Fact Pattern
Sibling 1 and Sibling 2 purchased a two-unit residential duplex in the town of Oakridge under a deed granting the property to them "as joint tenants with right of survivorship." The jurisdiction follows the lien theory of mortgages. Sibling 1 managed the building and leased Unit A to Tenant under a valid written two-year residential lease at $1,200 per month. The lease contained no restriction on assignments or subleases.
Six months into the lease, Sibling 1 borrowed $80,000 from Lender and executed a valid mortgage on Sibling 1's undivided half-interest in the duplex without telling Sibling 2. Two months later, Sibling 1 died, leaving a valid will devising "all of my real property to Friend."
Shortly thereafter, Unit A's furnace failed during freezing winter weather, leaving the apartment at 45 degrees Fahrenheit for three weeks. Tenant promptly notified Sibling 2—who had taken over management—in writing, but Sibling 2 took no action to repair the furnace. Tenant stayed inside Unit A for two weeks wearing heavy coats and withheld $600 of that month's rent.
At the end of those two weeks, without giving Sibling 2 any notice of vacating, Tenant signed a written agreement transferring "all of Tenant's remaining lease term in Unit A to Assignee," who moved in immediately. Assignee paid two months of $1,200 rent to Sibling 2, then abandoned Unit A with nine months left on the lease and stopped paying. Sibling 2 left Unit A vacant for all nine remaining months without advertising or showing the unit—even though comparable apartments in Oakridge rented within two weeks—and has now sued both Tenant and Assignee for all nine months of unpaid rent plus the $600 Tenant withheld.
Call of the Question
Under general United States real property law: (1) Who owns the duplex after Sibling 1's death, and does Lender's mortgage still encumber the property? (2) Was Tenant entitled to withhold $600 in rent or treat the lease as terminated based on the broken furnace? (3) What are Sibling 2's rights against Tenant and Assignee for the nine months of unpaid rent, and how does Sibling 2's failure to re-let affect recovery?
Model Answer (IRAC)
1. Joint Tenancy Severance, Survivorship, and Lender's Mortgage
Issue: Did Sibling 1's mortgage sever the joint tenancy, does Friend take any interest under Sibling 1's will, and does Lender's mortgage survive Sibling 1's death?
Rule: A joint tenancy carries a right of survivorship that automatically transfers a deceased joint tenant's interest to the surviving joint tenant(s) at the moment of death, leaving nothing to pass by will. An inter vivos conveyance by one joint tenant severs the joint tenancy as to that share and creates a tenancy in common. Under the majority lien theory of mortgages, a mortgage given by one joint tenant creates only a lien—not a transfer of title—so it does not sever the joint tenancy; when the mortgaging joint tenant dies first, the deceased tenant's interest evaporates and the surviving joint tenant takes the whole property free of the mortgage. (By contrast, in a minority title-theory jurisdiction, a mortgage conveys legal title, severs the joint tenancy into a tenancy in common, and keeps the mortgage attached to the debtor's half-share.)
Application: Sibling 1 and Sibling 2 held the Oakridge duplex as joint tenants with right of survivorship. Because this jurisdiction follows the lien theory, Sibling 1's $80,000 mortgage to Lender created only a security lien on Sibling 1's half-interest and did not break the four unities or sever the joint tenancy. Upon Sibling 1's death, the right of survivorship operated instantaneously, vesting 100% ownership in Sibling 2 and extinguishing Sibling 1's interest—together with Lender's mortgage lien on that interest. Because survivorship takes effect at death before a will operates, Sibling 1's will passes nothing to Friend.
Conclusion: Sibling 2 is the sole owner of the duplex free of Lender's mortgage (and Friend takes nothing), though in a minority title-theory state Sibling 2 and Friend would be tenants in common with Lender's mortgage encumbering Friend's half.
2. Implied Warranty of Habitability vs. Constructive Eviction ($600 Withholding)
Issue: May Tenant justify withholding $600 of rent under the implied warranty of habitability or constructive eviction while remaining in Unit A for two weeks?
Rule: Constructive eviction requires (1) substantial interference caused by the landlord's breach of a duty, (2) notice to the landlord and a reasonable opportunity to cure, and (3) the tenant actually vacating within a reasonable time. A tenant who stays in possession cannot claim constructive eviction. In residential leases, however, the non-waivable implied warranty of habitability requires the landlord to maintain basic living conditions such as adequate winter heat. Upon a material breach after notice and failure to cure, a residential tenant may remain in possession and withhold or abate rent down to the unit's fair rental value in its defective condition.
Application: Unit A was a residential apartment lacking heat in freezing winter weather (45 degrees), which is a severe breach of basic habitability standards. Tenant gave Sibling 2 prompt written notice, and Sibling 2 failed to fix the furnace for three weeks. Tenant cannot rely on constructive eviction for the two weeks Tenant stayed in Unit A wearing coats (and later assigned the lease rather than surrendering the unit to the landlord). Under the implied warranty of habitability, however, Tenant was entitled to remain in possession and claim rent abatement (offset) reflecting the reduced fair rental value of an unheated apartment—so reducing the month's rent by $600 for the two weeks Tenant occupied the unheated unit during the three-week outage is permissible as an abatement offset if proportionate to the diminished value (though Tenant bears the burden of proving the reasonable abatement amount when sued post-assignment, rather than withholding prospectively while awaiting repair).
Conclusion: Constructive eviction does not excuse the $600 rent reduction because Tenant stayed and assigned rather than vacating/terminating, but the implied warranty of habitability justifies Tenant's rent abatement (offset) up to the reduction in fair rental value for the two-week period Tenant held the unit.
3. Assignment Liability: Tenant (Privity of Contract) and Assignee (Privity of Estate)
Issue: Are Tenant and Assignee liable to Sibling 2 under the lease transfer?
Rule: An assignment occurs when a tenant transfers the entire remaining term of the lease; a sublease occurs when the tenant retains any portion of the term. In an assignment (permitted freely when the lease contains no restriction), the assignee enters into privity of estate with the landlord and becomes directly liable for rent and all covenants running with the land until the assignee further reassigns the lease—merely abandoning the premises without reassigning does not end privity of estate. Meanwhile, the original tenant remains liable in privity of contract for the entire lease term unless the landlord grants a novation.
Application: Because the lease contained no anti-assignment clause and Tenant transferred "all of Tenant's remaining lease term" to Assignee, the transfer was a valid assignment. Assignee entered privity of estate with Sibling 2 and paid two months of rent. When Assignee walked out with nine months left without reassigning the lease to anyone else, Assignee's privity of estate remained intact, leaving Assignee personally liable for the remaining lease obligations (subject to mitigation below). Likewise, Tenant never received a novation from Sibling 2, so Tenant remains secondarily liable in privity of contract for unpaid rent.
Conclusion: Both Assignee (via privity of estate) and Tenant (via privity of contract) remain liable for recoverable post-abandonment rent, subject to Sibling 2's duty to mitigate.
4. Abandonment and Landlord's Duty to Mitigate Damages
Issue: Can Sibling 2 recover all nine months of post-abandonment rent after making no effort to re-let Unit A?
Rule: Under the modern majority rule for residential leases, when a tenant (or assignee) unjustifiably abandons the premises before the lease expires, the landlord has an affirmative duty to take reasonable steps to mitigate damages by making ordinary efforts (such as advertising and showing the unit) to find a replacement tenant. Failure to make reasonable mitigation efforts bars the landlord from recovering rent that could reasonably have been avoided. (Under the traditional minority common-law rule, a landlord had no duty to mitigate and could leave the unit vacant and sue for full rent as it fell due.)
Application: Assignee unjustifiably abandoned Unit A with nine months left. Rather than advertising or showing the apartment, Sibling 2 left Unit A completely empty for nine months, even though comparable units in Oakridge rented within two weeks. Under the majority rule, Sibling 2 breached the duty to mitigate damages. Had Sibling 2 acted reasonably, Unit A would likely have been re-let within roughly two weeks to one month at the same market rent, avoiding eight months of vacancy loss.
Conclusion: Under the majority rule, Sibling 2's failure to mitigate bars recovery of the avoidable rent—limiting Sibling 2 to roughly two weeks to one month of lost rent (not all nine months) from Assignee and Tenant, whereas under the minority rule Sibling 2 could recover all nine months.
Points-Based Grading Guide
Total Possible: 20 Points
Issue 1: Joint Tenancy Severance & Mortgage Survival (5 Points)
- 1 pt Identifies the joint tenancy with right of survivorship and explains that a will cannot devise a joint-tenancy share (Friend takes nothing).
- 1 pt States the majority lien-theory rule: a mortgage creates only a lien and does not sever a joint tenancy.
- 1 pt Concludes that upon Sibling 1's death, Sibling 2 takes 100% by survivorship free of Lender's mortgage.
- 1 pt Notes the minority title-theory split (mortgage severs into a tenancy in common, leaving the half-interest encumbered).
- 1 pt Reaches a clear ownership and lien conclusion.
Issue 2: Habitability vs. Constructive Eviction (5 Points)
- 1 pt States the elements of constructive eviction (substantial interference, notice/opportunity to cure, prompt vacating).
- 1 pt Rejects constructive eviction for the $600 withholding because Tenant stayed in possession and later assigned rather than vacating to terminate.
- 1 pt Identifies the non-waivable residential implied warranty of habitability and applies it to the 45-degree furnace failure after written notice.
- 1 pt Explains that habitability lets a residential tenant remain in possession and abate/withhold rent to fair defective value.
- 1 pt Concludes Tenant's $600 rent abatement (offset) is justified to the extent it reflects the reduced fair rental value during the two-week period Tenant occupied the unheated unit.
Issue 3: Lease Assignment Liability (5 Points)
- 1 pt Classifies the transfer of the entire remaining term as a valid assignment (no lease restriction).
- 1 pt Explains that Assignee is in privity of estate with Sibling 2 and remains liable after abandoning because Assignee never reassigned.
- 1 pt Explains that Tenant remains liable in privity of contract absent a novation.
- 1 pt Notes that Assignee's and Tenant's obligation is joint/concurrent for recoverable rent (Sibling 2 gets one satisfaction).
- 1 pt Concludes both Assignee and Tenant are proper defendants for any unmitigated post-abandonment rent.
Issue 4: Abandonment & Duty to Mitigate (5 Points)
- 1 pt States the modern majority rule requiring residential landlords to make reasonable efforts to mitigate damages after abandonment.
- 1 pt Notes the traditional minority common-law rule allowing landlords to leave premises vacant and collect full rent.
- 1 pt Applies the facts: Sibling 2 did not advertise or show Unit A for nine months despite two-week local market demand.
- 1 pt Explains that Sibling 2 can recover only unavoidable rent (roughly two weeks to one month) plus reasonable re-letting costs, not nine months.
- 1 pt Reaches a clear damages conclusion.