
  • Inadvertent federal disclosure avoids waiver if reasonably prevented and promptly rectified.
  • Routine business records are never work product.

Pretrial Conferences and Orders Legacy exam only (through February 2028)

Rule: Scheduling orders modify only for good cause and judge's consent; the final pretrial order supersedes pleadings unless modified to prevent manifest injustice.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(b), (d)–(f).
Elements
  • Scheduling Order (16(b)): sets joinder, amendment, motion, and discovery deadlines.
  • Final Pretrial Order (16(e)): stricter manifest-injustice standard.
Invented Example

Final pretrial order omits punitive damages in Linden; Plaintiff moves at trial to add them. Denied.

Usual Traps
  • Rule 16(b) requires good cause; Rule 16(e) requires manifest injustice.
↑ Back to Contents

4. Preserving the Right to a Jury Trial

Seventh Amendment and Jury Demand

Rule: The Seventh Amendment preserves jury trials for legal claims (damages), not equitable remedies. Written demand is due within 14 days after the last directed pleading; overlapping legal claims try before equitable claims.

Source (unverified): U.S. Const. amend. VII; Fed. R. Civ. P. 38(b), (d); Beacon Theatres; Dairy Queen.
Elements
  • Demand: due within 14 days of last directed pleading or waived.
  • Mixed Claims: jury tries legal claims first, binding the judge's equitable rulings.
Invented Example

Builder seeks damages and an injunction in Oakridge, demanding a jury 10 days after Contractor's answer. Damages are tried first.

Usual Traps
  • New legal theories without new factual issues never revive a waived 14-day demand.
  • Purely equitable claims carry no jury right.

Jury Selection and Instructions Legacy exam only (through February 2028)

Rule: Federal civil juries seat 6–12 jurors and return unanimous verdicts absent stipulation. Each side gets unlimited for-cause challenges and 3 peremptories (no race or sex strikes). Rule 51 requires on-record instruction objections before instructions and deliberations to preserve appeal absent plain error.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 47, 48, 51; 28 U.S.C. § 1870; Edmonson.
Elements
  • Selection: 6–12 jurors; Batson/Edmonson bars race/sex peremptories.
  • Instructions (Rule 51): unpreserved errors get only plain-error review.
Invented Example

Counsel stays silent on a faulty Linden jury instruction, objecting after the verdict. Waived absent plain error.

Usual Traps
  • Civil litigants cannot exercise race- or sex-based peremptories.
↑ Back to Contents

5. Dispositive Motions

Rule 12 Motions, Waiver, Rule 12(c), and Dismissal

Rule: Answer within 21 days of service (14 after Rule 12 denial), pleading Rule 8(c) affirmative defenses (limitations, preclusion, release) or forfeiting them. Rule 12(b)(2)–(5) waive permanently if omitted from the first Rule 12 motion—or, if none, from the answer and Rule 15(a)(1) amendment as of right. Rule 12(c) permits judgment after pleadings close. Under Rule 41, one unilateral dismissal before answer/SJ is without prejudice (a second federal notice after a prior dismissal is on the merits); Rule 41(b) involuntary dismissal is on the merits except jurisdiction, venue, or Rule 19.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 8(b)–(c), 12(a)–(d), 12(g)–(h), 15(a)(1), 41(a)–(b).
Elements
  • 12(b)(6)–(7), 12(c), 12(b)(1): 12(b)(6)–(7) survive through trial (forfeited on appeal); 12(c) converts to Rule 56 with outside matters (12(d)); 12(b)(1) SMJ never waives.
  • Two-Dismissal Rule: after a prior voluntary dismissal (state or federal), a second unilateral federal notice dismissal bars refiling; stipulated dismissals avoid it unless with prejudice.
Invented Example

Contractor files a Rule 12(b)(6) motion alone, loses, and pleads Rule 12(b)(2) in its answer. Personal jurisdiction is waived.

Usual Traps
  • Absent a prior Rule 12 motion, omitting 12(b)(2)–(5) is curable via 21-day Rule 15(a)(1) amendment.
  • Unanswered non-damages allegations count as admissions.

Summary Judgment

Rule: Summary judgment issues when the movant shows no genuine dispute of material fact and entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, viewing evidence favorably to the nonmovant.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 56(a), (c); Celotex; Anderson.
Elements
  • Movant Burden: negate an element or show an absence of supporting evidence.
  • Nonmovant Duty: cite specific record materials (affidavits, depositions, documents), not bare pleadings.
Invented Example

Contractor submits sworn Oakridge inspection logs; Owner relies solely on unverified complaint allegations. Summary judgment granted.

Usual Traps
  • Judges never weigh credibility on summary judgment.
  • Summary judgment denials are generally unappealable until final judgment.

JMOL and New Trial

Rule: Rule 50(a) JMOL applies after a party is fully heard if no reasonable jury could find for it. Rule 50(b) renewed JMOL (due within 28 days) requires a pre-submission Rule 50(a) motion. Rule 59 permits a new trial within 28 days for error, misconduct, new evidence, or verdict against the great weight of evidence.

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 50(a)–(b), 59(a)–(b); Dimick v. Schiedt; Hetzel.
Elements
  • Rule 50(b): due within 28 days; requires prior Rule 50(a) motion.
  • Rule 59 (28 days): judge may weigh evidence for new trial or offer remittitur (never additur).
Invented Example

Defendant skips JMOL at trial in Linden, loses, and moves under Rule 50(b) 10 days later. Denied for lacking a Rule 50(a) motion.

Usual Traps
  • The 28-day deadline for Rules 50(b) and 59 cannot be extended.
  • Federal judges may offer remittitur conditioned on choosing a new trial (never unilaterally order reduced damages or additur).
↑ Back to Contents

6. Judgments

Default and Rule 60(b) Relief

Rule: Clerk enters default for failure to plead/defend, and default judgment only for a sum certain against a non-minor, non-incompetent unappeared party (else judge, with 7-day notice if appeared). Rule 55(c) sets aside default entry for good cause; default judgment requires Rule 60(b).

Source (unverified): Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(c), 55(a)–(c), 60(b)–(c); Coney Island Auto Parts.
Elements
  • Rule 54(c) & 60(b)(1)–(3): default judgment cannot exceed/differ from pleadings; mistake, excusable neglect, new evidence, or fraud due within reasonable time (max 1 year).
  • Rule 60(b)(4)–(6) (No 1-Year Cap): (4) void judgment, (5) satisfied/reversed/inequitable judgment, (6) extraordinary reasons—all due within a reasonable time.
Invented Example

Two years after a default judgment lacking PJ in Linden, Defendant learns of it and promptly moves under Rule 60(b)(4). Granted as void: no 1-year cap, timely under Rule 60(c)(1).

Usual Traps
  • Clerk cannot enter default judgment if damages are uncertain or defendant appeared.
  • The 1-year cap applies only to Rule 60(b)(1)–(3), but Rule 60(b)(4) void-judgment motions still require a reasonable time.

Effect of a Judgment: Preclusion

Rule: Claim preclusion bars same-party (or privy) relitigation of same-transaction claims (minority: primary rights) after a valid final merits judgment. Issue preclusion bars an identical issue actually litigated, determined, and essential to a valid final judgment against a party with full litigation opportunity.

Source (unverified): Restatement (Second) of Judgments §§ 17–24, 27–29; 28 U.S.C. § 1738; Migra; Semtek; Parklane Hosiery; Taylor.
Elements
  • Governing Law: state judgment uses rendering state law (§ 1738); federal-question uses federal common law; diversity uses federal common law borrowing forum law unless incompatible with federal interests (Semtek).
  • Nonmutual Preclusion: defensive generally allowed; offensive weighs four Parklane factors (wait-and-see, prior incentive, inconsistent judgments, unavailable procedural opportunities).
Invented Example

Passenger 1 proves Bus Co.'s driver ran an Oakridge red light. Passenger 2, who waited out suit one, may be denied offensive preclusion.

Usual Traps
  • Jurisdiction, venue, and Rule 19 dismissals are not on the merits.
  • Preclusion never binds nonparties lacking privity under Taylor.
↑ Back to Contents

7. Appealability and Review

Appeals, Interlocutory Review, and Standards

Rule: Appeals lie from final judgments disposing of all claims/parties (30-day notice, tolled by timely Rule 50(b), 52(b), 59, or 28-day Rule 60 motions), subject to Rule 54(b), injunctions (§ 1292(a)(1)), § 1292(b) certification, Rule 23(f) (14 days), and the collateral order doctrine.

Source (unverified): 28 U.S.C. §§ 1291, 1292; Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(f), 52(a)(6), 54(b); Fed. R. App. P. 4(a); Cohen; Pullman-Standard.
Elements
  • Interlocutory: Rule 54(b) (expressly no just reason for delay); § 1292(a)(1) (injunctions, not TROs); § 1292(b) (district judge certifies controlling law question with substantial difference of opinion materially advancing termination + appellate permission within 10 days); Cohen collateral order (conclusively determines important merits-separate issue effectively unreviewable after final judgment, e.g., immunity denial).
  • Standards: de novo (law), clear error (bench), substantial evidence (jury), abuse of discretion (discovery, evidence, new trial).
Invented Example

Judge denies summary judgment on the merits and a motion to compel. Neither order is appealable under § 1291.

Usual Traps
  • Ordinary TROs are unappealable under § 1292(a)(1), unlike preliminary injunctions.
  • Rule 23(f) petitions allow 14 days and § 1292(b) applications allow 10 days.
↑ Back to Contents

More memory hooks

↑ Back to Contents