Written for study. Not legal advice.

Fact Pattern

The City of Oakridge owns Oakridge Commons, a central public square surrounded by city sidewalks that has long been open for civic gatherings, concerts, and rallies. Oakridge's City Council enacted an ordinance requiring a city permit for any rally of ten or more persons in Oakridge Commons. Under the ordinance, Mayor may deny a permit whenever Mayor determines that the applicant's message "offends community values or is likely to provoke hostile spectators." The ordinance also requires applicants to pay a security fee ranging from $100 to $5,000, set by Mayor according to the anticipated hostility of counter-protesters.

Resident is a lawfully admitted permanent noncitizen who has lived in Oakridge for six years and operated a licensed food cart near Oakridge Commons under a two-year municipal vending license. Oakridge's municipal code expressly provides that a vending license "shall not be revoked during its two-year term except for good cause." Resident applied for a Saturday permit to hold a peaceful rally in Oakridge Commons criticizing Oakridge's property tax increases. Mayor denied the permit in writing, stating that Resident's anti-tax message "offends community values and may draw angry counter-protesters."

The next morning, Oakridge's City Council enforced a newly enacted municipal rule restricting all street-vending licenses solely to United States citizens, citing a desire to reserve municipal sidewalk commerce for citizens. Without giving Resident advance notice or any pre-revocation or post-revocation hearing, Mayor issued an order immediately revoking Resident's remaining one-year food-cart license because Resident is not a citizen.

Separately, Oakridge launched a Playground Safety Grant program offering matching funds to any local nonprofit organization that maintains a publicly accessible youth playground. Civic Chapel, a neighborhood church that operates a community playground open to all Oakridge children without religious instruction, applied and met every safety criterion. Oakridge denied Civic Chapel's application solely because Oakridge's city charter prohibits municipal grants to any religious organization.

Call of the Question

Under general United States constitutional law, what federal constitutional claims may Resident and Civic Chapel reasonably assert against the City of Oakridge, and what are the likely outcomes?