Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

In 2010, Grantor, a resident of Maplewood, executed and delivered an irrevocable inter vivos trust transferring Maplewood Farm and $300,000 in cash to Trustee "in trust to pay the net income to Child for life, and upon Child's death, to distribute the principal to Child's children who reach age 25, and if none of Child's children reach age 25, then to Sibling; provided, however, that Child shall have a testamentary power to appoint the trust principal among any persons Child selects, including Child's estate or creditors, by explicit reference to this power in Child's will."

At the creation of the trust in 2010, Grantor, Child, Sibling, and Child's first child, Grandchild-1 (then age 11), were all alive. In 2012, Child had a second child, Grandchild-2. In 2024, while Child was still alive, Trustee invested $200,000 of the trust's $300,000 cash reserve in a speculative, closely held software startup owned entirely by Trustee's spouse, without informing or obtaining consent from any beneficiary. Six months later, the startup failed, losing $100,000 of the invested trust funds.

In 2025, Child died leaving a valid will whose residuary clause stated simply: "I give all the residue of my property, real and personal, to Friend." The will did not mention the Maplewood Family Trust or Child's power of appointment. At Child's death in 2025, Grandchild-1 was age 26, Grandchild-2 was age 13, and Grantor and Sibling were both still living.

Call of the Question

Under general United States property and trust law (addressing both common-law and modern statutory rules), determine: (1) the interests created by the 2010 trust and whether Child's will exercised the power of appointment in favor of Friend; (2) the validity of the remainder interests under the Rule Against Perpetuities and the effect of class-closing rules; and (3) whether Trustee breached any fiduciary duties and what remedies are available.