Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

Sibling 1 and Sibling 2 purchased a two-unit residential duplex in the town of Oakridge under a deed granting the property to them "as joint tenants with right of survivorship." The jurisdiction follows the lien theory of mortgages. Sibling 1 managed the building and leased Unit A to Tenant under a valid written two-year residential lease at $1,200 per month. The lease contained no restriction on assignments or subleases.

Six months into the lease, Sibling 1 borrowed $80,000 from Lender and executed a valid mortgage on Sibling 1's undivided half-interest in the duplex without telling Sibling 2. Two months later, Sibling 1 died, leaving a valid will devising "all of my real property to Friend."

Shortly thereafter, Unit A's furnace failed during freezing winter weather, leaving the apartment at 45 degrees Fahrenheit for three weeks. Tenant promptly notified Sibling 2—who had taken over management—in writing, but Sibling 2 took no action to repair the furnace. Tenant stayed inside Unit A for two weeks wearing heavy coats and withheld $600 of that month's rent.

At the end of those two weeks, without giving Sibling 2 any notice of vacating, Tenant signed a written agreement transferring "all of Tenant's remaining lease term in Unit A to Assignee," who moved in immediately. Assignee paid two months of $1,200 rent to Sibling 2, then abandoned Unit A with nine months left on the lease and stopped paying. Sibling 2 left Unit A vacant for all nine remaining months without advertising or showing the unit—even though comparable apartments in Oakridge rented within two weeks—and has now sued both Tenant and Assignee for all nine months of unpaid rent plus the $600 Tenant withheld.

Call of the Question

Under general United States real property law: (1) Who owns the duplex after Sibling 1's death, and does Lender's mortgage still encumber the property? (2) Was Tenant entitled to withhold $600 in rent or treat the lease as terminated based on the broken furnace? (3) What are Sibling 2's rights against Tenant and Assignee for the nine months of unpaid rent, and how does Sibling 2's failure to re-let affect recovery?