Fact Pattern
Testator, an unmarried resident of the town of Linden, validly executed a typewritten, attested will ("the Will") in 2020 before two disinterested witnesses. The Will provided:
(1) "I give $50,000 to my sister, Sister."
(2) "I devise my Linden house, Oakhouse, to my brother, Brother."
(3) "I give the residue of my estate to my close friend, Friend."
In 2022, Sister died, survived by her only child, Niece. In 2023, Testator adopted a child, Daughter. Testator had no other children, never executed a new will or codicil, and made no nonprobate provisions for Daughter.
In 2024, thinking that Brother already owned a large home and wanting Niece to have a house instead, Testator took out the original Will, drew a dark ink line through the words "to my brother, Brother" in Clause (2), and wrote in the margin next to Clause (2) in Testator's own handwriting: "to my niece, Niece." Testator did not sign or initial the alteration, and no witnesses were present. Testator later told a neighbor, "I fixed my will so Niece gets Oakhouse instead of Brother."
Testator died in 2025, survived by Brother, Niece, Daughter, and Friend. Testator's net probate estate consists of Oakhouse and $250,000 in cash. The local intestacy statute gives 100% of an unmarried decedent's estate to the decedent's surviving issue.
Call of the Question
Under general United States probate law (noting majority/Uniform Probate Code and traditional splits where relevant), how should Testator's probate estate be distributed among Daughter, Niece, Brother, and Friend?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Daughter's Claim as a Pretermitted (Omitted) Child
Issue: What share of Testator's estate is Daughter entitled to take as a child adopted after the Will was executed?
Rule: Under Revised Uniform Probate Code § 2-302, an omitted child born to or adopted by the testator after the will's execution has the same rights as a biological child, with recovery turning on whether the testator had living children at execution: (1) if the testator had no child living when executing the will (§ 2-302(a)(1)), the omitted child takes an intestate share unless the testator devised all or substantially all of the estate to the omitted child's other parent who survives and takes under the will; (2) if the testator had one or more children living when executing the will (§ 2-302(a)(2)), the omitted child takes nothing if no devises were made to the then-living children (§ 2-302(a)(2)(i)), and otherwise takes an equal (1/N) share of the aggregate value devised to the then-living children (§ 2-302(a)(2)(ii)), funded by pro-rata abatement of those children's devises (§ 2-302(a)(2)(iv)). In either case (§ 2-302(b)), the child takes nothing if it appears from the will that the omission was intentional or if the testator provided for the child by transfers outside the will intended in lieu of a testamentary provision. In addition, under the doctrine of republication by codicil (Restatement (Third) of Property § 3.4), a valid post-adoption codicil (including an alteration validated under UPC § 2-503 "as if it had been executed in compliance with" formal execution rules) re-dates the will to the codicil's date: strict jurisdictions (Azcunce v. Estate of Azcunce) hold that republication disqualifies the child from claiming as adopted "after execution of the will" under § 2-302(a), whereas Restatement (Third) of Property §§ 3.4 cmt. e and 9.6 cmt. d decline to apply republication mechanically to defeat an omitted-child statute absent evidence of intent to exclude.
Application: Testator executed the Will in 2020 and validly adopted Daughter in 2023 without executing a new will. Because Testator had no children living in 2020, § 2-302(a)(1) applies rather than § 2-302(a)(2). None of the statutory bars apply on the 2020 Will alone: the Will mentions no future or omitted children (§ 2-302(b)(1)), Testator left nothing to a spouse or other parent of Daughter (§ 2-302(a)(1)), and Testator made no nonprobate transfers for Daughter (§ 2-302(b)(2)). However, if a court validates Testator's 2024 marginal pen alteration as a codicil under UPC § 2-503 harmless error (analyzed in Issue 2), republication by codicil would re-date the 2020 Will to 2024—after Daughter's 2023 adoption: in a strict Azcunce jurisdiction, validating the 2024 alteration under § 2-503 would defeat Daughter's omitted-child claim altogether, whereas under Restatement §§ 3.4 cmt. e and 9.6 cmt. d Daughter retains her § 2-302(a)(1) share because Testator merely changed Clause (2) from Brother to Niece without manifesting intent to disinherit Daughter. Absent mechanical republication (or if § 2-503 does not validate the 2024 note), Daughter takes an intestate share equal to 100% of the unmarried decedent's probate estate, absorbing the estate before Clauses (1)–(3) operate; nevertheless, analyzing Clauses (1)–(3) remains essential both in case a jurisdiction applies strict republication under § 2-503 and in case a narrower state pretermitted-child cap applies.
Conclusion: Unless § 2-503 validates the 2024 alteration in a strict mechanical-republication jurisdiction (Azcunce), Daughter takes 100% of Testator's probate estate as an omitted after-adopted child under UPC § 2-302(a)(1) (making analysis of Clauses (1)–(3) essential under both the republication split and alternative distribution analysis).
2. Clause (2): Partial Revocation by Physical Act and Unexecuted Interlineation
Issue: Did Testator's crossing out "to my brother, Brother" and writing "to my niece, Niece" validly revoke Brother's devise of Oakhouse and create a new devise to Niece?
Rule: A testator may revoke a will by physical act (burning, tearing, canceling, or obliterating) with concurrent revocatory intent. Under the UPC and majority rule, a testator may partially revoke a specific clause by physical act, whereas a minority of states forbid partial revocation by physical act and require a subsequent attested instrument. However, no jurisdiction allows a testator to add a new beneficiary or increase a gift through an unexecuted interlineation unless the addition independently satisfies will-execution formalities (such as a signed holographic codicil or, under UPC § 2-503, the harmless-error dispensing power backed by clear and convincing evidence).
Application: Testator intentionally lined through "to my brother, Brother" on the original Will with intent to revoke Brother's devise. In a minority state prohibiting partial revocation by physical act, the crossing-out is ineffective and Brother's devise remains intact. In a majority/UPC state recognizing partial physical revocation, the cancellation revokes Brother's devise unless saved by DRR (analyzed below). As to the handwritten words "to my niece, Niece," no witnesses attested the alteration, and Testator did not sign or initial the margin. Even in states recognizing holographic wills, an unsigned handwritten alteration fails formal holographic execution because a signature is required. Only in a jurisdiction adopting the UPC § 2-503 harmless-error rule could Niece argue—relying on Testator's handwriting and statement to the neighbor—that clear and convincing evidence proves Testator intended the marginal note as a codicil; however, as noted in Issue 1, validating the 2024 alteration as a codicil under § 2-503 also triggers republication of the 2020 Will as of 2024 (after Daughter's 2023 adoption), which in a strict Azcunce jurisdiction would defeat Daughter's omitted-child share whereas Restatement §§ 3.4 cmt. e and 9.6 cmt. d protect Daughter. Absent harmless error, the substitution to Niece fails.
Conclusion: The unexecuted marginal addition to Niece is invalid under traditional and holographic rules (unless rescued under UPC § 2-503 harmless error), and Brother's devise is revoked in majority/UPC states subject to Dependent Relative Revocation.
3. Clause (2): Dependent Relative Revocation (DRR)
Issue: Assuming partial physical revocation is recognized and the gift to Niece fails, does Dependent Relative Revocation (DRR) undo Testator's cancellation of Brother's devise?
Rule: Under DRR, a court disregards a revocation when the testator revoked a will or provision under a mistaken belief of law or fact—most commonly believing that a new, invalid substitute disposition was legally effective—and the testator would have preferred the prior revoked gift over the alternative outcome (typically intestacy or falling into the residue). Courts compare the revoked gift to the default fallback to decide whether the testator would have wanted the prior gift restored.
Application: Testator crossed out Brother's name solely because Testator wanted Oakhouse to go to Niece instead and mistakenly believed the unsigned marginal note accomplished that transfer. If the revocation stands without Niece's gift taking effect, Oakhouse falls into the residue and passes to Friend (a non-relative). However, Testator's reason for striking Brother's name was not animus toward Brother, but an assumption that Brother already owned a home and Niece would receive Oakhouse; alternatively, Brother can argue Testator intended Oakhouse to go to a family member (Brother) rather than Friend, whereas Friend will argue Testator deliberately chose to take Oakhouse away from Brother regardless. Most courts apply DRR when a testator substitutes one beneficiary for another by an invalid interlineation if giving the property back to the original family devisee aligns more closely with testator's intent than letting it fall into a stranger's residue—though courts sometimes refuse DRR where the testator's stated reason shows an independent wish to disinherit the prior taker.
Conclusion: Unless Daughter's omitted-child share takes the entire estate, a court will likely apply DRR to cancel the revocation of Clause (2) so Brother takes Oakhouse rather than letting it fall into Friend's residue (though if the court finds Testator wanted Brother excluded in all events, Oakhouse falls into the residue).
4. Clause (1): Lapse and Anti-Lapse Statute for Sister's $50,000 Gift
Issue: Does the $50,000 devise to Sister lapse into Friend's residue because Sister predeceased Testator, or does Niece take it under an anti-lapse statute?
Rule: Under common law, a devise to a beneficiary who predeceases the testator lapses and passes into the residuary clause (or intestacy if the gift is itself residuary). Nearly all states modify this rule with anti-lapse statutes, which substitute the predeceased beneficiary's surviving issue if (1) the predeceased beneficiary bears a specified statutory kinship to the testator (under UPC § 2-603(b), a grandparent, descendant of a grandparent, or stepchild—which includes siblings), (2) the predeceased beneficiary leaves surviving descendants, and (3) the will expresses no contrary intent (such as an alternate gift-over or, under the majority rule, an express condition of survival—whereas under the UPC § 2-603(b)(3) minority rule, mere words of survivorship do not by themselves defeat anti-lapse).
Application: Sister died in 2022, three years before Testator. As Testator's sibling (a descendant of Testator's parents/grandparents), Sister falls squarely within the protected class of every standard anti-lapse statute. Sister left one surviving descendant, Niece, and Clause (1) contains no survivorship condition ("if she survives me") and no alternative gift-over. Therefore, absent Daughter's pretermitted-child share consuming the estate, the anti-lapse statute prevents lapse and substitutes Niece into Sister's place.
Conclusion: Apart from Daughter's overriding omitted-child share, Clause (1) does not lapse; the anti-lapse statute awards the $50,000 gift to Niece rather than Friend.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Pretermitted (After-Adopted) Child (5 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies Daughter as an after-adopted child treated identically to a biological child under intestacy and pretermitted-heir rules.
- 1 pt States Revised UPC § 2-302(a)(1) (no living child at execution yields an intestate share unless substantially all went to the surviving other parent, contrasting § 2-302(a)(2)).
- 1 pt Evaluates and rejects all statutory bars (no intentional omission on will's face, no gift to a surviving other parent, no nonprobate provision in lieu of a will gift).
- 1 pt Calculates Daughter's intestate share as 100% of the unmarried decedent's probate estate and analyzes whether validating the 2024 alteration under § 2-503 republishes the Will after the 2023 adoption (Azcunce strict bar vs. Restatement §§ 3.4 cmt. e, 9.6 cmt. d).
- 1 pt Explains why complete exam analysis still requires addressing Clauses (1)–(3) (both if strict republication bars Daughter and as alternative distribution).
Issue 2: Partial Physical Revocation & Unexecuted Interlineation (6 Points)
- 1 pt States the rule for revocation by physical act (cancellation plus concurrent revocatory intent).
- 1 pt Notes the majority/UPC vs. minority split on whether partial revocation by physical act is valid.
- 1 pt Explains why the marginal addition "to my niece, Niece" fails as an attested codicil (no witnesses, no signature).
- 1 pt Explains why the marginal note fails as a holographic codicil (even where holographs are allowed, Testator did not sign or initial it).
- 1 pt Notes the UPC § 2-503 harmless-error (dispensing power) argument using Testator's handwriting and oral statement, plus its republication interaction with Issue 1.
- 1 pt Concludes the new gift to Niece fails under standard rules (subject to harmless error).
Issue 3: Dependent Relative Revocation (DRR) (5 Points)
- 1 pt States the DRR doctrine (revocation disregarded when based on mistake of law/fact regarding a failed substitute disposition).
- 1 pt Identifies Testator's mistake (believing the unsigned interlineation validly transferred Oakhouse to Niece).
- 1 pt Compares the two outcomes if DRR is not applied (Oakhouse falls into Friend's residue) vs. if DRR applies (Brother keeps Oakhouse).
- 1 pt Weighs Testator's stated reason ("Brother already owned a large home") against keeping Oakhouse in the family rather than Friend's residue.
- 1 pt Reaches a reasoned conclusion on whether DRR restores Brother's devise of Oakhouse.
Issue 4: Lapse and Anti-Lapse Statute (4 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies the lapse issue because Sister predeceased Testator in 2022.
- 1 pt States the anti-lapse elements (protected kinship + surviving issue + no contrary will intent).
- 1 pt Applies both kinship (sister is a grandparent's descendant) and issue (Niece survived Testator) with no survival condition.
- 1 pt Concludes Niece takes the $50,000 under Clause (1) rather than letting it lapse into Friend's residue (subject to Daughter's share).