Fact Pattern
Owner owns a house in the town of Linden. While planning a two-week trip out of town, Owner hired Builder, an independent excavation contractor who operates a separate business with Builder's own crew and equipment, to replace a leaking water pipe running under Owner's front lawn. Owner gave Builder full control over how and when to perform the work and had no reason to doubt Builder's competence.
A Linden municipal ordinance provides: "Any person excavating within five feet of a public sidewalk shall enclose the excavation with a four-foot-high solid barrier and place illuminated warning lights around the perimeter from dusk until dawn to prevent pedestrians from falling into open trenches."
On Tuesday afternoon, Builder dug a six-foot-deep trench three feet from the edge of the public sidewalk. At 5:00 p.m., Builder stopped for the day. Rather than erecting a four-foot barrier or setting out warning lights, Builder placed a single small orange plastic cone at the far end of the trench and left.
At 9:00 p.m., after dark and during a steady rain, Walker was walking along the public sidewalk past Owner's property. While glancing down for a moment at a paper street map, Walker inadvertently stepped off the edge of the sidewalk onto the unfenced grass border of Owner's lawn and fell into the open trench, breaking a leg.
A neighbor heard Walker call for help and summoned an ambulance. On the way to the hospital, the ambulance driver failed to notice a stop sign in the heavy rain and collided with a parked delivery van. The impact threw Walker against the side of the ambulance, fracturing Walker's collarbone.
Call of the Question
Under general United States tort law, what claims may Walker reasonably assert against Builder and Owner, what defenses may Builder and Owner raise, and what are the likely outcomes?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Walker's Negligence Claim Against Builder
Issue: Did Builder owe Walker a duty of care despite Walker's technical trespass onto Owner's lawn, and did Builder breach that duty under negligence per se or ordinary negligence?
Rule: A prima facie negligence claim requires duty, breach, causation, and damages. A defendant owes a duty of reasonable care to foreseeable plaintiffs within the zone of danger. Ordinarily, a person who steps onto private land without permission is an undiscovered trespasser owed no duty regarding land conditions (a defense shared by contractors performing work on the land for the possessor). However, under the traveler-deviation doctrine, a land possessor or contractor who creates or maintains an excavation or artificial condition so close to a public sidewalk that it poses an unreasonable risk to travelers who foreseeably and inadvertently deviate a short distance from the public way as an incident of travel owes a duty of reasonable care despite the technical trespass. Under the majority rule of negligence per se, an unexcused violation of a safety statute or ordinance establishes duty and breach as a matter of law if (1) the plaintiff is a member of the class the enactment was designed to protect, and (2) the harm suffered is the type of harm the enactment was intended to prevent. (A minority of jurisdictions treat an ordinance violation as a rebuttable presumption or mere evidence of negligence.)
Application: Builder may argue as a threshold defense that Walker became an undiscovered trespasser by stepping off the sidewalk onto Owner's private lawn. That defense fails under the traveler-deviation rule: Builder dug a six-foot trench only three feet from the public sidewalk, and it is entirely foreseeable that a nighttime pedestrian glancing at a map would inadvertently stray three feet onto an unfenced lawn edge as an ordinary incident of travel. Walker is therefore a foreseeable plaintiff owed a duty of reasonable care. Moreover, the Linden ordinance explicitly protects pedestrians from falling into open excavations near public sidewalks. Walker was a pedestrian who fell into an open trench three feet from the sidewalk after dusk, suffering the exact injury the ordinance was designed to prevent. Builder violated the ordinance by leaving only one orange cone rather than a four-foot barrier and warning lights, and no facts suggest impossibility, emergency, or any other valid excuse. Even if a jurisdiction treats a municipal ordinance only as evidence of negligence rather than negligence per se, leaving an unlit six-foot trench three feet from a public sidewalk in the dark with a single cone falls far below ordinary reasonable care.
Conclusion: The undiscovered-trespasser defense fails under the traveler-deviation doctrine, and Builder owed and breached a duty of care under negligence per se (and ordinary care).
2. Actual and Proximate Causation (Including Enhanced-Injury Apportionment)
Issue: Is Builder's negligence both the actual and proximate cause of Walker's broken leg and fractured collarbone, and how is liability apportioned with the negligent ambulance driver?
Rule: Actual cause is satisfied if the plaintiff's injury would not have occurred "but for" the defendant's negligent conduct. Proximate (legal) cause limits liability to harms that are a foreseeable consequence of the risk that made the conduct negligent. An intervening act that occurs after the defendant's breach does not break the chain of proximate causation if the intervening act is a normal, foreseeable response to the situation created by the defendant. Under general tort law, ordinary negligence by medical personnel or emergency transporters rendering aid necessitated by the original injury is foreseeable as a matter of law and is not a superseding cause; only extraordinary, unforeseeable, or intentional/reckless misconduct breaks the causal chain. Where a subsequent tortfeasor negligently causes a distinct additional injury during medical transport, liability is divisible as to the initial injury (for which only the original tortfeasor—and any vicariously liable hirer—is liable) and joint and several as to the enhanced subsequent injury.
Application: But for Builder's failure to erect the barrier and warning lights, Walker would not have fallen into the trench, broken a leg, or needed emergency ambulance transport to the hospital. Actual causation is met for both injuries. As to proximate cause, the broken leg is the direct, foreseeable result of leaving an unguarded trench beside a sidewalk. For the fractured collarbone, the ambulance driver's failure to notice a stop sign in heavy rain constitutes ordinary negligence during emergency transport necessitated by Walker's fall. Because ordinary negligence in emergency transportation is a foreseeable dependent intervening cause, it does not supersede Builder's liability. As between Builder/Owner and the ambulance driver, the leg fracture and collarbone fracture are divisible injuries: only Builder and Owner are liable for the initial broken leg, whereas Builder, Owner, and the ambulance driver are jointly and severally liable for the enhanced collarbone fracture (and Builder or Owner may seek contribution from the ambulance driver for the collarbone injury).
Conclusion: Builder's negligence is the actual and proximate cause of both Walker's broken leg and the fractured collarbone, with joint and several liability alongside the ambulance driver solely as to the enhanced collarbone injury.
3. Walker's Claim Against Owner (Independent Contractor, Nondelegable Duty & Indemnity)
Issue: Is Owner directly or vicariously liable for Builder's negligent excavation work, and what recovery rights exist between Owner and Builder?
Rule: A hirer is generally not vicariously liable for the torts of an independent contractor over whom the hirer retains no control regarding the manner and means of the work. Nor is a hirer directly liable absent negligent selection, negligent supervision, or retained control. However, an important exception imposes vicarious liability when the hirer owes a nondelegable duty. A duty is nondelegable when a safety statute or ordinance requires specific precautions for public protection, or when work conducted immediately adjacent to a public thoroughfare creates a peculiar risk of physical harm to pedestrians unless special precautions are taken. As noted above, the traveler-deviation doctrine overcomes any undiscovered-trespasser defense when a landowner maintains an unguarded pitfall right beside a public sidewalk where a traveler may inadvertently stray. Under joint and several liability, a plaintiff may collect the full award from either the vicariously liable hirer or the negligent contractor, and a hirer held solely vicariously liable without personal fault is entitled to 100% indemnity from the negligent contractor.
Application: Builder operated an independent business with Builder's own crew and tools, and Owner exercised no control over the work, so Builder is an independent contractor. Owner is not directly negligent because Owner was out of town, had no notice of the unlit trench, and had no reason to doubt Builder's competence when hiring. Owner's threshold defense that Walker was an undiscovered trespasser fails under the traveler-deviation rule because the trench was dug three feet from the public sidewalk. Moreover, excavating a six-foot trench three feet from a public sidewalk triggered both a statutory safety duty under the Linden ordinance and a peculiar risk to sidewalk users. Because that safety duty is nondelegable, Owner cannot shift responsibility to Builder for the failure to place barriers and warning lights. Owner and Builder are jointly and severally liable to Walker for both the broken leg and the collarbone fracture, but because Owner is blameless and held solely vicariously liable, Owner is entitled to full indemnity from Builder.
Conclusion: Although Owner is not directly negligent, Owner is vicariously liable—jointly and severally with Builder—for both the broken leg and the collarbone fracture under the nondelegable duty doctrine, and Owner is entitled to 100% indemnity from Builder.
4. Defenses: Comparative Negligence and Assumption of Risk
Issue: May Builder and Owner reduce or bar Walker's recovery based on Walker glancing at a paper map and stepping off the sidewalk?
Rule: A plaintiff must exercise reasonable care for self-protection. Under pure comparative negligence, a plaintiff's recovery is reduced by the plaintiff's percentage of fault. Under modified comparative negligence (the majority US approach), recovery is reduced by the plaintiff's fault percentage unless the plaintiff's fault reaches or exceeds 50% (or 51%, depending on the jurisdiction), in which case recovery is barred. (In the small minority of jurisdictions retaining traditional contributory negligence, any fault by the plaintiff bars recovery unless the defendant's conduct was willful or reckless.) Implied assumption of risk requires proof that the plaintiff actually knew of and appreciated the specific risk and voluntarily chose to encounter it.
Application: Glancing down at a map while walking in the dark and stepping onto the grass beside the sidewalk could be found by a factfinder to be a minor breach of Walker's duty to watch where Walker was going. Because leaving a six-foot unlit, unbarriered trench beside a sidewalk is far more culpable than momentarily looking at a map, a jury would likely assign Walker a modest percentage of fault—below 50%—reducing Walker's damages proportionally under both pure and modified comparative negligence without barring recovery. Implied assumption of risk fails completely because Walker did not know the hidden trench was there in the dark and did not voluntarily encounter it.
Conclusion: Assumption of risk does not apply, and Walker's damages will likely be reduced—not barred—by Walker's comparative fault in most jurisdictions (though traditional contributory negligence would bar recovery unless Builder's conduct is deemed reckless).
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Builder's Duty, Premises Defense & Negligence Per Se (6 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies the elements of negligence and that Builder owed a duty of care to foreseeable pedestrians near the sidewalk.
- 1 pt Raises the threshold undiscovered-trespasser defense (shared by Builder while working on Owner's land) and rejects it under the traveler-deviation doctrine for pitfalls immediately beside a public sidewalk.
- 1 pt States the negligence per se test (protected class + protected type of harm, with no excuse).
- 1 pt Applies the class and harm elements: Linden ordinance protects pedestrians near public sidewalks from falling into open excavations after dusk.
- 1 pt Notes Builder's unexcused violation (single cone instead of four-foot barrier and warning lights) and briefly notes the minority rule treating ordinance violations as evidence of negligence.
- 1 pt Concludes Builder owed a duty and breached it under negligence per se and ordinary reasonable care.
Issue 2: Actual & Proximate Causation and Apportionment (5 Points)
- 1 pt Correctly applies the "but-for" actual causation test to both the broken leg and the ambulance trip leading to the collarbone fracture.
- 1 pt States the proximate cause rule: foreseeability of harm and dependent intervening causes vs. superseding causes.
- 1 pt Explains the settled rule that ordinary negligence in emergency transport necessitated by the original injury (failing to see a stop sign in heavy rain) is foreseeable as a matter of law.
- 1 pt Addresses divisible vs. enhanced-injury apportionment: only Builder/Owner are liable for the initial broken leg, whereas Builder, Owner, and the ambulance driver are jointly and severally liable for the enhanced collarbone fracture.
- 1 pt Concludes Builder is the actual and proximate cause of both the leg and collarbone injuries.
Issue 3: Owner's Liability, Nondelegable Duty & Indemnity (5 Points)
- 1 pt Classifies Builder as an independent contractor and rules out direct negligence (Owner was away and had no notice of incompetence or the hazard).
- 1 pt Addresses Owner's undiscovered-trespasser defense and explains why the traveler-deviation doctrine defeats it on these sidewalk-adjacent facts.
- 1 pt Identifies the nondelegable duty exception for statutory safety precautions and peculiar risks adjacent to a public sidewalk.
- 1 pt Concludes Owner is vicariously liable—jointly and severally with Builder—for both injuries.
- 1 pt Explains that because Owner is solely vicariously liable without personal fault, Owner is entitled to 100% indemnity from Builder.
Issue 4: Affirmative Defenses (4 Points)
- 1 pt Evaluates Walker's conduct (glancing at a map in the dark and stepping onto the grass) as potential breach of self-care.
- 1 pt Distinguishes pure comparative negligence (proportional reduction) from modified comparative negligence (50%/51% bar) and notes traditional contributory negligence.
- 1 pt Explains why Walker's fault is likely minor relative to an unlit, unbarriered six-foot trench, reducing rather than barring recovery under comparative fault.
- 1 pt Rejects implied assumption of risk because Walker lacked actual knowledge of the hidden dark trench.